|
|
| (9 intermediate revisions by 2 users not shown) |
| Line 1: |
Line 1: |
| ==Part II: On the Man Called Christ== | | {{header |
| | |title = [[The Everlasting Man]] |
| | |author = Gilbert Keith Chesterton |
| | |section = Conclusion and Appendices |
| | |previous = [[../Part II, 6|VI. The Five Deaths of the Faith]] |
| | |next = |
| | |notes = |
| | }} |
|
| |
|
| ====I. The God in the Cave====
| | __TOC__ |
| This sketch of the human story began in a cave; the cave which popular
| | ==Conclusion: The Summary Of This Book== |
| science associates with the cave-man and in which practical discovery has
| |
| really found archaic drawings of animals. The second half of human history,
| |
| which was like a new creation of the world, also begins in a cave. There is
| |
| even a shadow of such a fancy in the fact that animals were again present; for
| |
| it was a cave used as a stable by the mountaineers of the uplands about
| |
| Bethlehem; who still drive their cattle into such holes and caverns at night. It
| |
| was here that a homeless couple had crept underground with the cattle when
| |
| the doors of the crowded caravanserai had been shut in their faces; and it was
| |
| here beneath the very feet of the passers-by, in a cellar under the very floor of
| |
| the world, that Jesus Christ was born. But in that second creation there was
| |
| indeed something symbolical in the roots of the primeval rock or the horns of
| |
| the prehistoric herd. God also was a Cave-Man, and had also traced strange
| |
| shapes of creatures, curiously coloured, upon the wall of the world; but the
| |
| pictures that he made had come to life.
| |
| | |
| A mass of legend and literature, which increases and will never end, has
| |
| repeated and rung the changes on that single paradox; that the hands that had
| |
| made the sun and stars were too small to reach the huge heads of the cattle.
| |
| Upon this paradox, we might almost say upon this jest, all the literature of our
| |
| faith is founded. It is at least like a jest in this, that it is something which the
| |
| scientific critic cannot see. He laboriously explains the difficulty which we
| |
| have always defiantly and almost derisively exaggerated; and mildly
| |
| condemns as improbable something that we have almost madly exalted as
| |
| incredible; as something that would be much too good to be true, except that it
| |
| is true. When that contrast between the cosmic creation and the little local
| |
| infancy has been repeated, reiterated, underlined, emphasised, exulted in,
| |
| sung, shouted, roared, not to say howled, in a hundred thousand hymns, carols,
| |
| rhymes, rituals, pictures, poems, and popular sermons, it may be suggested
| |
| that we hardly need a higher critic to draw our attention to something a little
| |
| odd about it; especially one of the sort that seems to take a long time to see a
| |
| joke, even his own joke. But about this contrast and combination of ideas one
| |
| thing may be said here, because it is relevant to the whole thesis of this book.
| |
| The sort of modern critic of whom I speak is generally much impressed with
| |
| the importance of education in life and the importance of psychology in
| |
| education. That sort of man is never tired of telling us that first impressions fix
| |
| character by the law of causation; and he will become quite nervous if a child's
| |
| visual sense is poisoned by the wrong colours on a golliwog or his nervous
| |
| system prematurely shaken by a cacophonous rattle. Yet he will think us very
| |
| narrow-minded, if we say that this is exactly why there really is a difference
| |
| between being brought up as a Christian and being brought up as a Jew or a
| |
| Moslem or an atheist. The difference is that every Catholic child has learned
| |
| from pictures, and even every Protestant child from stories, this incredible
| |
| combination of contrasted ideas as one of the very first impressions on his
| |
| mind. It is not merely a theological difference. It is a psychological difference
| |
| which can outlast any theologies. It really is, as that sort of scientist loves to
| |
| say about anything, incurable. Any agnostic or atheist whose childhood has
| |
| known a real Christmas has ever afterwards, whether he likes it or not, an
| |
| association in his mind between two ideas that most of mankind must regard
| |
| as remote from each other; the idea of a baby and the idea of unknown
| |
| strength that sustains the stars. His instincts and imagination can still connect
| |
| them, when his reason can no longer see the need of the connection; for him
| |
| there will always be some savour of religion about the mere picture of a
| |
| mother and a baby; some hint of mercy and softening about the mere mention
| |
| of the dreadful name of God. But the two ideas are not naturally or necessarily
| |
| combined. They would not be necessarily combined for an ancient Greek or a
| |
| Chinaman, even for Aristotle or Confucius. It is no more inevitable to connect
| |
| God with an infant than to connect gravitation with a kitten. It has been
| |
| created in our minds by Christmas because we are Christians, because we are
| |
| psychological Christians even when we are not theological ones. In other
| |
| words, this combination of ideas has emphatically, in the much disputed
| |
| phrase, altered human nature. There is really a difference between the man
| |
| who knows it and the man who does not. It may not be a difference of moral
| |
| worth, for the Moslem or the Jew might be worthier according to his lights;
| |
| but it is a plain fact about the crossing of two particular lights, the conjunction
| |
| of two stars in our particular horoscope. Omnipotence and impotence, or
| |
| divinity and infancy, do definitely make a sort of epigram which a million
| |
| repetitions cannot turn into a platitude. It is not unreasonable to call it unique.
| |
| Bethlehem is emphatically a place where extremes meet.
| |
| | |
| Here begins, it is needless to say, another mighty influence for the
| |
| humanisation of Christendom. If the world wanted what is called a noncontroversial
| |
| aspect of Christianity, it would probably select Christmas. Yet it
| |
| is obviously bound up with what is supposed to be a controversial aspect (I
| |
| could never at any stage of my opinions imagine why); the respect paid to the
| |
| Blessed Virgin. When I was a boy a more Puritan generation objected to a
| |
| statue upon my parish church representing the Virgin and Child. After much
| |
| controversy, they compromised by taking away the Child. One would think
| |
| that this was even more corrupted with Mariolatry, unless the mother was
| |
| counted less dangerous when deprived of a sort of weapon. But the practical
| |
| difficulty is also a parable. You cannot chip away the statue of a mother from
| |
| all round that of a new-born child. You can not suspend the new-born child in
| |
| mid-air; indeed you cannot really have a statue of a new-born child at all.
| |
| Similarly, you cannot suspend the idea of a new-born child in the void or think
| |
| of him without thinking of his mother. You cannot visit the child without
| |
| visiting the mother; you cannot in common human life approach the child
| |
| except through the mother. If we are to think of Christ in this aspect at all, the
| |
| other idea follows as it is followed in history. We must either leave Christ out
| |
| of Christmas, or Christmas out of Christ, or we must admit, if only as we
| |
| admit it in an old picture, that those holy heads are too near together for the
| |
| haloes not to mingle and cross.
| |
| | |
| It might be suggested, in a somewhat violent image, that nothing had happened
| |
| in that fold or crack in the great grey hills except that the whole universe had
| |
| been turned inside out. I mean that all the eyes of wonder and worship which
| |
| had been turned outwards to the largest thing were now turned inward to the
| |
| smallest. The very image will suggest all that multitudinous marvel of
| |
| converging eyes that makes so much of the coloured Catholic imagery like a
| |
| peacock's tail. But it is true in a sense that God who had been only a
| |
| circumference was seen as a centre; and a centre is infinitely small. It is true
| |
| that the spiritual spiral henceforward works inwards instead of outwards, and
| |
| in that sense is centripetal and not centrifugal. The faith becomes, in more
| |
| ways than one, a religion of little things. But its traditions in art and literature
| |
| and popular fable have quite sufficiently attested, as has been said, this
| |
| particular paradox of the divine being in the cradle. Perhaps they have not so
| |
| clearly emphasised the significance of the divine being in the cave. Curiously
| |
| enough, indeed, tradition has not very clearly emphasised the cave. It is a
| |
| familiar fact that the Bethlehem scene has been represented in every possible
| |
| setting of time and country, of landscape and architecture; and it is a wholly
| |
| happy and admirable fact that men have conceived it as quite different
| |
| according to their different individual traditions and tastes. But while all have
| |
| realised that it was a stable, not so many have realised that it was a cave. Some
| |
| critics have even been so silly as to suppose that there was some contradiction
| |
| between the stable and the cave; in which case they cannot know much about
| |
| caves or stables in Palestine. As they see differences that are not there, it is
| |
| needless to add that they do not see differences that are there. When a wellknown
| |
| critic says, for instance, that Christ being born in a rocky cavern is like
| |
| Mithras having sprung alive out of a rock, it sounds like a parody upon
| |
| comparative religion. There is such a thing as the point of a story, even if it is
| |
| a story in the sense of a lie. And the notion of a hero appearing, like Pallas
| |
| from the brain of Zeus, mature and without a mother, is obviously the very
| |
| opposite of the idea of a god being born like an ordinary baby and entirely
| |
| dependent on a mother. Whichever ideal we might prefer, we should surely see
| |
| that they are contrary ideals. It is as stupid to connect them because they both
| |
| contain a substance called stone as to identify the punishment of the Deluge
| |
| with the baptism in the Jordan because they both contain a substance called
| |
| water. Whether as a myth or a mystery, Christ was obviously conceived as
| |
| born in a hole in the rocks primarily because it marked the position of one
| |
| outcast and homeless. Nevertheless it is true, as I have said, that the cave has
| |
| not been so commonly or so clearly used as a symbol as the other realities that
| |
| surrounded the first Christmas.
| |
| | |
| And the reason for this also refers to the very nature of that new world. It was
| |
| in a sense the difficulty of a new dimension. Christ was not only born on the
| |
| level of the world, but even lower than the world. The first act of the divine
| |
| drama was enacted, not only on no stage set up above the sight-seer, but on a
| |
| dark and curtained stage sunken out of sight; and that is an idea very difficult
| |
| to express in most modes of artistic expression. It is the idea of simultaneous
| |
| happenings on different levels of life. Something like it might have been
| |
| attempted in the more archaic and decorative medieval art. But the more the
| |
| artists learned of realism and perspective, the less they could depict at once the
| |
| angels in the heavens and the shepherds on the hills, and the glory in the
| |
| darkness that was under the hills. Perhaps it could have been best conveyed by
| |
| the characteristic expedient of some of the medieval guilds, when they
| |
| wheeled about the streets a theatre with three stages one above the other, with
| |
| heaven above the earth and hell under the earth. But in the riddle of Bethlehem
| |
| it was heaven that was under the earth.
| |
| | |
| There is in that alone the touch of a revolution, as of the world turned upside
| |
| down. It would be vain to attempt to say anything adequate, or anything new,
| |
| about the change which this conception of a deity born like an outcast or even
| |
| an outlaw had upon the whole conception of law and its duties to the poor and
| |
| outcast. It is profoundly true to say that after that moment there could be no
| |
| slaves. There could be and were people bearing that legal title, until the
| |
| Church was strong enough to weed them out, but there could be no more of the
| |
| pagan repose in the mere advantage to the state of keeping it a servile state.
| |
| Individuals became important, in a sense in which no instruments can be
| |
| important. A man could not be a means to an end, at any rate to any other
| |
| man's end. All this popular and fraternal element in the story has been rightly
| |
| attached by tradition to the episode of the Shepherds; the hinds who found
| |
| themselves talking face to face with the princes of heaven. But there is another
| |
| aspect of the popular element as represented by the shepherds which has not
| |
| perhaps been so fully developed; and which is more directly relevant here.
| |
| Men of the people, like the shepherds, men of the popular tradition, had
| |
| everywhere been the makers of the mythologies. It was they who had felt most
| |
| directly, with least check or chill from philosophy or the corrupt cults of
| |
| civilisation, the need we have already considered; the images that were
| |
| adventures of the imagination; the mythology that was a sort of search; the
| |
| tempting and tantalising hints of something half-human in nature; the dumb
| |
| significance of seasons and special places. They had best understood that the
| |
| soul of a landscape is a story and the soul of a story is a personality. But
| |
| rationalism had already begun to rot away these really irrational though
| |
| imaginative treasures of the peasant; even as systematic slavery had eaten the
| |
| peasant out of house and home. Upon all such peasantries everywhere there
| |
| was descending a dusk and twilight of disappointment, in the hour when these
| |
| few men discovered what they sought. Everywhere else Arcadia was fading
| |
| from the forest. Pan was dead and the shepherds were scattered like sheep.
| |
| And though no man knew it, the hour was near which was to end and to fulfil
| |
| all things; and though no man heard it, there was one far-off cry in an
| |
| unknown tongue upon the heaving wilderness of the mountains. The shepherds
| |
| had found their Shepherd.
| |
| | |
| And the thing they found was of a kind with the things they sought. The
| |
| populace had been wrong in many things; but they had not been wrong in
| |
| believing that holy things could have a habitation and that divinity need not
| |
| disdain the limits of time and space. And the barbarian who conceived the
| |
| crudest fancy about the sun being stolen and hidden in a box, or the wildest
| |
| myth about the god being rescued and his enemy deceived with a stone, was
| |
| nearer to the secret of the cave and knew more about the crisis of the world,
| |
| than all those in the circle of cities round the Mediterranean who had become
| |
| content with cold abstractions or cosmopolitan generalisations; than all those
| |
| who were spinning thinner and thinner threads of thought out of the
| |
| transcendentalism of Plato or the orientalism of Pythagoras. The place that the
| |
| shepherds found was not an academy or an abstract republic, it was not a place
| |
| of myths allegorised or dissected or explained or explained away. It was a
| |
| place of dreams come true. Since that hour no mythologies have been made in
| |
| the world. Mythology is a search.
| |
| | |
| We all know that the popular presentation of this popular story, in so many
| |
| miracle plays and carols, has given to the shepherds the costumes, the
| |
| language, and the landscape of the separate English and European
| |
| countrysides. We all know that one shepherd will talk in a Somerset dialect or
| |
| another talk of driving his sheep from Conway towards Clyde. Most of us
| |
| know by this time how true is that error, how wise, how artistic, how intensely
| |
| Christian and Catholic is that anachronism. But some who have seen it in these
| |
| scenes of medieval rusticity have perhaps not seen it in another sort of poetry,
| |
| which it is sometimes the fashion to call artificial rather than artistic. I fear that
| |
| many modern critics will see only a faded classicism in the fact that men like
| |
| Crashaw and Herrick conceived the shepherds of Bethlehem under the form of
| |
| the shepherds of Virgil. Yet they were profoundly right; and in turning their
| |
| Bethlehem play into a Latin Eclogue they took up one of the most important
| |
| links in human history. Virgil, as we have already seen, does stand for all that
| |
| saner heathenism that had over-thrown the insane heathenism of human
| |
| sacrifice; but the very fact that even the Virgilian virtues and the sane
| |
| heathenism were in incurable decay is the whole problem to which the
| |
| revelation to the shepherds is the solution. If the world had ever had the
| |
| chance to grow weary of being demoniac, it might have been healed merely by
| |
| becoming sane. But if it had grown weary even of being sane, what was to
| |
| happen, except what did happen? Nor is it false to conceive the Arcadian
| |
| shepherd of the Eclogues as rejoicing in what did happen. One of the Eclogues
| |
| has even been claimed as a prophecy of what did happen. But it is quite as
| |
| much in the tone and incidental diction of the great poet that we feel the
| |
| potential sympathy with the great event; and even in their own human phrases
| |
| the voices of the Virgilian shepherds might more than once have broken upon
| |
| more than the tenderness of Italy `Incipe, parve puer, risu cognoscere matrem.'
| |
| They might have found in that strange place all that was best in the last
| |
| traditions of the Latins; and something better than a wooden idol standing up
| |
| for ever for the pillar of the human family; a household god. But they and all
| |
| the other mythologists would be justified in rejoicings that the event had
| |
| fulfilled not merely the mysticism but the materialism of mythology.
| |
| Mythology had many sins; but it had not been wrong in being as carnal as the
| |
| Incarnation. But something of the ancient voice that was supposed to have
| |
| rung through the graves, it could cry again, 'We have seen, he hath seen us, a
| |
| visible god.' So the ancient shepherds might have danced, and their feet have
| |
| been beautiful upon the mountains, rejoicing over the philosophers. But the
| |
| philosophers had also heard.
| |
| | |
| It is still a strange story, though an old one, how they came out of orient lands,
| |
| crowned with the majesty of kings and clothed with something of the mystery
| |
| of magicians. That truth that is tradition has wisely remembered them almost
| |
| as unknown quantities, as mysterious as their mysterious and melodious
| |
| names; Melchior, Caspar, Balthazar. But there came with them all that world
| |
| of wisdom that had watched the stars in Chaldea and the sun in Persia; and we
| |
| shall not be wrong if we see in them the same curiosity that moves all the
| |
| sages. They would stand for the same human ideal if their names had really
| |
| been Confucius or Pythagoras or Plato. They were those who sought not tales
| |
| but the truth of things, and since their thirst for truth was itself a thirst for God,
| |
| they also have had their reward. But even in order to understand that reward,
| |
| we must understand that for philosophy as much as mythology, that reward
| |
| was the completion of the incomplete.
| |
| | |
| Such learned men would doubtless have come, as these learned men did come,
| |
| to find themselves confirmed in much that was true in their own traditions and
| |
| right in their own reasoning. Confucius would have found a new foundation
| |
| for the family in the very reversal of the Holy Family; Buddha would have
| |
| looked upon a new renunciation, of stars rather than jewels and divinity than
| |
| royalty. These learned men would still have the right to say, or rather a new
| |
| right to say, that there was truth in their old teaching. But after all these
| |
| learned men would have come to learn. They would have come to complete
| |
| their conceptions with something they had not yet conceived; even to balance
| |
| their imperfect universe with something they might once have contradicted.
| |
| Buddha would have come from his impersonal paradise to worship a person.
| |
| Confucius would have come from his temples of ancestor-worship to worship
| |
| a child.
| |
| | |
| We must grasp from the first this character in the new cosmos; that it was
| |
| larger than the old cosmos. In that sense Christendom is larger than creation;
| |
| as creation had been before Christ. It included things that had not been there; it
| |
| also included the things that had been there. The point happens to be well
| |
| illustrated in this example of Chinese piety, but it would be true of other pagan
| |
| virtues or pagan beliefs. Nobody can doubt that a reasonable respect for
| |
| parents is part of a gospel in which God himself was subject in childhood to
| |
| earthly parents. But the other sense in which the parents were subject to him
| |
| does introduce an idea that is not Confucian. The infant Christ is not like the
| |
| infant Confucius; our mysticism conceives him in an immortal infancy. I do
| |
| not know what Confucius would have done with the Bambino had it come to
| |
| life in his arms as it did in the arms of St. Francis. But this is true in relation to
| |
| all the other religions and philosophies; it is the challenge of the Church. The
| |
| Church contains what the world does not contain. Life itself does not provide
| |
| as she does for all sides of life. That every other single system is narrow and
| |
| insufficient compared to this one; that is not a rhetorical boast; it is a real fact
| |
| and a real dilemma. Where is the Holy child amid the Stoics and the ancestorworshippers?
| |
| Where is Our Lady of the Moslems, a woman made for no man
| |
| and set above all angels? Where is St. Michael of the monks of Buddha, rider
| |
| and master of the trumpets, guarding for every soldier the honour of the
| |
| sword? What could St. Thomas Aquinas do with the mythology of
| |
| Brahminism, he who set forth all the science and rationality and even
| |
| rationalism of Christianity? Yet even if we compare Aquinas with Aristotle, at
| |
| the other extreme of reason, we shall find the same sense of something added.
| |
| Aquinas could understand the most logical parts of Aristotle; it is doubtful if
| |
| Aristotle could have understood the most mystical parts of Aquinas. Even
| |
| where we can hardly call the Christian greater, we are forced to call him
| |
| larger. But it is so to whatever philosophy or heresy or modern movement we
| |
| may turn. How would Francis the Troubadour have fared among the
| |
| Calvinists, or for that matter among the Utilitarians of the Manchester School?
| |
| Yet men like Bossuet and Pascal could be as stern and logical as any Calvinist
| |
| or Utilitarian. How would St. Joan of Arc, a woman waving on men to war
| |
| with the sword, have fared among the Quakers or the Doukhabors or the
| |
| Tolstoyan sect of pacifists? Yet any number of Catholic saints have spent their
| |
| lives in preaching peace and preventing wars. It is the same with all the
| |
| modern attempts at Syncretism. They are never able to make something larger
| |
| than the Creed without leaving something out. I do not mean leaving out
| |
| something divine but something human; the flag or the inn or the boy's tale of
| |
| battle or the hedge at the end of the field. The Theosophists build a pantheon;
| |
| but it is only a pantheon for pantheists. They call a Parliament of Religions as
| |
| a reunion of all the peoples; but it is only a reunion of all the prigs. Yet exactly
| |
| such a pantheon had been set up two thousand years before by the shores of
| |
| the Mediterranean; and Christians were invited to set up the image of Jesus
| |
| side by side with the image of Jupiter, of Mithras, of Osiris, of Atys, or of
| |
| Ammon. It was the refusal of the Christians that was the turning-point of
| |
| history. If the Christians had accepted, they and the whole world would have
| |
| certainly, in a grotesque but exact metaphor, gone to pot. They would all have
| |
| been boiled down to one lukewarm liquid in that great pot of cosmopolitan
| |
| corruption in which all the other myths and mysteries were already melting. It
| |
| was an awful and an appalling escape. Nobody understands the nature of the
| |
| Church, or the ringing note of the creed descending from antiquity, who does
| |
| not realise that the whole world once very nearly died of broadmindedness and
| |
| the brotherhood of all religions.
| |
| | |
| Here it is the important point that the Magi, who stand for mysticism and
| |
| philosophy, are truly conceived as seeking something new and even as finding
| |
| something unexpected. That tense sense of crisis which still tingles in the
| |
| Christmas story and even in every Christmas celebration, accentuates the idea
| |
| of a search and a discovery. The discovery is, in this case, truly a scientific
| |
| discovery. For the other mystical figures in the miracle play; for the angel and
| |
| the mother, the shepherds and the soldiers of Herod, there may be aspects both
| |
| simpler and more supernatural, more elemental or more emotional. But the
| |
| wise Men must be seeking wisdom, and for them there must be a light also in
| |
| the intellect. And this is the light; that the Catholic creed is catholic and that
| |
| nothing else is catholic. The philosophy of the Church is universal. The
| |
| philosophy of the philosophers was not universal. Had Plato and Pythagoras
| |
| and Aristotle stood for an instant in the light that came out of that little cave,
| |
| they would have known that their own light was not universal. It is far from
| |
| certain, indeed, that they did not know it already. Philosophy also, like
| |
| mythology, had very much the air of a search. It is the realisation of this truth
| |
| that gives its traditional majesty and mystery to the figures of the Three Kings;
| |
| the discovery that religion is broader than philosophy and that this is the
| |
| broadest of religions, contained within this narrow space. The Magicians were
| |
| gazing at the strange pentacle with the human triangle reversed; and they have
| |
| never come to the end of their calculations about it. For it is the paradox of
| |
| that group in the cave, that while our emotions about it are of childish
| |
| simplicity, our thoughts about it can branch with a never-ending complexity.
| |
| And we can never reach the end even of our own ideas about the child who
| |
| was a father and the mother who was a child.
| |
| | |
| We might well be content to say that mythology had come with the shepherds
| |
| and philosophy with the philosophers; and that it only remained for them to
| |
| combine in the recognisation of religion. But there was a third element that
| |
| must not be ignored and one which that religion for ever refuses to ignore, in
| |
| any revel or reconciliation. There was present in the primary scenes of the
| |
| drama that Enemy that had rotted the legends with lust and frozen theories into
| |
| atheism, but which answered the direct challenge with something of that more
| |
| direct method which we have seen in the conscious cult of the demons. In the
| |
| description of that demon-worship, of the devouring detestation of innocence
| |
| shown in the works of its witchcraft and the most inhuman of its human
| |
| sacrifice, I have said less of its incorrect and secret penetration of the saner
| |
| paganism; the soaking of mythological imagination with sex; the rise of
| |
| imperial pride into insanity. But both the indirect and the direct influence
| |
| make themselves felt in the drama of Bethlehem. A ruler under the Roman
| |
| suzerainty, probably equipped and surrounded with the Roman ornament and
| |
| order though himself of eastern blood, seems in that hour to have felt stirring
| |
| within him the spirit of strange things. We all know the story of how Herod,
| |
| alarmed at some rumour of a mysterious rival, remembered the wild gesture of
| |
| the capricious despots of Asia and ordered a massacre of suspects of the new
| |
| generation of the populace. Everyone knows the story; but not everyone has
| |
| perhaps noted its place in the story of the strange religions of men. Not
| |
| everybody has seen the significance even of its very contrast with the
| |
| Corinthian columns and Roman pavement of that conquered and superficially
| |
| civilised world. Only, as the purpose in his dark spirit began to show and shine
| |
| in the eyes of the Idumean, a seer might perhaps have seen something like a
| |
| great grey ghost that looked over his shoulder; have seen behind him filling
| |
| the dome of night and hovering for the last time over history, that vast and
| |
| fearful face that was Moloch of the Carthaginians; awaiting his last tribute
| |
| from a ruler of the races of Shem. The demons also, in that first festival of
| |
| Christmas, feasted after their own fashion.
| |
| | |
| Unless we understand the presence of that enemy, we shall not only miss the
| |
| point of Christianity, but even miss the point of Christmas. Christmas for us in
| |
| Christendom has become one thing, and in one sense even a simple thing. But
| |
| like all the truths of that tradition, it is in another sense a very complex thing.
| |
| Its unique note is the simultaneous striking of many notes; of humility, of
| |
| gaiety, of gratitude, of mystical fear, but also of vigilance and of drama. It is
| |
| not only an occasion for the peacemakers any more than for the merry-makers;
| |
| it is not only a Hindu peace conference any more than it is only a
| |
| Scandinavian winter feast. There is something defiant in it also; something that
| |
| makes the abrupt bells at midnight sound like the great guns of a battle that has
| |
| just been won. All this indescribable thing that we call the Christmas
| |
| atmosphere only hangs in the air as something like a lingering fragrance or
| |
| fading vapour from the exultant explosion of that one hour in the Judean hills
| |
| nearly two thousand years ago. But the savour is still unmistakable, and it is
| |
| something too subtle or too solitary to be covered by our use of the word
| |
| peace. By the very nature of the story the rejoicings in the cavern were
| |
| rejoicings in a fortress or an outlaw's den; properly understood it is not unduly
| |
| flippant to say they were rejoicings in a dug-out. It is not only true that such a
| |
| subterranean chamber was a hiding-place from enemies; and that the enemies
| |
| were already scouring the stony plain that lay above it like a sky. It is not only
| |
| that the very horse-hoofs of Herod might in that sense have passed like
| |
| thunder over the sunken head of Christ. It is also that there is in that image a
| |
| true idea of an outpost, of a piercing through the rock and an entrance into an
| |
| enemy territory. There is in this buried divinity an idea of undermining the
| |
| world; of shaking the towers and palaces from below; even as Herod the great
| |
| king felt that earthquake under him and swayed with his swaying palace.
| |
| That is perhaps the mightiest of the mysteries of the cave. It is already
| |
| apparent that though men are said to have looked for hell under the earth, in
| |
| this case it is rather heaven that is under the earth. And there follows in this
| |
| strange story the idea of an upheaval of heaven. That is the paradox of the
| |
| whole position; that henceforth the highest thing can only work from below.
| |
| Royalty can only return to its own by a sort of rebellion. Indeed the Church
| |
| from its beginnings, and perhaps especially in its beginnings, was not so much
| |
| a principality as a revolution against the prince of the world. This sense that
| |
| the world had been conquered by the great usurper, and was in his possession,
| |
| has been much deplored or derided by those optimists who identify
| |
| enlightenment with ease. But it was responsible for all that thrill of defiance
| |
| and a beautiful danger that made the good news seem to be really both good
| |
| and new. It was in truth against a huge unconscious usurpation that it raised a
| |
| revolt, and originally so obscure a revolt. Olympus still occupied the sky like a
| |
| motionless cloud moulded into many mighty forms; philosophy still sat in the
| |
| high places and even on the thrones of the kings, when Christ was born in the
| |
| cave and Christianity in the catacombs. In both cases we may remark the same
| |
| paradox of revolution; the sense of something despised and of something
| |
| feared. The cave in one aspect is only a hole or corner into which the outcasts
| |
| are swept like rubbish; yet in the other aspect it is a hiding-place of something
| |
| valuable which the tyrants are seeking like treasure. In one sense they are there
| |
| because the innkeeper would not even remember them, and in another because
| |
| the king can never forget them. We have already noted that this paradox
| |
| appeared also in the treatment of the early Church. It was important while it
| |
| was still insignificant, and certainly while it was still impotent. It was
| |
| important solely because it was intolerable; and in that sense it is true to say
| |
| that it was intolerable because it was intolerant. It was resented, because, in its
| |
| own still and almost secret way, it had declared war. It had risen out of the
| |
| ground to wreck the heaven and earth of heathenism. It did not try to destroy
| |
| all that creation of gold and marble; but it contemplated a world without it. It
| |
| dared to look right through it as though the gold and marble had been glass.
| |
| Those who charged the Christians with burning down Rome with firebrands
| |
| were slanderers; but they were at least far nearer to the nature of Christianity
| |
| than those among the moderns who tell us that the Christians were a sort of
| |
| ethical society, being martyred in a languid fashion for telling men they had a
| |
| duty to their neighbors, and only mildly disliked because they were meek and
| |
| mild.
| |
| | |
| Herod had his place, therefore, in the miracle play of Bethlehem because he is
| |
| the menace to the Church Militant and shows it from the first as under
| |
| persecution and fighting for its life. For those who think this a discord, it is a
| |
| discord that sounds simultaneously with the Christmas bells. For those who
| |
| think the idea of the Crusade is one that spoils the idea of the Cross, we can
| |
| only say that for them the idea of the Cross is spoiled; the idea of the cross is
| |
| spoiled quite literally in the cradle. It is not here to the purpose to argue with
| |
| them on the abstract ethics of fighting; the purpose in this place is merely to
| |
| sum up the combination of ideas that make up the Christian and Catholic idea,
| |
| and to note that all of them are already crystallised in the first Christmas story.
| |
| | |
| They are three distinct and commonly contrasted things which are nevertheless
| |
| one thing; but this is the only thing which can make them one. The first is the
| |
| human instinct for a heaven that shall be as literal and almost as local as a
| |
| home. It is the idea pursued by all poets and pagans making myths; that a
| |
| particular place must be the shrine of the god or the abode of the blest; that
| |
| fairyland is a land; or that the return of the ghost must be the resurrection of
| |
| the body. I do not here reason about the refusal of rationalism to satisfy this
| |
| need. I only say that if the rationalists refuse to satisfy it, the pagans will not
| |
| be satisfied. This is present in the story of Bethlehem and Jerusalem as it is
| |
| present in the story of Delos and Delphi; and as it is not present in the whole
| |
| universe of Lucretius or the whole universe of Herbert Spencer. The second
| |
| element is a philosophy larger than other philosophies; larger than that of
| |
| Lucretius and infinitely larger than that of Herbert Spencer. It looks at the
| |
| world through a hundred windows where the ancient stoic or the modern
| |
| agnostic only looks through one. It sees life with thousands of eyes belonging
| |
| to thousands of different sorts of people, where the other is only the individual
| |
| standpoint of a stoic or an agnostic. It has something for all moods of man, it
| |
| finds work for all kinds of men, it understands secrets of psychology, it is
| |
| aware of depths of evil, it is able to distinguish between ideal and unreal
| |
| marvels and miraculous exceptions, it trains itself in tact about hard cases, all
| |
| with a multiplicity and subtlety and imagination about the varieties of life
| |
| which is far beyond the bald or breezy platitudes of most ancient or modern
| |
| moral philosophy. In a word, there is more in it; it finds more in existence to
| |
| think about; it gets more out of life. Masses of this material about our manysided
| |
| life have been added since the time of St. Thomas Aquinas. But St.
| |
| Thomas Aquinas alone would have found himself limited in the world of
| |
| Confucius or of Comte. And the third point is this; that while it is local enough
| |
| for poetry and larger than any other philosophy, it is also a challenge and a
| |
| fight. While it is deliberately broadened to embrace every aspect of truth, it is
| |
| still stiffly embattled against every mode of error. It gets every kind of man to
| |
| fight for it, it gets every kind of weapon to fight with, it widens its knowledge
| |
| of the things that are fought for and against with every art of curiosity or
| |
| sympathy; but it never forgets that it is fighting. It proclaims peace on earth
| |
| and never forgets why there was war in heaven.
| |
| | |
| This is the trinity of truths symbolised here by the three types in the old
| |
| Christmas story; the shepherds and the kings and that other king who warred
| |
| upon the children. It is simply not true to say that other religions and
| |
| philosophies are in this respect its rivals. It is not true to say that any one of
| |
| them combines these characters; it is not true to say that any one of them
| |
| pretends to combine them. Buddhism may profess to be equally mystical; it
| |
| does not even profess to be equally military. Islam may profess to be equally
| |
| military; it does not even profess to be equally metaphysical and subtle.
| |
| Confucianism may profess to satisfy the need of the philosophers for order and
| |
| reason; it does not even profess to satisfy the need of the mystics for miracle
| |
| and sacrament and the consecration of concrete things. There are many
| |
| evidences of this presence of a spirit at once universal and unique. One will
| |
| serve here which is the symbol of the subject of this chapter; that no other
| |
| story, no pagan legend or philosophical anecdote or historical event, does in
| |
| fact affect any of us with that peculiar and even poignant impression produced
| |
| on us by the word Bethlehem. No other birth of a god or childhood of a sage
| |
| seems to us to be Christmas or anything like Christmas. It is either too cold or
| |
| too frivolous, or too formal and classical, or too simple and savage, or too
| |
| occult and complicated. Not one of us, whatever his opinions, would ever go
| |
| to such a scene with the sense that he was going home. He might admire it
| |
| because it was poetical, or because it was philosophical, or any number of
| |
| other things in separation; but not because it was itself. The truth is that there
| |
| is a quite peculiar and individual character about the hold of this story on
| |
| human nature; it is not in its psychological substance at all like a mere legend
| |
| or the life of a great man. It does not exactly in the ordinary sense turn our
| |
| minds to greatness; to those extensions and exaggerations of humanity which
| |
| are turned into gods and heroes, even by the healthiest sort of hero-worship. It
| |
| does not exactly work outwards, adventurously, to the wonders to be found at
| |
| the ends of the earth. It is rather something that surprises us from behind, from
| |
| the hidden and personal part of our being; like that which can some times take
| |
| us off our guard in the pathos of small objects or the blind pieties of the poor.
| |
| It is rather as if a man had found an inner room in the very heart of his own
| |
| house, which he had never suspected; and seen a light from within. It is as if
| |
| he found something at the back of his own heart that betrayed him into good. It
| |
| is not made of what the world would call strong materials; or rather it is made
| |
| of materials whose strength is in that winged levity with which they brush us
| |
| and pass. It is all that is in us but a brief tenderness that is there made eternal;
| |
| all that means no more than a momentary softening that is in some strange
| |
| fashion become a strengthening and a repose; it is the broken speech and the
| |
| lost word that are made positive and suspended unbroken; as the strange kings
| |
| fade into a far country and the mountains resound no more with the feet of the
| |
| shepherds; and only the night and the cavern lie in fold upon fold over
| |
| something more human than humanity.
| |
| | |
| ===II. The Riddles of the Gospel=== | |
| To understand the nature of this chapter, it is necessary to recur to the nature
| |
| of this book. The argument which is meant to be the backbone of the book is
| |
| of the kind called the reductio ad absurdum. It suggests that the results of
| |
| assuming the rationalist thesis are more irrational than ours; but to prove it we
| |
| must assume that thesis. Thus in the first section I often treated man as merely
| |
| an animal, to show that the effect was more impossible than if he were treated
| |
| as an angel. In the sense in which it was necessary to treat man merely as an
| |
| animal, it is necessary to treat Christ merely as a man. I have to suspend my
| |
| own beliefs, which are much more positive; and assume this limitation even in
| |
| order to remove it. I must try to imagine what would happen to a man who did
| |
| really read the story of Christ as the story of a man; and even of a man of
| |
| whom he had never heard before. And I wish to point out that a really
| |
| impartial reading of that kind would lead, if not immediately to belief, at least
| |
| to a bewilderment of which there is really no solution except in belief. In this
| |
| chapter, for this reason, I shall bring in nothing of the spirit of my own creed; I
| |
| shall exclude the very style of diction, and even of lettering, which I should
| |
| think fitting in speaking in my own person. I am speaking as an imaginary
| |
| heathen human being, honestly, staring at the Gospel story for the first time.
| |
| Now it is not at all easy to regard the New Testament as a New Testament. It is
| |
| not at all easy to realise the good news as new. Both for good and evil
| |
| familiarity fills us with assumptions and associations; and no man of our
| |
| civilisation, whatever he thinks of our religion, can really read the thing as if
| |
| he had never heard of it before. Of course it is in any case utterly unhistorical
| |
| to talk as if the New Testament were a neatly bound book that had fallen from
| |
| heaven. It is simply the selection made by the authority of the Church from a
| |
| mass of early Christian literature. But apart from any such question there is a
| |
| psychological difficulty in feeling the New Testament as new. There is a
| |
| psychological difficulty in seeing those well-known words simply as they
| |
| stand and without going beyond what they intrinsically stand for. And this
| |
| difficulty must indeed be very great; for the result of it is very curious. The
| |
| result of it is that most modern critics and most current criticism, even popular
| |
| criticism, makes a comment that is the exact reverse of the truth. It is so
| |
| completely the reverse of the truth that one could almost suspect that they had
| |
| never read the New Testament at all.
| |
| | |
| We have all heard people say a hundred times over, for they seem never to tire
| |
| of saying it, that the Jesus of the New Testament is indeed a most merciful and
| |
| humane lover of humanity, but that the Church has hidden this human
| |
| character in repellent dogmas and stiffened it with ecclesiastical terrors till it
| |
| has taken on an inhuman character. This is, I venture to repeat, very nearly the
| |
| reverse of the truth. The truth is that it is the image of Christ in the churches
| |
| that is almost entirely mild and merciful. It is the image of Christ in the
| |
| Gospels that is a good many other things as well. The figure in the Gospels
| |
| does indeed utter in words of almost heart-breaking beauty his pity for our
| |
| broken hearts. But they are very far from being the only sort of words that he
| |
| utters. Nevertheless they are almost the only kind of words that the Church in
| |
| its popular imagery ever represents him as uttering. That popular imagery is
| |
| inspired by a perfectly sound popular instinct. The mass of the poor are
| |
| broken, and the mass of the people are poor, and for the mass of mankind the
| |
| main thing is to carry the conviction of the incredible compassion of God. But
| |
| nobody with his eyes open can doubt that it is chiefly this idea of compassion
| |
| that the popular machinery of the Church does seek to carry. The popular
| |
| imagery carries a great deal to excess the sentiment of 'Gentle Jesus, meek and
| |
| mild.' It is the first thing that the outsider feels and criticises in a Pieta or a
| |
| shrine of the Sacred Heart. As I say, while the art may be insufficient, I am not
| |
| sure that the instinct is unsound. In any case there is something appalling,
| |
| something that makes the blood run cold, in the idea of having a statue of
| |
| Christ in wrath. There is something insupportable even to the imagination in
| |
| the idea of turning the corner of a street or coming out into the spaces of a
| |
| marketplace, to meet the petrifying petrifaction of that figure as it turned upon
| |
| a generation of vipers, or that face as it looked at the face of a hypocrite. The
| |
| Church can reasonably be justified therefore if she turns the most merciful face
| |
| or aspect towards men; but it is certainly the most merciful aspect that she
| |
| does turn. And the point is here that it is very much more specially and
| |
| exclusively merciful than any impression that could be formed by a man
| |
| merely reading the New Testament for the first time. A man simply taking the
| |
| words of the story as they stand would form quite another impression; an
| |
| impression full of mystery and possibly of inconsistency; but certainly not
| |
| merely an impression of mildness. It would be intensely interesting; but part of
| |
| the interest would consist in its leaving a good deal to be guessed at or
| |
| explained. It is full of sudden gestures evidently significant except that we
| |
| hardly know what they signify, of enigmatic silences; of ironical replies. The
| |
| outbreaks of wrath, like storms above our atmosphere, do not seem to break
| |
| out exactly where we should expect them, but to follow some higher weatherchart
| |
| of their own. The Peter whom popular Church teaching presents is very
| |
| rightly the Peter to whom Christ said in forgiveness, 'Feed my lambs.' He is
| |
| not the Peter upon whom Christ turned as if he were the devil, crying in that
| |
| obscure wrath, 'Get thee behind me, Satan.' Christ lamented with nothing but
| |
| love and pity over Jerusalem which was to murder him. We do not know what
| |
| strange spiritual atmosphere or spiritual insight led him to sink Bethsaida
| |
| lower in the pit than Sodom. I am putting aside for the moment all questions of
| |
| doctrinal inferences or expositions, orthodox or otherwise; I am simply
| |
| imagining the effect on a man's mind if he did really do what these critics are
| |
| always talking about doing; if he did really read the New Testament without
| |
| reference to orthodoxy and even without reference to doctrine. He would find
| |
| a number of things which fit in far less with the current unorthodoxy than they
| |
| do with the current orthodoxy. He would find, for instance, that if there are
| |
| any descriptions that deserved to be called realistic, they are precisely the
| |
| descriptions of the supernatural. If there is one aspect of the New Testament
| |
| Jesus in which he may be said to present himself eminently as a practical
| |
| person, it is in the aspect of an exorcist. There is nothing meek and mild, there
| |
| is nothing even in the ordinary sense mystical, about the tone of the voice that
| |
| says 'Hold thy peace and come out of him.' It is much more like the tone of a
| |
| very business-like lion-tamer or a strong-minded doctor dealing with a
| |
| homicidal maniac. But this is only a side issue for the sake of illustration; I am
| |
| not now raising these controversies; but considering the case of the imaginary
| |
| man from the moon to whom the New Testament is new.
| |
| | |
| Now the first thing to note is that if we take it merely as a human story, it is in
| |
| some ways a very strange story. I do not refer here to its tremendous and tragic
| |
| culmination or to any implications involving triumph in that tragedy. I do not
| |
| refer to what is commonly called the miraculous element; for on that point
| |
| philosophies vary and modern philosophies very decidedly waver. Indeed the
| |
| educated Englishman of to-day may be said to have passed from an old
| |
| fashion, in which he would not believe in any miracles unless they were
| |
| ancient, and adopted a new fashion in which he will not believe in any
| |
| miracles unless they are modern. He used to hold that miraculous cures
| |
| stopped with the first Christians and is now inclined to suspect that they began
| |
| with the first Christian Scientists. But I refer here rather specially to
| |
| unmiraculous and even to unnoticed and inconspicuous parts of the story.
| |
| There are a great many things about it which nobody would have invented, for
| |
| they are things that nobody has ever made any particular use of; things which
| |
| if they were remarked at all have remained rather as puzzles. For instance,
| |
| there is that long stretch of silence in the life of Christ up to the age of thirty. It
| |
| is of all silences the most immense and imaginatively impressive. But it is not
| |
| the sort of thing that anybody is particularly likely to invent in order to prove
| |
| something; and no body so far as I know has ever tried to prove anything in
| |
| particular from it. It is impressive, but it is only impressive as a fact; there is
| |
| nothing particularly popular or obvious about it as a fable. The ordinary trend
| |
| of hero-worship and myth-making is much more likely to say the precise
| |
| opposite. It is much more likely to say (as I believe some of the gospels
| |
| rejected by the Church do say) that Jesus displayed a divine precocity and
| |
| began his mission at a miraculously early age. And there is indeed something
| |
| strange in the thought that he who of all humanity needed least preparation
| |
| seems to have had most. Whether it was some mode of the divine humility, or
| |
| some truth of which we see the shadow of the longer domestic tutelage of the
| |
| higher creatures of the earth. I do not propose to speculate; I mention it simply
| |
| as an example of the sort of thing that does in any case give rise to
| |
| speculations, quite apart from recognised religious speculations. Now the
| |
| whole story is full of these things. It is not by any means, as baldly presented
| |
| in print, a story that it is easy to get to the bottom of. It is anything but what
| |
| these people talk of as a simple Gospel. Relatively speaking, it is the Gospel
| |
| that has the mysticism and the Church that has the rationalism. As I should put
| |
| it, of course, it is the Gospel that is the riddle and the Church that is the
| |
| answer. But whatever be the answer, the Gospel as it stands is almost a book
| |
| of riddles.
| |
| | |
| First, a man reading the Gospel sayings would not find platitudes. If he had
| |
| read even in the most respectful spirit the majority of ancient philosophers and
| |
| of modern moralists, he would appreciate the unique importance of saying that
| |
| he did not find platitudes. It is more than can be said even of Plato. It is much
| |
| more than can be said of Epictetus or Seneca or Marcus Aurelius or
| |
| Apollonius of Tyana. And it is immeasurably more than can be said of most of
| |
| the agnostic moralists and the preachers of the ethical societies; with their
| |
| songs of service and their religion of brotherhood. The morality of most
| |
| moralists ancient and modern, has been one solid and polished cataract of
| |
| platitudes flowing for ever and ever. That would certainly not be the
| |
| impression of the imaginary independent outsider studying the New
| |
| Testament. He would be conscious of nothing so commonplace and in a sense
| |
| of nothing so continuous as that stream. He would find a number of strange
| |
| claims that might sound like the claim to be the brother of the sun and moon; a
| |
| number of very startling pieces of advice; a number of stunning rebukes; a
| |
| number of strangely beautiful stories. He would see some very gigantesque
| |
| figures of speech about the impossibility of threading a needle with a camel or
| |
| the possibility of throwing a mountain into the sea. He would see a number of
| |
| very daring simplifications of the difficulties of life; like the advice to shine
| |
| upon everybody indifferently as does the sunshine or not to worry about the
| |
| future any more than the birds. He would find on the other hand some
| |
| passages of almost impenetrable darkness, so far as he is concerned, such as
| |
| the moral of the parable of the Unjust Steward. Some of these things might
| |
| strike him as fables and some as truths; but none as truisms. For instance, he
| |
| would not find the ordinary platitudes in favour of peace. He would find
| |
| several paradoxes in favour of peace. He would find several ideals of nonresistance,
| |
| which taken as they stand would be rather too pacific for any
| |
| pacifist. He would be told in one passage to treat a robber not with passive
| |
| resistance, but rather with positive and enthusiastic encouragement, if the
| |
| terms be taken literally; heaping up gifts upon the man who had stolen goods.
| |
| But he would not find a word of all that obvious rhetoric against war which
| |
| has filled countless books and odes and orations; not a word about the
| |
| wickedness of war, the wastefulness of war, the appalling scale of the
| |
| slaughter in war and all the rest of the familiar frenzy; indeed not a word about
| |
| war at all. There is nothing that throws any particular light on Christ's attitude
| |
| towards organised warfare, except that he seems to have been rather fond of
| |
| Roman soldiers. Indeed it is another perplexity, speaking from the same
| |
| external and human stand point, that he seems to have got on much better with
| |
| Romans than he did with Jews. But the question here is a certain tone to be
| |
| appreciated by merely reading a certain text; and we might give any number of
| |
| instances of it.
| |
| | |
| The statement that the meek shall inherit the earth is very far from being a
| |
| meek statement. I mean it is not meek in the ordinary sense of mild and
| |
| moderate and inoffensive. To justify it, it would be necessary to go very deep
| |
| into history and anticipate things undreamed of then and by many unrealised
| |
| even now; such as the way in which the mystical monks reclaimed the lands
| |
| which the practical kings had lost. If it was a truth at all, it was because it was
| |
| a prophecy. But certainly it was not a truth in the sense of a truism. The
| |
| blessing upon the meek would seem to be a very violent statement; in the
| |
| sense of doing violence to reason and probability. And with this we come to
| |
| another important stage in the speculation. As a prophecy it really was
| |
| fulfilled; but it was only fulfilled long afterwards. The monasteries were the
| |
| most practical and prosperous estates and experiments in reconstruction after
| |
| the barbaric deluge; the meek did really inherit the earth. But nobody could
| |
| have known anything of the sort at the time-- unless indeed there was one who
| |
| knew. Something of the same thing may be said about the incident of Martha
| |
| and Mary; which has been interpreted in retrospect and from the inside by the
| |
| mystics of the Christian contemplative life. But it was not at all an obvious
| |
| view of it; and most moralists, ancient and modern, could be trusted to make a
| |
| rush for the obvious. What torrents of effortless eloquence would have flowed
| |
| from them to swell any slight superiority on the part of Martha; what splendid
| |
| sermons about the Joy of Service and the Gospel of Work and the World Left
| |
| Better Than We Found It, and generally all the ten thousand platitudes that can
| |
| be uttered in favour of taking trouble--by people who need take no trouble to
| |
| utter them. If in Mary the mystic and child of love Christ was guarding the
| |
| seed of something more subtle, who was likely to understand it at the time?
| |
| Nobody else could have seen Clare and Catherine and Teresa shining above
| |
| the little roof at Bethany. It is so in another way with that magnificent menace
| |
| about bringing into the world a sword to sunder and divide. Nobody could
| |
| have guessed then either how it could be fulfilled or how it could be justified.
| |
| Indeed some freethinkers are still so simple as to fall into the trap and be
| |
| shocked at a phrase so deliberately defiant. They actually complain of the
| |
| paradox for not being a platitude.
| |
| | |
| But the point here is that if we could read the Gospel reports as things as new
| |
| as newspaper reports, they would puzzle us and perhaps terrify us much more
| |
| than the same things as developed by historical Christianity. For instance,
| |
| Christ after a clear allusion to the eunuchs of eastern courts, said there would
| |
| be eunuchs of the kingdom of heaven. If this does not mean the voluntary
| |
| enthusiasm of virginity, it could only be made to mean something much more
| |
| unnatural or uncouth. It is the historical religion that humanises it for us by
| |
| experience of Franciscans or of Sisters of Mercy. The mere statement standing
| |
| by itself might very well suggest a rather dehumanised atmosphere; the sinister
| |
| and inhuman silence of the Asiatic harem and divan. This is but one instance
| |
| out of scores; but the moral is that the Christ of the Gospel might actually
| |
| seem more strange and terrible than the Christ of the Church.
| |
| | |
| I am dwelling on the dark or dazzling or defiant or mysterious side of the
| |
| Gospel words, not because they had not obviously a more obvious and popular
| |
| side, but because this is the answer to a common criticism on a vital point. The
| |
| freethinker frequently says that Jesus of Nazareth was a man of his time, even
| |
| if he was in advance of his time; and that we cannot accept his ethics as final
| |
| for humanity. The freethinker then goes on to criticise his ethics, saying
| |
| plausibly enough that men cannot turn the other cheek, or that they must take
| |
| thought for the morrow, or that the self-denial is too ascetic or the monogamy
| |
| too severe. But the Zealots and the Legionaries did not turn the other cheek
| |
| any more than we do, if so much. The Jewish traders and Roman tax-gatherers
| |
| took thought for the morrow as much as we, if not more. We cannot pretend to
| |
| be abandoning the morality of the past for one more suited to the present. It is
| |
| certainly not the morality of another age, but it might be of another world.
| |
| In short, we can say that these ideals are impossible in themselves. Exactly
| |
| what we cannot say is that they are impossible for us. They are rather notably
| |
| marked by a mysticism which, if it be a sort of madness, would always have
| |
| struck the same sort of people as mad. Take, for instance, the case of marriage
| |
| and the relations of the sexes. It might very well have been true that a Galilean
| |
| teacher taught things natural to a Galilean environment; but it is not. It might
| |
| rationally be expected that a man in the time of Tiberius would have advanced
| |
| a view conditioned by the time of Tiberius; but he did not. What he advanced
| |
| was something quite different; something very difficult; but something no
| |
| more difficult now than it was then. When, for instance, Mahomet made his
| |
| polygamous compromise we may reasonably say that it was conditioned by a
| |
| polygamous society. When he allowed a man four wives he was really doing
| |
| something suited to the circumstances, which might have been less suited to
| |
| other circumstances. Nobody will pretend that the four wives were like the
| |
| four winds, something seemingly a part of the order of nature; nobody will say
| |
| that the figure four was written for ever in stars upon the sky. But neither will
| |
| anyone say that the figure four is an inconceivable ideal; that it is beyond the
| |
| power of the mind of man to count up to four; or to count the number of his
| |
| wives and see whether it amounts to four. It is a practical compromise carrying
| |
| with it the character of a particular society. If Mahomet had been born in
| |
| Acton in the nineteenth century, we may well doubt whether he would
| |
| instantly have filled that suburb with harems of four wives apiece. As he was
| |
| born in Arabia in the sixth century, he did in his conjugal arrangements
| |
| suggest the conditions of Arabia in the sixth century. But Christ in his view of
| |
| marriage does not in the least suggest the conditions of Palestine of the first
| |
| century. He does not suggest anything at all, except the sacramental view of
| |
| marriage as developed long afterwards by the Catholic Church. It was quite as
| |
| difficult for people then as for people now. It was much more puzzling to
| |
| people then than to people now. Jews and Romans and Greeks did not believe,
| |
| and did not even understand enough to disbelieve, the mystical idea that the
| |
| man and the woman had become one sacramental substance. We may think it
| |
| an incredible or impossible ideal; but we cannot think it any more incredible or
| |
| impossible than they would have thought it. In other words, whatever else is
| |
| true, it is not true that the controversy has been altered by time. Whatever else
| |
| is true, it is emphatically not true that the ideas of Jesus of Nazareth were
| |
| suitable to his time, but are no longer suitable to our time. Exactly how
| |
| suitable they were to his time is perhaps suggested in the end of his story.
| |
| | |
| The same truth might be stated in another way by saying that if the story be
| |
| regarded as merely human and historical, it is extraordinary how very little
| |
| there is in the recorded words of Christ that ties him at all to his own time. I do
| |
| not mean the details of a period, which even a man of the period knows to be
| |
| passing. I mean the fundamentals which even the wisest man often vaguely
| |
| assumes to be eternal. For instance, Aristotle was perhaps the wisest and most
| |
| wide-minded man who ever lived. He founded himself entirely upon
| |
| fundamentals, which have been generally found to remain rational and solid
| |
| through all social and historical changes. Still, he lived in a world in which it
| |
| was thought as natural to have slaves as to have children. And therefore he did
| |
| permit himself a serious recognition of a difference between slaves and free
| |
| men. Christ as much as Aristotle lived in a world that took slavery for granted.
| |
| He did not particularly denounce slavery. He started a movement that could
| |
| exist in a world with slavery. But he started a movement that could exist in a
| |
| world without slavery. He never used a phrase that made his philosophy
| |
| depend even upon the very existence of the social order in which he lived. He
| |
| spoke as one conscious that everything was ephemeral, including the things
| |
| that Aristotle thought eternal. By that time the Roman Empire had come to be
| |
| merely the orbis terrarum, another name for the world. But he never made his
| |
| morality dependent on the existence of the Roman Empire or even on the
| |
| existence of the world. 'Heaven and earth shall pass away, but my words shall
| |
| not pass away.'
| |
| | |
| The truth is that when critics have spoken of the local limitations of the
| |
| Galilean, it has always been a case of the local limitations of the critics. He did
| |
| undoubtedly believe in certain things that one particular modern sect of
| |
| materialists do not believe. But they were not things particularly peculiar to his
| |
| time. It would be nearer the truth to say that the denial of them is quite
| |
| peculiar to our time. Doubtless it would be nearer still to the truth to say
| |
| merely that a certain solemn social importance, in the minority disbelieving
| |
| them, is peculiar to our time. He believed, for instance, in evil spirits or in the
| |
| psychic healing of bodily ills; but not because he was a Galilean born under
| |
| Augustus. It is absurd to say that a man believed things because he was a
| |
| Galilean under Augustus when he might have believed the same things if he
| |
| had been an Egyptian under Tutenkamen or an Indian under Gengis Khan. But
| |
| with this general question of the philosophy of diabolism or of divine miracles
| |
| I deal elsewhere. It is enough to say that the materialists have to prove the
| |
| impossibility of miracles against the testimony of all mankind, not against the
| |
| prejudices of provincials in North Palestine under the first Roman Emperors.
| |
| What they have to prove, for the present argument, is the presence in the
| |
| Gospels of those particular prejudices of those particular provincials. And,
| |
| humanly speaking, it is astonishing how little they can produce even to make a
| |
| beginning of proving it.
| |
| | |
| So it is in this case of the sacrament of marriage. We may not believe in
| |
| sacraments, as we may not believe in spirits, but it is quite clear that Christ
| |
| believed in this sacrament in his own way and not in any current or
| |
| contemporary way. He certainly did not get his argument against divorce from
| |
| the Mosaic law or the Roman law or the habits of the Palestinian people. It
| |
| would appear to his critics then exactly what it appears to his critics now; an
| |
| arbitrary and transcendental dogma coming from nowhere save in the sense
| |
| that it came from him. I am not at all concerned here to defend that dogma; the
| |
| point here is that it is just as easy to defend it now as it was to defend it then. It
| |
| is an ideal altogether outside time; difficult at any period; impossible at no
| |
| period. In other words, if anyone says it is what might be expected of a man
| |
| walking about in that place at that period, we can quite fairly answer that it is
| |
| much more like what might be the mysterious utterance of a being beyond
| |
| man, if he walked alive among men.
| |
| | |
| I maintain therefore that a man reading the New Testament frankly and freshly
| |
| would not get the impression of what is now often meant by a human Christ.
| |
| The merely human Christ is a made-up figure, a piece of artificial selection,
| |
| like the merely evolutionary man. Moreover there have been too many of these
| |
| human Christs found in the same story, just as there have been too many keys
| |
| to mythology found in the same stories. Three or four separate schools of
| |
| rationalism have worked over the ground and produced three or four equally
| |
| rational explanations of his life. The first rational explanation of his life was
| |
| that he never lived. And this in turn gave an opportunity for three or four
| |
| different explanations, as that he was a sun-myth or a corn-myth, or any other
| |
| kind of myth that is also a monomania. Then the idea that he was a divine
| |
| being who did not exist gave place to the idea that he was a human being who
| |
| did exist. In my youth it was the fashion to say that he was merely an ethical
| |
| teacher in the manner of the Essenes, who had apparently nothing very much
| |
| to say that Hillel or a hundred other Jews might not have said; as that it is a
| |
| kindly thing to be kind and an assistance to purification to be pure. Then
| |
| somebody said he was a madman with a Messianic delusion. Then others said
| |
| he was indeed an original teacher because he cared about nothing but
| |
| Socialism; or (as others said) about nothing but Pacifism. Then a more grimly
| |
| scientific character appeared who said that Jesus would never have been heard
| |
| of at all except for his prophecies of the end of the world. He was important
| |
| merely as a Millenarian like Dr. Cumming; and created a provincial scare by
| |
| announcing the exact date of the crack of doom. Among other variants on the
| |
| same theme was the theory that he was a spiritual healer and nothing else; a
| |
| view implied by Christian Science, which has really to expound a Christianity
| |
| without the Crucifixion in order to explain the curing of Peter's wife's mother
| |
| or the daughter of a centurion. There is another theory that concentrates
| |
| entirely on the business of diabolism and what it would call the contemporary
| |
| superstition about demoniacs, as if Christ, like a young deacon taking his first
| |
| orders, had got as far as exorcism and never got any further. Now, each of
| |
| these explanations in itself seems to me singularly inadequate; but taken
| |
| together they do suggest something of the very mystery which they miss.
| |
| There must surely have been something not only mysterious but many-sided
| |
| about Christ if so many smaller Christs can be carved out of him. If the
| |
| Christian Scientist is satisfied with him as a spiritual healer and the Christian
| |
| Socialist is satisfied with him as a social reformer, so satisfied that they do not
| |
| even expect him to be anything else, it looks as if he really covered rather
| |
| more ground than they could be expected to expect. And it does seem to
| |
| suggest that there might be more than they fancy in these other mysterious
| |
| attributes of casting out devils or prophesying doom.
| |
| | |
| Above all, would not such a new reader of the New Testament stumble over
| |
| something that would startle him much more than it startles us? I have here
| |
| more than once attempted the rather impossible task of reversing time and the
| |
| historic method; and in fancy looking forward to the facts, instead of backward
| |
| through the memories. So I have imagined the monster that man might have
| |
| seemed at first to the mere nature around him. We should have a worse shock
| |
| if we really imagined the nature of Christ named for the first time. What
| |
| should we feel at the first whisper of a certain suggestion about a certain man?
| |
| Certainly it is not for us to blame anybody who should find that first wild
| |
| whisper merely impious and insane. On the contrary, stumbling on that rock of
| |
| scandal is the first step. Stark staring incredulity is a far more loyal tribute to
| |
| that truth than a modernist metaphysic that would make it out merely a matter
| |
| of degree. It were better to rend our robes with a great cry against blasphemy,
| |
| like Caiaphas in the judgement, or to lay hold of the man as a maniac
| |
| possessed of devils like the kinsmen and the crowd, rather than to stand
| |
| stupidly debating fine shades of pantheism in the presence of so catastrophic a
| |
| claim. There is more of the wisdom that is one with surprise in any simple
| |
| person, full of the sensitiveness of simplicity, who should expect the grass to
| |
| wither and the birds to drop dead out of the air, when a strolling carpenter's
| |
| apprentice said calmly and almost carelessly, like one looking over his
| |
| shoulder: 'Before Abraham was, I am.'
| |
| | |
| ===III. The Strangest Story in the World=== | |
| In the last chapter I have deliberately stressed what seems to be nowadays a
| |
| neglected side of the New Testament story, but nobody will suppose, I
| |
| imagine, that it is meant to obscure that side that may truly be called human.
| |
| That Christ was and is the most merciful of judges and the most sympathetic
| |
| of friends is a fact of considerably more importance in our own private lives
| |
| than in anybody's historical speculations. But the purpose of this book is to
| |
| point out that something unique has been swamped in cheap generalisations;
| |
| and for that purpose it is relevant to insist that even what was most universal
| |
| was also most original. For instance, we might take a topic which really is
| |
| sympathetic to the modern mood, as the ascetic vocations recently referred to
| |
| are not. The exaltation of childhood is something which we do really
| |
| understand; but it was by no means a thing that was then in that sense
| |
| understood. If we wanted an example of the originality of the Gospels we
| |
| could hardly take a stronger or more startling one. Nearly two thousand years
| |
| afterwards we happen to find ourselves in a mood that does really feel the
| |
| mystical charm of the child; we express it in romances and regrets about
| |
| childhood, in Peter Pan or The Child's Garden of Verses. And we can say of
| |
| the words of Christ with so angry an anti-Christian as Swinburne:--
| |
| | |
| ;'No sign that ever was given
| |
| ;To faithful or faithless eyes
| |
| ;Showed ever beyond clouds riven
| |
| ;So clear a paradise.
| |
| ;Earth's creeds may be seventy times seven
| |
| ;And blood have defiled each creed
| |
| ;But if such be the kingdom of heaven
| |
| ;It must be heaven indeed.'
| |
| | |
| But that paradise was not clear until Christianity had gradually cleared it. The
| |
| pagan world, as such, would not have understood any such thing as a serious
| |
| suggestion that a child is higher or holier than a man. It would have seemed
| |
| like the suggestion that a tadpole is higher or holier than a frog. To the merely
| |
| rationalistic mind, it would sound like saying that a bud must be more
| |
| beautiful than a flower or that an unripe apple must be better than a ripe one.
| |
| In other words, this modern feeling is an entirely mystical feeling. It is quite as
| |
| mystical as the cult of virginity; in fact it is the cult of virginity. But pagan
| |
| antiquity had much more idea of the holiness of the virgin than of the holiness
| |
| of the child. For various reasons we have come nowadays to venerate children,
| |
| perhaps partly because we envy children for still doing what men used to do;
| |
| such as play simple games and enjoy fairy-tales. Over and above this,
| |
| however, there is a great deal of real and subtle psychology in our appreciation
| |
| of childhood; but if we turn it into a modern discovery, we must once more
| |
| admit that the historical Jesus of Nazareth had already discovered it two
| |
| thousand years too soon. There was certainly nothing in the world around him
| |
| to help him to the discovery. Here Christ was indeed human; but more human
| |
| than a human being was then likely to be. Peter Pan does not belong to the
| |
| world of Pan but the world of Peter.
| |
| | |
| Even in the matter of mere literary style, if we suppose ourselves thus
| |
| sufficiently detached to look at it in that light, there is a curious quality to
| |
| which no critic seems to have done justice. It had among other things a
| |
| singular air of piling tower upon tower by the use of the a fortiori; making a
| |
| pagoda of degrees like the seven heavens. I have already noted that almost
| |
| inverted imaginative vision which pictured the impossible penance of the
| |
| Cities of the Plain. There is perhaps nothing so perfect in all language or
| |
| literature as the use of these three degrees in the parable of the lilies of the
| |
| field; in which he seems first to take one small flower in his hand and note its
| |
| simplicity and even its impotence; then suddenly expands it in flamboyant
| |
| colours into all the palaces and pavilions full of a great name in national
| |
| legend and national glory; and then, by yet a third overturn, shrivels into
| |
| nothing once more with a gesture as if flinging it away `and if God so clothes
| |
| the grass that today is and tomorrow is cast into the oven-- how much more' It
| |
| is like the building of a good Babel tower by white magic in a moment and in
| |
| the movement of a hand; a tower heaved suddenly up to heaven on the top of
| |
| which can be seen afar off, higher than we had fancied possible, the figure of
| |
| man; lifted by three infinities above all other things, on a starry ladder of light
| |
| logic and swift imagination. Merely in a literary sense it would be more of a
| |
| masterpiece than most of the masterpieces in the libraries; yet it seems to have
| |
| been uttered almost at random while a man might pull a flower. But merely in
| |
| a literary sense also, this use of the comparative in several degrees has about it
| |
| a quality which seems to me to hint of much higher things than the modern
| |
| suggestion of the simple teaching of pastoral or communal ethics. There is
| |
| nothing that really indicates a subtle and in the true sense a superior mind so
| |
| much as this power of comparing a lower thing with a higher and yet that
| |
| higher with a higher still; of thinking on three planes at once. There is nothing
| |
| that wants the rarest sort of wisdom so much as to see, let us say, that the
| |
| citizen is higher than the slave and yet that the soul is infinitely higher than the
| |
| citizen or the city. It is not by any means a faculty that commonly belongs to
| |
| these simplifiers of the Gospel; those who insist on what they call a simple
| |
| morality and others call a sentimental morality. It is not at all covered by those
| |
| who are content to tell everybody to remain at peace. On the contrary, there is
| |
| a very striking example of it in the apparent inconsistency between Christ's
| |
| sayings about peace and about a sword. It is precisely this power which
| |
| perceives that while a good peace is better than a good war, even a good war is
| |
| better than a bad peace. These far-flung comparisons are nowhere so common
| |
| as in the Gospels; and to me they suggest something very vast. So a thing
| |
| solitary and solid, with the added dimension of depth or height, might tower
| |
| over the flat creatures living only on a plane.
| |
| | |
| This quality of something that can only be called subtle and superior,
| |
| something that is capable of long views and even of double meanings, is not
| |
| noted here merely as a counterblast to the commonplace exaggerations of
| |
| amiability and mild idealism. It is also to be noted in connection with the more
| |
| tremendous truth touched upon at the end of the last chapter. For this is the
| |
| very last character that commonly goes with mere megalomania; especially
| |
| such steep and staggering megalomania as might be involved in that claim.
| |
| | |
| This quality that can only be called intellectual distinction is not, of course, an
| |
| evidence of divinity. But it is an evidence of a probable distaste for vulgar and
| |
| vainglorious claims to divinity. A man of that sort, if he were only a man,
| |
| would be the last man in the world to suffer from that intoxication by one
| |
| notion from nowhere in particular, which is the mark of the self-deluding
| |
| sensationalist in religion . Nor is it even avoided by denying that Christ did
| |
| make this claim. Of no such man as that, of no other prophet or philosopher of
| |
| the same intellectual order, would it be even possible to pretend that he had
| |
| made it. Even if the Church had mistaken his meaning, it would still be true
| |
| that no other historical tradition except the Church had ever even made the
| |
| same mistake. Mahomedans did not misunderstand Mahomet and suppose he
| |
| was Allah. Jews did not misinterpret Moses and identify him with Jehovah.
| |
| Why was this claim alone exaggerated unless this alone was made. Even if
| |
| Christianity was one vast universal blunder, it is still a blunder as solitary as
| |
| the Incarnation.
| |
| | |
| The purpose of these pages is to fix the falsity of certain vague and vulgar
| |
| assumptions; and we have here one of the most false. There is a sort of notion
| |
| in the air everywhere that all the religions are equal because all the religious
| |
| founders were rivals, that they are all fighting for the same starry crown. It is
| |
| quite false. The claim to that crown, or anything like that crown, is really so
| |
| rare as to be unique. Mahomet did not make it any more than Micah or
| |
| Malachi. Confucius did not make it any more that Plato or Marcus Aurelius.
| |
| Buddha never said he was Brahma. Zoroaster no more claimed to be Ormuz
| |
| than to be Ahriman. The truth is that, in the common run of cases, it is just as
| |
| we should expect it to be, in common sense and certainly in Christian
| |
| philosophy. It is exactly the other way. Normally speaking, the greater a man
| |
| is, the less likely he is to make the very greatest claim. Outside the unique case
| |
| we are considering, the only kind of man who ever does make that kind of
| |
| claim is a very small man; a secretive or self-centered monomaniac. Nobody
| |
| can imagine Aristotle claiming to be the father of gods and men, come down
| |
| from the sky; though we might imagine some insane Roman Emperor like
| |
| Caligula claiming it for him, or more probably for himself. Nobody can
| |
| imagine Shakespeare talking as if he were literally divine; though we might
| |
| imagine some crazy American crank finding it as a cryptogram in
| |
| Shakespeare's works, or preferably in his own works. It is possible to find here
| |
| and there human beings who make this supremely superhuman claim. It is
| |
| possible to find them in lunatic asylums; in padded cells; possibly in strait
| |
| waistcoats. But what is much more important than their mere materialistic fate
| |
| in our very materialistic society, under very crude and clumsy laws about
| |
| lunacy, the type we know as tinged with this, or tending towards it, is a
| |
| diseased and disproportionate type; narrow yet swollen and morbid to
| |
| monstrosity. It is by rather an unlucky metaphor that we talk of a madman as
| |
| cracked; for in a sense he is not cracked enough. He is cramped rather than
| |
| cracked; there are not enough holes in his head to ventilate it. This
| |
| impossibility of letting in daylight on a delusion does sometimes cover and
| |
| conceal a delusion of divinity. It can be found, not among prophets and sages
| |
| and founders of religions, but only among a low set of lunatics. But this is
| |
| exactly where the argument becomes intensely interesting; because the
| |
| argument proves too much. For nobody supposes that Jesus of Nazareth was
| |
| that sort of person. No modern critic in his five wits thinks that the preacher of
| |
| the Sermon on the Mount was a horrible half-witted imbecile that might be
| |
| scrawling stars on the walls of a cell. No atheist or blasphemer believes that
| |
| the author of the Parable of the Prodigal Son was a monster with one mad idea
| |
| like a cyclops with one eye. Upon any possible historical criticism, he must be
| |
| put higher in the scale of human beings than that. Yet by all analogy we have
| |
| really to put him there or else in the highest place of all.
| |
| | |
| In fact, those who can really take it (as I here hypothetically take it) in a quite
| |
| dry and detached spirit, have here a most curious and interesting human
| |
| problem. It is so intensely interesting, considered as a human problem, that it
| |
| is in a spirit quite disinterested, so to speak, that I wish some of them had
| |
| turned that intricate human problem into something like an intelligible human
| |
| portrait. If Christ was simply a human character, he really was a highly
| |
| complex and contradictory human character. For he combined exactly the two
| |
| things that lie at the two extremes of human variation. He was exactly what the
| |
| man with a delusion never is; he was wise; he was a good judge. What he said
| |
| was always unexpected; but it was always unexpectedly magnanimous and
| |
| often unexpectedly moderate. Take a thing like the point of the parable of the
| |
| tares and the wheat. It has the quality that unites sanity and subtlety. It has not
| |
| the simplicity of a madman. It has not even the simplicity of a fanatic. It might
| |
| be uttered by a philosopher a hundred years old, at the end of a century of
| |
| Utopias. Nothing could be less like this quality of seeing beyond and all round
| |
| obvious things, than the condition of the egomaniac with the one sensitive spot
| |
| on his brain. I really do not see how these two characters could be
| |
| convincingly combined, except in the astonishing way in which the creed
| |
| combines them. For until we reach the full acceptance of the fact as a fact,
| |
| however marvellous, all mere approximations to it are actually further and
| |
| further away from it. Divinity is great enough to be divine; it is great enough
| |
| to call itself divine. But as humanity grows greater, it grows less and less
| |
| likely to do so. God is God, as the Moslems say; but a great man knows he is
| |
| not God, and the greater he is the better he knows it. That is the paradox;
| |
| everything that is merely approaching to that point is merely receding from it.
| |
| Socrates, the wisest man, knows that he knows nothing. A lunatic may think
| |
| he is omniscience, and a fool may talk as if he were omniscient. But Christ is
| |
| in another sense omniscient if he not only knows, but knows that he knows.
| |
| Even on the purely human and sympathetic side, therefore, the Jesus of the
| |
| New Testament seems to me to have in a great many ways the note of
| |
| something superhuman; that is of something human and more than human. But
| |
| there is another quality running through all his teachings which seems to me
| |
| neglected in most modern talk about them as teachings; and that is the
| |
| persistent suggestion that he has not really come to teach. If there is one
| |
| incident in the record which affects me personally as grandly and gloriously
| |
| human, it is the incident of giving wine for the wedding-feast. That is really
| |
| human in the sense in which a whole crowd of prigs, having the appearance of
| |
| human beings, can hardly be described as human. It rises superior to all
| |
| superior persons. It is as human as Herrick and as democratic as Dickens. But
| |
| even in that story there is something else that has that note of things not fully
| |
| explained; and in a way here very relevant. I mean the first hesitation, not on
| |
| any ground touching the nature of the miracle, but on that of the propriety of
| |
| working any miracles at all, at least at that stage; 'my time is not yet come.'
| |
| What does that mean? At least it certainly meant a general plan or purpose in
| |
| the mind, with which certain things did or did not fit in. And if we leave out
| |
| that solitary strategic plan, we not only leave out the point of the story, but the
| |
| story.
| |
|
| |
|
| We often hear of Jesus of Nazareth as a wandering teacher, and there is a vital
| |
| truth in that view in so far as it emphasises an attitude towards luxury and
| |
| convention which most respectable people would still regard as that of a
| |
| vagabond. It is expressed in his own great saying about the holes of the foxes
| |
| and the nests of the birds, and, like many of his great sayings, it is felt as less
| |
| powerful than it is, through lack of appreciation of that great paradox by which
| |
| he spoke of his own humanity as in some way collectively and representatively
| |
| human; calling himself simply the Son of Man; that is, in effect, calling
| |
| himself simply Man. It is fitting that the New Man or the Second Adam should
| |
| repeat in so ringing a voice and with so arresting a gesture the great fact which
| |
| came first in the original story, that man differs from the brutes by everything,
| |
| even by deficiency; that he is in a sense less normal and even less native; a
| |
| stranger upon the earth. It is well to speak of his wanderings in this sense and
| |
| in the sense that he shared the drifting life of the most homeless and hopeless
| |
| of the poor. It is assuredly well to remember that he would quite certainly have
| |
| been moved on by the police and almost certainly arrested by the police for
| |
| having no visible means of subsistence. For our law has in it a turn of humour
| |
| or touch of fancy which Nero and Herod never happened to think of, that of
| |
| actually punishing homeless people for not sleeping at home.
| |
|
| |
| But in another sense the word 'wandering' as applied to his life is a little
| |
| misleading. As a matter of fact, a great many of the pagan sages and not a few
| |
| of the pagan sophists might truly be described as wandering teachers. In some
| |
| of them their rambling journeys were not altogether without a parallel in their
| |
| rambling remarks. Apollonius of Tyana, who figured in some fashionable cults
| |
| as a sort of ideal philosopher, is represented as rambling as far as the Ganges
| |
| and Ethiopia, more or less talking all the time. There was actually a school of
| |
| philosophers called the Peripatetics; and most even of the great philosophers
| |
| give us a vague impression of having very little to do except to walk and talk.
| |
| The great conversations which give us our glimpses of the great minds of
| |
| Socrates or Buddha or even Confucius often seem to be parts of a neverending
| |
| picnic; and especially, which is the important point, to have neither
| |
| beginning nor end. Socrates did indeed find the conversation interrupted by the
| |
| incident of his execution. But it is the whole point and the whole particular
| |
| merit, of the position of Socrates that death was only an interruption and an
| |
| incident. We miss the real moral importance of the great philosopher if we
| |
| miss that point; that he stares at the executioner with an innocent surprise, and
| |
| almost an innocent annoyance, at finding anyone so unreasonable as to cut
| |
| short a little conversation for the elucidation of truth. He is looking for truth
| |
| and not looking for death. Death is but a stone in the road which can trip him
| |
| up. His work in life is to wander on the roads of the world and talk about truth
| |
| for ever. Buddha, on the other hand, did arrest attention by one gesture; it was
| |
| the gesture of renunciation, and therefore in a sense of denial. But by one
| |
| dramatic negation he passed into a world of negation that was not dramatic;
| |
| which he would have been the first to insist was not dramatic. Here again we
| |
| miss the particular moral importance of the great mystic if we do not see the
| |
| distinction; that it was his whole point that he had done with drama, which
| |
| consists of desire and struggle and generally of defeat and disappointment. He
| |
| passes into peace and lives to instruct others how to pass into it. Henceforth
| |
| his life is that of the ideal philosopher; certainly a far more really ideal
| |
| philosopher than Apollonius of Tyana; but still a philosopher in the sense that
| |
| it is not his business to do anything but rather to explain everything; in his
| |
| case, we might almost say, mildly and softly to explode everything. For the
| |
| messages are basically different. Christ said 'Seek first the kingdom, and all
| |
| these things shall be added unto you.' Buddha said 'Seek first the kingdom, and
| |
| then you will need none of these things.'
| |
| Now compared to these wanderers the life of Jesus went as swift and straight
| |
| as a thunderbolt. It was above all things dramatic; it did above all things
| |
| consist in doing something that had to be done. It emphatically would not have
| |
| been done, if Jesus had walked about the world for ever doing nothing except
| |
| tell the truth. And even the external movement of it must not be described as a
| |
| wandering in the sense of forgetting that it was a journey. This is where it was
| |
| a fulfilment of the myths rather than of the philosophies; it is a journey with a
| |
| goal and an object, like Jason going to find the Golden Fleece, or Hercules the
| |
| golden apples of the Hesperides. The gold that he was seeking was death. The
| |
| primary thing that he was going to do was to die. He was going to do other
| |
| things equally definite and objective; we might almost say equally external
| |
| and material. But from first to last the most definite fact is that he is going to
| |
| die. No two things could possibly be more different than the death of Socrates
| |
| and the death of Christ. We are meant to feel that the death of Socrates was,
| |
| from the point of view of his friends at least, a stupid muddle and miscarriage
| |
| of justice interfering with the flow of a humane and lucid, I had almost said a
| |
| light philosophy. We are meant to feel that Death was the bride of Christ as
| |
| Poverty was the bride of St. Francis. We are meant to feel that his life was in
| |
| that sense a sort of love-affair with death, a romance of the pursuit of the
| |
| ultimate sacrifice. From the moment when the star goes up like a birthday
| |
| rocket to the moment when the sun is extinguished like a funeral torch, the
| |
| whole story moves on wings with the speed and direction of a drama, ending
| |
| in an act beyond words.
| |
|
| |
| Therefore the story of Christ is the story of a journey, almost in the manner of
| |
| a military march; certainly in the manner of the quest of a hero moving to his
| |
| achievement or his doom. It is a story that begins in the paradise of Galilee, a
| |
| pastoral and peaceful land having really some hint of Eden, and gradually
| |
| climbs the rising country into the mountains that are nearer to the storm-clouds
| |
| and the stars, as to a Mountain of Purgatory. He may be met as if straying in
| |
| strange places, or stopped on the way for discussion or dispute; but his face is
| |
| set towards the mountain city. That is the meaning of that great culmination
| |
| when he crested the ridge and stood at the turning of the road and suddenly
| |
| cried aloud, lamenting over Jerusalem. Some light touch of that lament is in
| |
| every patriotic poem; or if it is absent, the patriotism stinks with vulgarity.
| |
| That is the meaning the stirring and startling incident at the gates of the
| |
| Temple, when the tables were hurled like lumber down the steps, and the rich
| |
| merchants driven forth with bodily blows; the incident that must be at least as
| |
| much of a puzzle to the pacifists as any paradox about non resistance can be to
| |
| any of the militarists. I have compared the quest to the journey of Jason, but
| |
| we must never forget that in a deeper sense it is rather to be compared to the
| |
| journey of Ulysses. It was not only a romance of travel but a romance of
| |
| return; and of the end of a usurpation. No healthy boy reading the story
| |
| regards the rout of the Ithacan suitors as anything but a happy ending. But
| |
| there are doubtless some who regard the rout of the Jewish merchants and
| |
| money changers with that refined repugnance which never fails to move them
| |
| in the presence of violence, and especially of violence against the well-to-do.
| |
| The point, here however, is that all these incidents have in them a character of
| |
| mounting crisis. In other words. these incidents are not incidental. When
| |
| Apollonius the ideal philosopher is brought before the judgement-seat of
| |
| Domitian and vanishes by magic, the miracle is entirely incidental. It might
| |
| have occurred at any time in the wandering life of the Tyanean; indeed, I
| |
| believe it is doubtful in date as well as in substance. The ideal philosopher
| |
| merely vanished, and resumed his ideal existence somewhere else for an
| |
| indefinite period. It is characteristic of the contrast perhaps that Apollonius
| |
| was supposed to have lived to an almost miraculous old age. Jesus of Nazareth
| |
| was less prudent in his miracles. When Jesus was brought before the
| |
| judgement-seat of Pontius Pilate, he did not vanish. It was the crisis and the
| |
| goal; it was the hour and the power of darkness. It was the supremely
| |
| supernatural act, of all his miraculous life, that he did not vanish.
| |
|
| |
| Every attempt to amplify that story has diminished it. The task has been
| |
| attempted by many men of real genius and eloquence as well as by only too
| |
| many vulgar sentimentalists and self-conscious rhetoricians. The tale has been
| |
| retold with patronising pathos by elegant sceptics and with fluent enthusiasm
| |
| by boisterous best-sellers. It will not be retold here. The grinding power of the
| |
| plain words of the Gospel story is like the power of mill-stones; and those who
| |
| can read them simply enough will feel as if rocks had been rolled upon them.
| |
| Criticism is only words about words; and of what use are words about such
| |
| words as these? What is the use of word-painting about the dark garden filled
| |
| suddenly with torchlight and furious faces? 'Are you come out with swords
| |
| and staves as against a robber? All day I sat in your temple teaching, and you
| |
| took me not.' Can anything be added to the massive and gathered restraint of
| |
| that irony; like a great wave lifted to the sky and refusing to fall? 'Daughters of
| |
| Jerusalem, weep not for me but weep for yourselves and for your children.' As
| |
| the High Priest asked what further need he had of witnesses, we might well
| |
| ask what further need we have of words. Peter in a panic repudiated him: 'and
| |
| immediately the cock crew; and Jesus looked upon Peter, and Peter went out
| |
| and wept bitterly.' Has anyone any further remarks to offer. Just before the
| |
| murder he prayed for all the murderous race of men, saying, 'They know not
| |
| what they do'; is there anything to say to that, except that we know as little
| |
| what we say? Is there any need to repeat and spin out the story of how the
| |
| tragedy trailed up the Via Dolorosa and how they threw him in haphazard with
| |
| two thieves in one of the ordinary batches of execution; and how in all that
| |
| horror and howling wilderness of desertion one voice spoke in homage, a
| |
| startling voice from the very last place where it was looked for, the gibbet of
| |
| the criminal; and he said to that nameless ruffian, 'This night shalt thou be with
| |
| me in Paradise'? Is there anything to put after that but a full stop? Or is anyone
| |
| prepared to answer adequately that farewell gesture to all flesh which created
| |
| for his Mother a new Son?
| |
|
| |
| It is more within my powers, and here more immediately to my purpose, to
| |
| point out that in that scene were symbolically gathered all the human forces
| |
| that have been vaguely sketched in this story. As kings and philosophers and
| |
| the popular element had been symbolically present at his birth, so they were
| |
| more practically concerned in his death; and with that we come face to face
| |
| with the essential fact to be realised. All the great groups that stood about the
| |
| Cross represent in one way or another the great historical truth of the time; that
| |
| the world could not save itself. Man could do no more. Rome and Jerusalem
| |
| and Athens and everything else were going down like a sea turned into a slow
| |
| cataract. Externally indeed the ancient world was still at its strongest; it is
| |
| always at that moment that the inmost weakness begins. But in order to
| |
| understand that weakness we must repeat what has been said more than once;
| |
| that it was not the weakness of a thing originally weak. It was emphatically the
| |
| strength of the world that was turned to weakness and the wisdom of the world
| |
| that was turned to folly.
| |
|
| |
| In this story of Good Friday it is the best things in the world that are at their
| |
| worst. That is what really shows us the world at its worst. It was, for instance,
| |
| the priests of a true monotheism and the soldiers of an international
| |
| civilisation. Rome, the legend, founded upon fallen Troy and triumphant over
| |
| fallen Carthage, had stood for a heroism which was the nearest that any pagan
| |
| ever came to chivalry. Rome had defended the household gods and the human
| |
| decencies against the ogres of Africa and the hermaphrodite monstrosities of
| |
| Greece. But in the lightning flash of this incident, we see great Rome, the
| |
| imperial republic, going downward under her Lucretian doom. Scepticism has
| |
| eaten away even the confident sanity of the conquerors of the world. He who
| |
| is enthroned to say what is justice can only ask: 'What is truth?' So in that
| |
| drama which decided the whole fate of antiquity, one of the central figures is
| |
| fixed in what seems the reverse of his true role. Rome was almost another
| |
| name for responsibility. Yet he stands for ever as a sort of rocking statue of the
| |
| irresponsible. Man could do no more. Even the practical had become the
| |
| impracticable. Standing between the pillars of his own judgement-seat, a
| |
| Roman had washed his hands of the world.
| |
|
| |
| There too were the priests of that pure and original truth that was behind all
| |
| the mythologies like the sky behind the clouds. It was the most important truth
| |
| in the world; and even that could not save the world. Perhaps there is
| |
| something overpowering in pure personal theism; like seeing the sun and
| |
| moon and sky come together to form one staring face. Perhaps the truth is too
| |
| tremendous when not broken by some intermediaries divine or human; perhaps
| |
| it is merely too pure and far away. Anyhow it could not save the world; it
| |
| could not even conquer the world. There were philosophers who held it in its
| |
| highest and noblest form; but they not only could not convert the world, but
| |
| they never tried. You could no more fight the jungle of popular mythology
| |
| with a private opinion than you could clear away a forest with a pocket-knife.
| |
| The Jewish priests had guarded it jealously in the good and the bad sense.
| |
| They had kept it as a gigantic secret. As savage heroes might have kept the sun
| |
| in a box, they kept the Everlasting in the tabernacle. They were proud that they
| |
| alone could look upon the blinding sun of a single deity; and they did not
| |
| know that they had themselves gone blind. Since that day their representatives
| |
| have been like blind men in broad daylight, striking to right and left with their
| |
| staffs, and cursing the darkness. But there has been that in their monumental
| |
| monotheism that it has at least remained like a monument, the last thing of its
| |
| kind, and in a sense motionless in the more restless world which it cannot
| |
| satisfy. For it is certain that for some reason it cannot satisfy. Since that day it
| |
| has never been quite enough to say that God is in his heaven and all is right
| |
| with the world, since the rumour that God had left his heavens to set it right.
| |
| And as it was with these powers that were good, or at least had once been
| |
| good, so it was with the element which was perhaps the best, or which Christ
| |
| himself seems certainly to have felt as the best. The poor to whom he preached
| |
| the good news, the common people who heard him gladly, the populace that
| |
| had made so many popular heroes and demigods in the old pagan world,
| |
| showed also the weaknesses that were dissolving the world. They suffered the
| |
| evils often seen in the mob of the city, and especially the mob of the capital,
| |
| during the decline of a society. The same thing that makes the rural population
| |
| live on tradition makes the urban population live on rumour. Just as its myths
| |
| at the best had been irrational, so its likes and dislikes are easily changed by
| |
| baseless assertion that is arbitrary without being authoritative. Some brigand
| |
| or other was artificially turned into a picturesque and popular figure and run as
| |
| a kind of candidate against Christ. In all this we recognise the urban
| |
| population that we know, with its newspaper scares and scoops. But there was
| |
| present in this ancient population an evil more peculiar to the ancient world.
| |
| We have noted it already as the neglect of the individual, even of the
| |
| individual voting the condemnation and still more of the individual
| |
| condemned. It was the soul of the hive; a heathen thing. The cry of this spirit
| |
| also was heard in that hour, 'It is well that one man die for the people.' Yet this
| |
| spirit in antiquity of devotion to the city and to the state had also been in itself
| |
| and in its time a noble spirit. It had its poets and its martyrs; men still to be
| |
| honoured for ever. It was failing through its weakness in not seeing the
| |
| separate soul of a man, the shrine of all mysticism; but it was only failing as
| |
| everything else was failing. The mob went along with the Sadducees and the
| |
| Pharisees, the philosophers and the moralists. It went along with the imperial
| |
| magistrates and the sacred priests, the scribes and the soldiers, that the one
| |
| universal human spirit might suffer a universal condemnation; that there might
| |
| be one deep, unanimous chorus of approval and harmony when Man was
| |
| rejected of men.
| |
|
| |
| There were solitudes beyond where none shall follow. There were secrets in
| |
| the inmost and invisible part of that drama that have no symbol in speech; or
| |
| in any severance of a man from men. Nor is it easy for any words less stark
| |
| and single-minded than those of the naked narrative even to hint at the horror
| |
| of exaltation that lifted itself above the hill. Endless expositions have not come
| |
| to the end of it, or even to the beginning. And if there be any sound that can
| |
| produce a silence, we may surely be silent about the end and the extremity;
| |
| when a cry was driven out of that darkness in words dreadfully distinct and
| |
| dreadfully unintelligible, which man shall never understand in all the eternity
| |
| they have purchased for him; and for one annihilating instant an abyss that is
| |
| not for our thoughts had opened even in the unity of the absolute; and God had
| |
| been forsaken of God.
| |
|
| |
| They took the body down from the cross and one of the few rich men among
| |
| the first Christians obtained permission to bury it in a rock tomb in his garden;
| |
| the Romans setting a military guard lest there should be some riot and attempt
| |
| to recover the body. There was once more a natural symbolism in these natural
| |
| proceedings; it was well that the tomb should be sealed with all the secrecy of
| |
| ancient eastern sepulture and guarded by the authority of the Caesars. For in
| |
| that second cavern the whole of that great and glorious humanity which we
| |
| call antiquity was gathered up and covered over; and in that place it was
| |
| buried. It was the end of a very great thing called human history; the history
| |
| that was merely human. The mythologies and the philosophies were buried
| |
| there, the gods and the heroes and the sages. In the great Roman phrase, they
| |
| had lived. But as they could only live, so they could only die; and they were
| |
| dead.
| |
|
| |
| On the third day the friends of Christ coming at daybreak to the place found
| |
| the grave empty and the stone rolled away. In varying ways they realised the
| |
| new wonder; but even they hardly realised that the world had died in the night.
| |
| What they were looking at was the first day of a new creation, with a new
| |
| heaven and a new earth; and in a semblance of the gardener God walked again
| |
| in the garden, in the cool not of the evening but the dawn.
| |
|
| |
| ===IV. The Witness of the Heretics===
| |
| Christ founded the Church with two great figures of speech; in the final words
| |
| to the Apostles who received authority to found it. The first was the phrase
| |
| about founding it on Peter as on a rock; the second was the symbol of the keys.
| |
| About the meaning of the former there is naturally no doubt in my own case;
| |
| but it does not directly affect the argument here save in two more secondary
| |
| aspects. It is yet another example of a thing that could only fully expand and
| |
| explain itself afterwards, and even long afterwards. And it is yet another
| |
| example of something the very reverse of simple and self-evident even in the
| |
| language, in so far as it described a man as a rock when he had much more the
| |
| appearance of a reed.
| |
|
| |
| But the other image of the keys has an exactitude that has hardly been exactly
| |
| noticed. The keys have been conspicuous enough in the art and heraldry of
| |
| Christendom; but not everyone has noted the peculiar aptness of the allegory.
| |
| We have now reached the point in history where something must be said of the
| |
| first appearance and activities of the Church in the Roman Empire; and for that
| |
| brief description nothing could be more perfect than that ancient metaphor.
| |
| The Early Christian was very precisely a person carrying about a key, or what
| |
| he said was a key. The whole Christian movement consisted in claiming to
| |
| possess that key. It was not merely a vague forward movement, which might
| |
| be better represented by a battering-ram. It was not something that swept along
| |
| with it similar or dissimilar things, as does a modern social movement. As we
| |
| shall see in a moment, it rather definitely refused to do so. It definitely asserted
| |
| that there was a key and that it possessed that key and that no other key was
| |
| like it; in that sense it was as narrow as you please. Only it happened to be the
| |
| key that could unlock the prison of the whole world; and let in the white
| |
| daylight of liberty.
| |
|
| |
| The creed was like a key in three respects; which can be most conveniently
| |
| summed up under this symbol. First, a key is above all things a thing with a
| |
| shape. It is a thing that depends entirely upon keeping its shape. The Christian
| |
| creed is above all things the philosophy of shapes and the enemy of
| |
| shapelessness. That is where it differs from all that formless infinity,
| |
| Manichean or Buddhist, which makes a sort of pool of night in the dark heart
| |
| of Asia; the ideal of uncreating all the creatures. That is where it differs also
| |
| from the analogous vagueness of mere evolutionism, the idea of creatures
| |
| constantly losing their shape. A man told that his solitary latchkey had been
| |
| melted down with a million others into a Buddhistic unity would be annoyed.
| |
| But a man told that his key was gradually growing and sprouting in his pocket,
| |
| and branching into new wards or complications, would not be more gratified.
| |
| Second, the shape of a key is in itself a rather fantastic shape. A savage who
| |
| did not know it was a key would have the greatest difficulty in guessing what
| |
| it could possibly be. And it is fantastic because it is in a sense arbitrary. A key
| |
| is not a matter of abstractions; in that sense a key is not a matter of argument.
| |
| It either fits the lock or it does not. It is useless for men to stand disputing over
| |
| it, considered by itself; or reconstructing it on pure principles of geometry or
| |
| decorative art. It is senseless for a man to say he would like a simple key; it
| |
| would be far more sensible to do his best with a crowbar. And thirdly, as the
| |
| key is necessarily a thing with a pattern, so this was one having in some ways
| |
| a rather elaborate pattern. When people complain of the religion being so early
| |
| complicated with theology and things of the kind, they forget that the world
| |
| had not only got into a hole, but had got into a whole maze of holes and
| |
| corners. The problem itself was a complicated problem; it did not in the
| |
| ordinary sense merely involve anything so simple as sin. It was also full of
| |
| secrets, of unexplored and unfathomable fallacies, of unconscious mental
| |
| diseases, of dangers in all directions. If the faith had faced the world only with
| |
| the platitudes about peace and simplicity some moralists would confine it to, it
| |
| would not have had the faintest effect on that luxurious and labyrinthine
| |
| lunatic asylum. What it did do we must now roughly describe; it is enough to
| |
| say here that there was undoubtedly much about the key that seemed complex,
| |
| indeed there was only one thing about it that was simple. It opened the door.
| |
| There are certain recognised and accepted statements in this matter which may
| |
| for brevity and convenience be described as lies. We have all heard people say
| |
| that Christianity arose in an age of barbarism. They might just as well say that
| |
| Christian Science arose in an age of barbarism. They may think Christianity
| |
| was a symptom of social decay, as I think Christian Science a symptom of
| |
| mental decay. They may think Christianity a superstition that ultimately
| |
| destroyed a civilisation, as I think Christian Science a superstition capable (if
| |
| taken seriously) of destroying any number of civilisations. But to say that a
| |
| Christian of the fourth or fifth centuries was a barbarian living in a barbarous
| |
| time is exactly like saying that Mrs. Eddy was a Red Indian. And if I allowed
| |
| my constitutional impatience with Mrs. Eddy to impel me to call her a Red
| |
| Indian, I should incidentally be telling a lie. We may like or dislike the
| |
| imperial civilisation of Rome in the fourth century; we may like or dislike the
| |
| industrial civilisation of America in the nineteenth century; but that they both
| |
| were what we commonly mean by a civilisation no person of commonsense
| |
| could deny if he wanted to. This is a very obvious fact but it is also a very
| |
| fundamental one; and we must make it the foundation of any further
| |
| description of constructive Christianity in the past. For good or evil, it was
| |
| pre-eminently the product of a civilised age, perhaps of an over-civilised age.
| |
| This is the first fact apart from all praise or blame; indeed I am so unfortunate
| |
| as not to feel that I praise a thing when I compare it to Christian Science. But it
| |
| is at least desirable to know something of the savour of a society in which we
| |
| are condemning or praising anything; and the science that connects Mrs. Eddy
| |
| with tomahawks or the Mater Dolorosa with totems may for our general
| |
| convenience be eliminated. The dominant fact, not merely about the Christian
| |
| religion, but about the whole pagan civilisation, was that which has been more
| |
| than once repeated in these pages. The Mediterranean was a lake in the real
| |
| sense of a pool; in which a number of different cults or cultures were, as the
| |
| phrase goes, pooled. Those cities facing each other round the circle of the lake
| |
| became more and more one cosmopolitan culture. On its legal and military
| |
| side it was the Roman Empire, but it was very many-sided. It might be called
| |
| superstitious in the sense that it contained a great number of varied
| |
| superstitions; but by no possibility can any part of it be called barbarous.
| |
| In this level of cosmopolitan culture arose the Christian religion and the
| |
| Catholic Church; and everything in the story suggests that it was felt to be
| |
| something new and strange. Those who have tried to suggest that it evolved
| |
| out of something much milder or more ordinary have found that in this case
| |
| their evolutionary method is very difficult to apply. They may suggest that
| |
| Essenes or Ebionites or such things were the seed; but the seed is invisible; the
| |
| tree appears very rapidly full-grown; and the tree is something totally
| |
| different. It is certainly a Christmas tree in the sense that it keeps the
| |
| kindliness and moral beauty of the story of Bethlehem; but it was as ritualistic
| |
| as the seven-branched candlestick, and the candles it carried were considerably
| |
| more than were probably permitted by the first prayer-book of Edward the
| |
| Sixth. It might well be asked, indeed, why any one accepting the Bethlehem
| |
| tradition should object to golden or gilded ornament since the Magi
| |
| themselves brought gold, why he should dislike incense in the church since
| |
| incense was brought even to the stable. But these are controversies that do not
| |
| concern me here. I am concerned only with the historical fact, more and more
| |
| admitted by historians, that very early in its history this thing became visible to
| |
| the civilisation of antiquity; and that already the Church appeared as a Church;
| |
| with everything that is implied in a Church and much that is disliked in a
| |
| Church. We will discuss in a moment how far it was like other ritualistic or
| |
| magical or ascetical mysteries in its own time. It was certainly not in the least
| |
| like merely ethical and idealistic movements in our time. It had a doctrine; it
| |
| had a discipline; it had sacraments; it had degrees of initiation, it admitted
| |
| people and expelled people; it affirmed one dogma with authority and
| |
| repudiated another with anathemas. If all these things be the marks of
| |
| Antichrist, the reign of Antichrist followed very rapidly upon Christ.
| |
| Those who maintain that Christianity was not a Church but a moral movement
| |
| of idealists have been forced to push the period of its perversion or
| |
| disappearance further and further back. A bishop of Rome writes claiming
| |
| authority in the very lifetime of St. John the Evangelist; and it is described as
| |
| the first papal aggression. A friend of the Apostles writes of them as men he
| |
| knew and says they taught him the doctrine of the Sacrament, and Mr. Wells
| |
| can only murmur that the reaction towards barbaric blood-rites may have
| |
| happened rather earlier than might be expected. The date of the Fourth Gospel,
| |
| which at one time was steadily growing later and later, is now steadily
| |
| growing earlier and earlier; until critics are staggered at the dawning and
| |
| dreadful possibility that it might be something like what it professes to be. The
| |
| last limit of an early date for the extinction of true Christianity has probably
| |
| been found by the latest German professor whose authority is invoked by Dean
| |
| Inge. This learned scholar says that Pentecost was the occasion for the first
| |
| founding of an ecclesiastical, dogmatic, and despotic Church utterly alien to
| |
| the simple ideals of Jesus of Nazareth. This may be called, in a popular as well
| |
| as a learned sense, the limit. What do professors of this kind imagine that men
| |
| are made of? Suppose it were a matter of any merely human movement, let us
| |
| say that of the conscientious objectors. Some say the early Christians were
| |
| Pacifists; I do not believe it for a moment; but I am quite ready to accept the
| |
| parallel for the sake of the argument. Tolstoy or some great preacher of peace
| |
| among peasants has been shot as a mutineer for defying conscription; and a
| |
| little while afterwards his few followers meet together in an upper room in
| |
| remembrance of him. They never had any reason for coming together except
| |
| that common memory; they are men of many kinds with nothing to bind them,
| |
| except that the greatest event in all their lives was this tragedy of the teacher of
| |
| universal peace. They are always repeating his words, revolving his problems,
| |
| trying to imitate his character. The Pacifists meet at their Pentecost and are
| |
| possessed of a sudden ecstasy of enthusiasm and wild rush of the whirlwind of
| |
| inspiration, in the course of which they proceed to establish universal
| |
| Conscription, to increase the Navy Estimates, to insist on everybody going
| |
| about armed to the teeth and on all the frontiers bristling with artillery; the
| |
| proceedings concluded with the singing of 'Boys of the Bulldog Breed' and
| |
| 'Don't let them scrap the British Navy.' That is something like a fair parallel to
| |
| the theory of these critics; that the transition from their idea of Jesus to their
| |
| idea of Catholicism could have been made in the little upper room at
| |
| Pentecost. Surely anybody's commonsense would tell him that enthusiasts who
| |
| only met through their common enthusiasm for a leader whom they loved,
| |
| would not instantly rush away to establish everything that he hated. No, if the
| |
| 'ecclesiastical and dogmatic system' is as old as Pentecost it is as old as
| |
| Christmas. If we trace it back to such very early Christians we must trace it
| |
| back to Christ.
| |
|
| |
| We may begin then with these two negations. It is nonsense to say that the
| |
| Christian faith appeared in a simple age; in the sense of an unlettered and
| |
| gullible age. It is equally nonsense to say that the Christian faith was a simple
| |
| thing; in the sense of a vague or childish or merely instinctive thing. Perhaps
| |
| the only point in which we could possibly say that the Church fitted into the
| |
| pagan world, is the fact that they were both not only highly civilised but rather
| |
| complicated. They were both emphatically many-sided; but antiquity was then
| |
| a many-sided hole, like a hexagonal hole waiting for an equally hexagonal
| |
| stopper. In that sense only the Church was many-sided enough to fit the world.
| |
| The six sides of the Mediterranean world faced each other across the sea and
| |
| waited for something that should look all ways at once. The Church had to be
| |
| both Roman and Greek and Jewish and African and Asiatic. In the very words
| |
| of the Apostle of the Gentiles, it was indeed all things to all men. Christianity
| |
| then was not merely crude and simple and was the very reverse of the growth
| |
| of a barbaric time. But when we come to the contrary charge, we come to a
| |
| much more plausible charge. It is very much more tenable that the Faith was
| |
| but the final phase of the decay of civilisation, in the sense of the excess of
| |
| civilisation; that this superstition was a sign that Rome was dying, and dying
| |
| of being much too civilised. That is an argument much better worth
| |
| considering; and we will proceed to consider it.
| |
|
| |
| At the beginning of this book I ventured on a general summary of it, in a
| |
| parallel between the rise of humanity out of nature and the rise of Christianity
| |
| out of history. I pointed out that in both cases what had gone before might
| |
| imply something coming after; but did not in the least imply what did come
| |
| after. If a detached mind had seen certain apes it might have deduced more
| |
| anthropoids; it would not have deduced man or anything within a thousand
| |
| miles of what man has done. In short, it might have seen Pithecanthropus or
| |
| the Missing Link looming in the future, if possible almost as dimly and
| |
| doubtfully as we see him looming in the past. But if it foresaw him appearing
| |
| it would also foresee him disappearing, and leaving a few faint traces just as
| |
| he has left a few faint traces; if they are traces. To foresee that Missing Link
| |
| would not be to foresee Man, or anything like Man. Now this earlier
| |
| explanation must be kept in mind; because it is an exact parallel to the true
| |
| view of the Church; and the suggestion of it having evolved naturally out of
| |
| the Empire in decay.
| |
|
| |
| The truth is that in one sense a man might very well have predicted that the
| |
| imperial decadence would produce something like Christianity. That is,
| |
| something a little like and gigantically different. A man might very well have
| |
| said, for instance, 'Pleasure has been pursued so extravagantly that there will
| |
| be a reaction into pessimism. Perhaps it will take the form of asceticism; men
| |
| will mutilate themselves instead of merely hanging themselves.' Or a man
| |
| might very reasonably have said, 'If we weary of our Greek and Latin gods we
| |
| shall be hankering after some eastern mystery or other; there will be a fashion
| |
| in Persians or Hindoos.' Or a man of the world might well have been shrewd
| |
| enough to say, 'Powerful people are picking up these fads; some day the court
| |
| will adopt one of them and it may become official.' Or yet another and
| |
| gloomier prophet might be pardoned for saying, 'The world is going down-hill;
| |
| dark and barbarous superstitions will return, it does not matter much which.
| |
| They will all be formless and fugitive like dreams of the night.'
| |
| Now it is the intense interest of the case that all these prophecies were really
| |
| fulfilled; but it was not the Church that fulfilled them. It was the Church that
| |
| escaped from them, confounded them, and rose above them in triumph. In so
| |
| far as it was probable that the mere nature of hedonism would produce a mere
| |
| reaction of asceticism it did produce a mere reaction of asceticism. It was the
| |
| movement called Manichean and the Church was its mortal enemy. In so far as
| |
| it would have naturally appeared at that point of history, it did appear; it did
| |
| also disappear, which was equally natural. The mere pessimist reaction did
| |
| come with the Manichees and did go with the Manichees. But the Church did
| |
| not come with them or go with them; and she had much more to do with them
| |
| going than with their coming. Or again, in so far as it was probable that even
| |
| the growth of scepticism would bring in a fashion of eastern religion, it did
| |
| bring it in; Mithras came from far beyond Palestine out of the heart of Persia,
| |
| bringing strange mysteries of the blood of bulls. Certainly there was
| |
| everything to show that some such fashion would have come in any case but
| |
| certainly there is nothing in the world to show that it would not have passed
| |
| away in any case. Certainly an Oriental fad was something eminently fitted to
| |
| the fourth or fifth century; but that hardly explains it having remained to the
| |
| twentieth century, and still going strong. In short, in so far as things of the kind
| |
| might have been expected then, things like Mithraism were experienced then;
| |
| but it scarcely explains our more recent experiences. And if we were still
| |
| Mithraists merely because Mithraic head-dresses and other Persian apparatuses
| |
| might be expected to be all the rage in the days of Domitian, it would almost
| |
| seem by this time that we must be a little dowdy.
| |
|
| |
| It is the same, as will be suggested in a moment, with the idea of official
| |
| favouritism. In so far as such favouritism shown towards a fad was something
| |
| that might have been looked for during the decline and fall of the Roman
| |
| Empire, it was something that did exist in that Empire and did decline and fall
| |
| with it. It throws no sort of light on the thing that resolutely refused to decline
| |
| and fall; that grew steadily while the other was declining and falling; and
| |
| which even at this moment is going forward with fearless energy, when an
| |
| other aeon has completed its cycle and another civilisation seems almost ready
| |
| to fall or to decline.
| |
|
| |
| Now the curious fact is this; that the very heresies which the early Church is
| |
| blamed for crushing testify to the unfairness for which she is blamed. In so far
| |
| as something deserved the blame, it was precisely the things that she is blamed
| |
| for blaming. In so far as something was merely a superstition, she herself
| |
| condemned that superstition. In so far as something was a mere reaction into
| |
| barbarism, she herself resisted it because it was a reaction into barbarism. In so
| |
| far as something was a fad of the fading empire, that died and deserved to die,
| |
| it was the Church alone that killed it. The Church is reproached for being
| |
| exactly what the heresy was repressed for being. The explanations of the
| |
| evolutionary historians and higher critics do really explain why Arianism and
| |
| Gnosticism and Nestorianism were born--and also why they died. They do not
| |
| explain why the Church was born or why she has refused to die. Above all,
| |
| they do not explain why she should have made war on the very evils she is
| |
| supposed to share.
| |
|
| |
| Let us take a few practical examples of the principle; the principle that if there
| |
| was anything that was really a superstition of the dying empire, it did really
| |
| die with the dying empire; and certainly was not the same as the very thing
| |
| that destroyed it. For this purpose we will take in order two or three of the
| |
| most ordinary explanations of Christian origins among the modern critics of
| |
| Christianity. Nothing is more common, for instance, than to find such a
| |
| modern critic writing something like this: 'Christianity was above all a
| |
| movement of ascetics, a rush into the desert, a refuge in the cloister, a
| |
| renunciation of all life and happiness; and this was a part of a gloomy and
| |
| inhuman reaction against nature itself, a hatred of the body, a horror of the
| |
| material universe, a sort of universal suicide of the senses and even of the self.
| |
| It came from an eastern fanaticism like that of the fakirs and was ultimately
| |
| founded on an eastern pessimism, which seems to feel existence itself as an
| |
| evil.'
| |
| Now the most extraordinary thing about this is that it is all quite true; it is true
| |
| in every detail except that it happens to be attributed entirely to the wrong
| |
| person. It is not true of the Church; but it is true of the heretics condemned by
| |
| the Church. It is as if one were to write a most detailed analysis of the
| |
| mistakes and misgovernment of the ministers of George the Third, merely with
| |
| the small inaccuracy that the whole story was told about George Washington;
| |
| or as if somebody made a list of the crimes of the Bolshevists with no
| |
| variation except that they were all attributed to the Czar. The early Church was
| |
| indeed very ascetic in connection with a totally different philosophy; but the
| |
| philosophy of a war on life and nature as such really did exist in the world, if
| |
| the critics only knew where to look for it.
| |
|
| |
| What really happened was this. When the Faith first emerged into the world,
| |
| the very first thing that happened to it was that it was caught in a sort of swarm
| |
| of mystical and metaphysical sects, mostly out of the East; like one lonely
| |
| golden bee caught in a swarm of wasps. To the ordinary onlooker, there did
| |
| not seem to be much difference, or anything beyond a general buzz; indeed in
| |
| a sense there was not much difference so far as stinging and being stung were
| |
| concerned. The difference was that only one golden dot in all that whirring
| |
| gold-dust had the power of going forth to make hives for all humanity; to give
| |
| the world honey and wax or (as was so finely said in a context too easily
| |
| forgotten) 'the two noblest things, which are sweetness and light.' The wasps
| |
| all died that winter; and half the difficulty is that hardly anyone knows
| |
| anything about them and most people do not know that they ever existed; so
| |
| that the whole story of that first phase of our religion is lost. Or, to vary the
| |
| metaphor, when this movement or some other movement pierced the dyke
| |
| between the east and west and brought more mystical ideas into Europe, it
| |
| brought with it a whole flood of other mystical ideas besides its own, most of
| |
| them ascetical and nearly all of them pessimistic. They very nearly flooded
| |
| and over-whelmed the purely Christian element. They came mostly from that
| |
| region that was a sort of dim borderland between the eastern philosophies and
| |
| the eastern mythologies, and which shared with the wilder philosophers that
| |
| curious crave for making fantastic patterns of the cosmos in the shape of maps
| |
| and genealogical trees. Those that are supposed to derive from the mysterious
| |
| Manes are called Manichean; kindred cults are more generally known as
| |
| Gnostic; they are mostly of a labyrinthine complexity, but the point to insist on
| |
| is the pessimism; the fact that nearly all in one form or another regarded the
| |
| creation of the world as the work of an evil spirit. Some of them had that
| |
| Asiatic atmosphere that surrounds Buddhism; the suggestion that life is a
| |
| corruption of the purity of being. Some of them suggested a purely spiritual
| |
| order which had been betrayed by the coarse and clumsy trick of making such
| |
| toys as the sun and moon and stars. Anyhow all this dark tide out of the
| |
| metaphysical sea in the midst of Asia poured through the dykes
| |
| simultaneously with the creed of Christ; but it is the whole point of the story
| |
| that the two were not the same; that they flowed like oil and water. That creed
| |
| remained in the shape of a miracle; a river still flowing through the sea. And
| |
| the proof of the miracle was practical once more; it was merely that while all
| |
| that sea was salt and bitter with the savour of death, of this one stream in the
| |
| midst of it a man could drink.
| |
|
| |
| Now that purity was preserved by dogmatic definitions and exclusions. It
| |
| could not possibly have been preserved by anything else. If the Church had not
| |
| renounced the Manicheans it might have become merely Manichean. If it had
| |
| not renounced the Gnostics it might have become Gnostic. But by the very fact
| |
| that it did renounce them it proved that it was not either Gnostic or Manichean.
| |
| At any rate it proved that something was not either Gnostic or Manichean; and
| |
| what could it be that condemned them, if it was not the original good news of
| |
| the runners from Bethlehem and the trumpet of the Resurrection? The early
| |
| Church was ascetic, but she proved that she was not pessimistic, simply by
| |
| condemning the pessimists. The creed declared that man was sinful, but it did
| |
| not declare that life was evil, and it proved it by damning those who did. The
| |
| condemnation of the early heretics is itself condemned as something crabbed
| |
| and narrow; but it was in truth the very proof that the Church meant to be
| |
| brotherly and broad. It proved that the primitive Catholics were specially eager
| |
| to explain that they did not think man utterly vile; that they did not think life
| |
| incurably miserable; that they did not think marriage a sin or procreation a
| |
| tragedy. They were ascetic because asceticism was the only possible purge of
| |
| the sins of the world; but in the very thunder of their anathemas they affirmed
| |
| for ever that their asceticism was not to be anti-human or anti-natural; that
| |
| they did wish to purge the world and not destroy it. And nothing else except
| |
| those anathemas could possibly have made it clear, amid a confusion which
| |
| still confuses them with their mortal enemies. Nothing else but dogma could
| |
| have resisted the riot of imaginative invention with which the pessimists were
| |
| waging their war against nature; with their Aeons and their Demiurge, their
| |
| strange Logos and their sinister Sophia. If the Church had not insisted on
| |
| theology, it would have melted into a mad mythology of the mystics, yet
| |
| further removed from reason or even from rationalism; and, above all yet
| |
| further removed from life and from the love of life. Remember that it would
| |
| have been an inverted mythology, one contradicting everything natural in
| |
| paganism; a mythology in which Pluto would be above Jupiter and Hades hang
| |
| higher than Olympus; in which Brahma and all that has the breath of life
| |
| would be subject to Seeva, shining with the eye of death.
| |
|
| |
| That the early Church was itself full of an ecstatic enthusiasm for renunciation
| |
| and virginity makes this distinction much more striking and not less so. It
| |
| makes all the more important the place where the dogma drew the line. A man
| |
| might crawl about on all fours like a beast because he was an ascetic. He might
| |
| stand night and day on the top of a pillar and be adored for being an ascetic,
| |
| but he could not say that the world was a mistake or the marriage state a sin
| |
| without being a heretic. What was it that thus deliberately disengaged itself
| |
| from eastern asceticism by sharp definition and fierce refusal, if it was not
| |
| something with an individuality of its own; and one that was quite different? If
| |
| the Catholics are to be confused with the Gnostics, we can only say it was not
| |
| their fault if they are. And it is rather hard that the Catholics should be blamed
| |
| by the same critics for persecuting the heretics and also for sympathising with
| |
| the heresy.
| |
|
| |
| The Church was not a Manichean movement if only because it was not a
| |
| movement at all. It was not even merely an ascetical movement, because it
| |
| was not a movement at all. It would be nearer the truth to call it the tamer of
| |
| asceticism than the mere leader or loosener of it. It was a thing having its own
| |
| theory of asceticism, its own type of asceticism, but most conspicuous at the
| |
| moment as the moderator of other theories and types. This is the only sense
| |
| that can be made, for instance, of the story of St. Augustine. As long as he was
| |
| a mere man of the world, a mere man drifting with his time, he actually was a
| |
| Manichean. It really was quite modern and fashionable to be a Manichean. But
| |
| when he became a Catholic, the people he instantly turned on and rent in
| |
| pieces were the Manicheans. The Catholic way of putting it is that he left off
| |
| being a pessimist to become an ascetic. But as the pessimists interpreted
| |
| asceticism, it ought to be said that he left off being an ascetic to become a
| |
| saint. The war upon life, the denial of nature, were exactly the things he had
| |
| already found in the heathen world outside the Church, and had to renounce
| |
| when he entered the Church. The very fact that St. Augustine remains a
| |
| somewhat sterner or sadder figure than St. Francis or St. Teresa only
| |
| accentuates the dilemma. Face to face with the gravest or even grimmest of
| |
| Catholics, we can still ask, 'Why did Catholicism make war on Manichees, if
| |
| Catholicism was Manichean?'
| |
|
| |
| Take another rationalistic explanation of the rise of Christendom. It is common
| |
| enough to find another critic saying, 'Christianity did not really rise at all; that
| |
| is, it did not merely rise from below; it was imposed from above. It is an
| |
| example of the power of the executive, especially in despotic states. The
| |
| Empire was really an Empire; that is, it was really ruled by the Emperor. One
| |
| of the Emperors happened to become a Christian. He might just as well have
| |
| become a Mithraist or a Jew or a Fire-Worshipper; it was common in the
| |
| decline of the Empire for eminent and educated people to adopt these eccentric
| |
| eastern cults. But when he adopted it, it became the official religion of the
| |
| Roman Empire; and when it became the official religion of the Roman
| |
| Empire, it became as strong, as universal and as invincible as the Roman
| |
| Empire. It has only remained in the world as a relic of that Empire; or, as
| |
| many have put it, it is but the ghost of Caesar still hovering over Rome.' This
| |
| also is a very ordinary line taken in the criticism of orthodoxy, to say that it
| |
| was only officialism that ever made it orthodoxy. And here again we can call
| |
| on the heretics to refute it.
| |
|
| |
| The whole great history of the Arian heresy might have been invented to
| |
| explode this idea. It is a very interesting history often repeated in this
| |
| connection; and the upshot of it is in that in so far as there ever was a merely
| |
| official religion, it actually died because it was merely an official religion; and
| |
| what destroyed it was the real religion. Arius advanced a version of
| |
| Christianity which moved, more or less vaguely, in the direction of what we
| |
| should call Unitarianism; though it was not the same, for it gave to Christ a
| |
| curious intermediary position between the divine and human. The point is that
| |
| it seemed to many more reasonable and less fanatical; and among these were
| |
| many of the educated class in a sort of reaction against the first romance of
| |
| conversion. Arians were a sort of moderates and a sort of modernists. And it
| |
| was felt that after the first squabbles this was the final form of rationalised
| |
| religion into which civilisation might well settle down. It was accepted by
| |
| Divus Caesar himself and became the official orthodoxy; the generals and
| |
| military princes drawn from the new barbarian powers of the north, full of the
| |
| future, supported it strongly. But the sequel is still more important. Exactly as
| |
| a modern man might pass through Unitarianism to complete agnosticism, so
| |
| the greatest of the Arian emperors ultimately shed the last and thinnest
| |
| pretense of Christianity; he abandoned ever Arius and returned to Apollo. He
| |
| was a Caesar of the Caesars; a soldier, a scholar, a man of large ambitions and
| |
| ideals; another of the philosopher kings. It seemed to him as if at his signal the
| |
| sun rose again. The oracles began to speak like birds beginning to sing at
| |
| dawn; paganism was itself again; the gods returned. It seemed the end of that
| |
| strange interlude of an alien superstition. And indeed it was the end of it, so far
| |
| as there was a mere interlude of mere superstition. It was the end of it, in so far
| |
| as it was the fad of an emperor or the fashion of a generation. If there really
| |
| was something that began with Constantine, then it ended with Julian.
| |
| But there was something that did not end. There had arisen in that hour of
| |
| history, defiant above the democratic tumult of the Councils of the Church,
| |
| Athanasius against the world. We may pause upon the point at issue; because
| |
| it is relevant to the whole of this religious history, and the modern world
| |
| seems to miss the whole point of it. We might put it this way. If there is one
| |
| question which the enlightened and liberal have the habit of deriding and
| |
| holding up as a dreadful example of barren dogma and senseless sectarian
| |
| strife, it is this Athanasian question of the Co-Eternity of the Divine Son. On
| |
| the other hand, if there is one thing that the same liberals always offer us as a
| |
| piece of pure and simple Christianity, untroubled by doctrinal disputes, it is the
| |
| single sentence, 'God is Love.' Yet the two statements are almost identical; at
| |
| least one is very nearly nonsense without the other. The barren dogma is only
| |
| the logical way of stating the beautiful sentiment. For if there be a being
| |
| without beginning, existing before all things, was He loving when there was
| |
| nothing to be loved? If through that unthinkable eternity He is lonely, what is
| |
| the meaning of saying He is love? The only justification of such a mystery is
| |
| the mystical conception that in His own nature there was something analogous
| |
| to self-expression; something of what begets and beholds what it has begotten.
| |
| Without some such idea, it is really illogical to complicate the ultimate essence
| |
| of deity with an idea like love. If the moderns really want a simple religion of
| |
| love, they must look for it in the Athanasian Creed. The truth is that the
| |
| trumpet of true Christianity, the challenge of the charities and simplicities of
| |
| Bethlehem or Christmas Day never rang out more arrestingly and
| |
| unmistakably than in the defiance of Athanasius to the cold compromise of the
| |
| Arians. It was emphatically he who really was fighting for a God of Love
| |
| against a God of colourless and remote cosmic control; the God of the stoics
| |
| and the agnostics. It was emphatically he who was fighting for the Holy Child
| |
| against the grey deity of the Pharisees and the Sadducees. He was fighting for
| |
| that very balance of beautiful interdependence and intimacy, in the very
| |
| Trinity of the Divine Nature, that draws our hearts to the Trinity of the Holy
| |
| Family. His dogma, if the phrase be not misunderstood, turns even God into a
| |
| Holy Family.
| |
|
| |
| That this purely Christian dogma actually for a second time rebelled against
| |
| the Empire, and actually for a second time refounded the Church in spite of the
| |
| Empire, is itself a proof that there was something positive and personal
| |
| working in the world, other than whatever official faith the Empire chose to
| |
| adopt. This power utterly destroyed the official faith that the Empire did adopt.
| |
| It went on its own way as it is going on its own way still. There are any
| |
| number of other examples in which is repeated precisely the same process we
| |
| have reviewed in the case of the Manichean and the Arian. A few centuries
| |
| afterwards, for instance, the Church had to maintain the same Trinity, which is
| |
| simply the logical side of love, against another appearance of the isolated and
| |
| simplified deity in the religion of Islam. Yet there are some who cannot see
| |
| what the Crusaders were fighting for; and some even who talk as if
| |
| Christianity had never been anything but a form of what they call Hebraism
| |
| coming in with the decay of Hellenism. Those people must certainly be very
| |
| much puzzled by the war between the Crescent and the Cross. If Christianity
| |
| had never been anything but a simpler morality sweeping away polytheism,
| |
| there is no reason why Christendom should not have been swept into Islam.
| |
| The truth is that Islam itself was a barbaric reaction against that very humane
| |
| complexity that is really a Christian character; that idea of balance in the deity,
| |
| as of balance in the family, that makes that creed a sort of sanity, and that
| |
| sanity the soul of civilisation. And that is why the Church is from the first a
| |
| thing holding its own position and point of view, quite apart from the accidents
| |
| and anarchies of its age. That is why it deals blows impartially right and left, at
| |
| the pessimism of the Manichean or the optimism of the Pelagian. It was not a
| |
| Manichean movement because it was not a movement at all. It was not an
| |
| official fashion because it was not a fashion at all. It was something that could
| |
| coincide with movements and fashions, could control them and could survive
| |
| them.
| |
|
| |
| So might rise from their graves the great heresiarchs to confound their
| |
| comrades of to-day. There is nothing that the critics now affirm that we cannot
| |
| call on these great witnesses to deny. The modern critic will say lightly enough
| |
| that Christianity was but a reaction into asceticism and anti-natural spirituality,
| |
| a dance of fakirs furious against life and love. But Manes the great mystic will
| |
| answer them from his secret throne and cry, 'These Christians have no right to
| |
| be called spiritual; these Christians have no title to be called ascetics, they who
| |
| compromised with the curse of life and all the filth of the family. Through
| |
| them the earth is still foul with fruit and harvest and polluted with population.
| |
|
| |
| Theirs was no movement against nature, or my children would have carried it
| |
| to triumph; but these fools renewed the world when I would have ended it with
| |
| a gesture.' And another critic will write that the Church was but the shadow of
| |
| the Empire, the fad of a chance Emperor, and that it remains in Europe only as
| |
| the ghost of the power of Rome. And Arius the deacon will answer out of the
| |
| darkness of oblivious `No, indeed, or the world would have followed my more
| |
| reasonable religion. For mine went down before demagogues and men defying
| |
| Caesar; and around my champion was the purple cloak and mine was the glory
| |
| of the eagles. It was not for lack of these things that I failed.' And yet a third
| |
| modern will maintain that the creed spread only as a sort of panic of hell-fire;
| |
| men everywhere attempting impossible things in fleeing from incredible
| |
| vengeance; a nightmare of imaginary remorse; and such an explanation will
| |
| satisfy many who see something dreadful in the doctrine of orthodoxy. And
| |
| then there will go up against it the terrible voice of Tertullian, saying, 'And
| |
| why then was I cast out; and why did soft hearts and heads decide against me
| |
| when I proclaimed the perdition of all sinners; and what was this power that
| |
| thwarted me when I threatened all backsliders with hell? For none ever went
| |
| up that hard road so far as I; and mine was the Credo Quia Impossible.' Then
| |
| there is the fourth suggestion that there was something of the Semitic secret
| |
| society in the whole matter; that it was a new invasion of the nomad spirit
| |
| shaking a kindlier and more comfortable paganism, its cities and its household
| |
| gods; whereby the jealous monotheistic races could after all establish their
| |
| jealous God. And Mahomet shall answer out of the whirlwind, the red
| |
| whirlwind of the desert, 'Who ever served the jealousy of God as I did or left
| |
| him more lonely in the sky? Who ever paid more honour to Moses and
| |
| Abraham or won more victories over idols and the images of paganism? And
| |
| what was this thing that thrust me back with the energy of a thing alive; whose
| |
| fanaticism could drive me from Sicily and tear up my deep roots out of the
| |
| rock of Spain? What faith was theirs who thronged in thousands of every class
| |
| a country crying out that my ruin was the will of God; and what hurled great
| |
| Godfrey as from a catapult over the wall of Jerusalem, and what brought great
| |
| Sobieski like a thunderbolt to the gates of Vienna? I think there was more than
| |
| you fancy in the religion that has so matched itself with mine.'
| |
| Those who would suggest that the faith was a fanaticism are doomed to an
| |
| eternal perplexity. In their account it is bound to appear as fanatical for
| |
| nothing, and fanatical against everything. It is ascetical and at war with
| |
| ascetics, Roman and in revolt against Rome, monotheistic and fighting
| |
| furiously against monotheism; harsh in its condemnation of harshness; a riddle
| |
| not to be explained even as unreason. And what sort of unreason is it that
| |
| seems reasonable to millions of educated Europeans through all the
| |
| revolutions of some sixteen hundred years? People are not amused with a
| |
| puzzle or a paradox or a mere muddle in the mind for all that time. I know of
| |
| no explanation except that such a thing is not unreason but reason; that if it is
| |
| fanatical it is fanatical for reason and fanatical against all the unreasonable
| |
| things. That is the only explanation I can find of a thing from the first so
| |
| detached and so confident, condemning things that looked so like itself,
| |
| refusing help from powers that seemed so essential to its existence, sharing on
| |
| its human side all the passions of the age, yet always at the supreme moment
| |
| suddenly rising superior to them, never saying exactly what it was expected to
| |
| say and never needing to unsay what it had said; I can find no explanation
| |
| except that, like Pallas from the brain of Jove, it had indeed come forth out of
| |
| the mind of God, mature and mighty and armed for judgement and for war.
| |
|
| |
| ===V. The Escape from Paganism===
| |
| The modern missionary, with his palm-leaf hat and his umbrella, has become
| |
| rather a figure of fun. He is chaffed among men of the world for the ease with
| |
| which he can be eaten by cannibals and the narrow bigotry which makes him
| |
| regard the cannibal culture as lower than his own. Perhaps the best part of the
| |
| joke is that the men of the world do not see that the joke is against themselves.
| |
| It is rather ridiculous to ask a man just about to be boiled in a pot and eaten, at
| |
| a purely religious feast, why he does not regard all religions as equally friendly
| |
| and fraternal. But there is a more subtle criticism uttered against the more oldfashioned
| |
| missionary; to the effect that he generalises too broadly about the
| |
| heathen and pays too little attention to the difference between Mahomet and
| |
| Mumbo-Jumbo. There was probably truth in this complaint, especially in the
| |
| past; but it is my main contention here that the exaggeration is all the other
| |
| way at present. It is the temptation of the professors to treat mythologies too
| |
| much as theologies; as things thoroughly thought out are seriously held. It is
| |
| the temptation of the intellectuals to take much too seriously the fine shades of
| |
| various schools in the rather irresponsible metaphysics of Asia. Above all it is
| |
| their temptation to miss the real truth implied in the idea of Aquinas contra
| |
| Gentiles or Athanasius contra mundum.
| |
|
| |
| If the missionary says, in fact, that he is exceptional in being a Christian, and
| |
| that the rest of the races and religions can be collectively classified as heathen,
| |
| he is perfectly right. He may say it in quite the wrong spirit, in which case he
| |
| is spiritually wrong. But in the cold light of philosophy and history, he is
| |
| intellectually right. He may not be right minded, but he is right. He may not
| |
| even have a right to be right, but he is right. The outer world to which he
| |
| brings his creed really is some thing subject to certain generalisations covering
| |
| all its varieties, and is not merely a variety of similar creeds. Perhaps it is in
| |
| any case too much of a temptation to pride or hypocrisy to call it heathenry.
| |
| Perhaps it could be better simply to call it humanity. But there are certain
| |
| broad characteristics of what we call humanity while it remains in what we
| |
| call heathenry. They are not necessarily bad characteristics; some of them are
| |
| worthy of the respect of Christendom; some of them have been absorbed and
| |
| transfigured in the substance of Christendom. But they existed before
| |
| Christendom and they still exist outside Christendom, as certainly as the sea
| |
| existed before a boat and all round a boat; and they have as strong and as
| |
| universal and as unmistakable a savour as the sea.
| |
|
| |
| For instance, all real scholars who have studied the Greek and Roman culture
| |
| say one thing about it. They agree that in the ancient world religion was one
| |
| thing and philosophy quite another. There was very little effort to rationalise
| |
| and at the same time to realise a real belief in the gods. There was very little
| |
| pretense of any such real belief among the philosophers. But neither had the
| |
| passion or perhaps the power to persecute the others save in particular and
| |
| peculiar cases; and neither the philosopher in his school nor the priest in his
| |
| temple seems ever to have seriously contemplated his own concept as covering
| |
| the world. A priest sacrificing to Artemis in Calydon did not seem to think that
| |
| people would some day sacrifice to her instead of to Isis beyond the sea; a
| |
| sage following the vegetarian rule of the Neo-Pythagoreans did not seem to
| |
| think it would universally prevail and exclude the methods of Epictetus or
| |
| Epicurus. We may call this liberality if we like; I am not dealing with an
| |
| argument but describing an atmosphere. All this, I say, is admitted by all
| |
| scholars; but what neither the learned nor the unlearned have fully realised,
| |
| perhaps, is that this description is really an exact description of all non-
| |
| Christian civilisation today; and especially of the great civilisations of the
| |
| East. Eastern paganism really is much more all of a piece, just as ancient
| |
| paganism was much more all of a piece, than the modern critics admit. It is a
| |
| many-coloured Persian Carpet as the other was a varied and tessellated Roman
| |
| pavement; but the one real crack right across that pavement came from the
| |
| earthquake of the Crucifixion.
| |
|
| |
| The modern European seeking his religion in Asia is reading his religion into
| |
| Asia. Religion there is something different; it is both more and less. He is like
| |
| a man mapping out the sea as land; marking waves as mountains; not
| |
| understanding the nature of its peculiar permanence. It is perfectly true that
| |
| Asia has its own dignity and poetry and high civilisation. But it is not in the
| |
| least true that Asia has its own definite dominions of moral government, where
| |
| all loyalty is conceived in terms of morality; as when we say that Ireland is
| |
| Catholic or that New England was Puritan. The map is not marked out in
| |
| religions, in our sense of churches. The state of mind is far more subtle, more
| |
| relative, more secretive, more varied and changing, like the colours of the
| |
| snake. The Moslem is the nearest approach to a militant Christian; and that is
| |
| precisely because he is a much nearer approach to an envoy from western
| |
| civilisation. The Moslem in the heart of Asia almost stands for the soul of
| |
| Europe. And as he stands between them and Europe in the matter of space so
| |
| he stands between them and Christianity in the matter of time. In that sense the
| |
| Moslems in Asia are merely like the Nestorians in Asia. Islam, historically
| |
| speaking, is the greatest of the Eastern heresies. It owed something to the quite
| |
| isolated and unique individuality of Israel; but it owed more to Byzantium and
| |
| the theological enthusiasm of Christendom. It owed something even to the
| |
| Crusades. It owed nothing whatever to Asia. It owed nothing to the
| |
| atmosphere of the ancient and traditional world of Asia, with its immemorial
| |
| etiquette and its bottomless or bewildering philosophies. All that ancient and
| |
| actual Asia felt the entrance of Islam as something foreign and western and
| |
| warlike, piercing it like a spear.
| |
|
| |
| Even where we might trace in dotted lines the domains of Asiatic religions, we
| |
| should probably be reading into them something dogmatic and ethical
| |
| belonging to our own religion. It is as if a European ignorant of the American
| |
| atmosphere were to suppose that each 'state' was a separate sovereign state as
| |
| patriotic as France or Poland; or that when a Yankee referred fondly to his
| |
| 'home town' he meant he had no other nation, like a citizen of ancient Athens
| |
| or Rome. As he would be reading a particular sort of loyalty into America, so
| |
| we are reading a particular sort of loyalty into Asia. There are loyalties of
| |
| other kinds; but not what men in the West mean by being a believer, by trying
| |
| to be a Christian, by being a good Protestant or a practising Catholic. In the
| |
| intellectual world it means something far more vague and varied by doubts and
| |
| speculations. In the moral world it means something far more loose and
| |
| drifting. A professor of Persian at one of our great universities, so passionate a
| |
| partisan of the East as practically to profess a contempt for the West, said to a
| |
| friend of mine: 'You will never understand oriental religions, because you
| |
| always conceive religion as connected with ethics. This kind has really nothing
| |
| to do with ethics.' We have most of us known some Masters of the Higher
| |
| Wisdom, some Pilgrims upon the Path to Power, some eastern esoteric saints
| |
| and seers, who had really nothing to do with ethics. Something different,
| |
| something detached and irresponsible, tinges the moral atmosphere of Asia
| |
| and touches even that of Islam. It was very realistically caught in the
| |
| atmosphere of Hassan; and a very horrible atmosphere too. It is even more
| |
| vivid in such glimpses as we get of the genuine and ancient cults of Asia.
| |
| Deeper than the depths of metaphysics, far down in the abysses of mystical
| |
| meditations under all that solemn universe of spiritual things, is a secret, an
| |
| intangible and a terrible levity. It does not really very much matter what one
| |
| does. Either because they do not believe in a devil, or because they do believe
| |
| in a destiny, or because experience here is everything and eternal life
| |
| something totally different, but for some reason they are totally different. I
| |
| have read somewhere that there were three great friends famous in medieval
| |
| Persia for their unity of mind. One became the responsible and respected
| |
| Vizier of the Great King; the second was the poet Omar, pessimist and
| |
| epicurean, drinking wine in mockery of Mahomet; the third was the Old Man
| |
| of the Mountain who maddened his people with hashish that they might
| |
| murder other people with daggers. It does not really much matter what one
| |
| does.
| |
|
| |
| The Sultan in Hassan would have understood all those three men; indeed he
| |
| was all those three men. But this sort of universalist cannot have what we call
| |
| a character; it is what we call a chaos. He cannot choose; he cannot fight; he
| |
| cannot repent; he cannot hope. He is not in the same sense creating something;
| |
| for creation means rejection. He is not, in our religious phrase, making his
| |
| soul. For our doctrine of salvation does really mean a labour like that of a man
| |
| trying to make a statue beautiful; a victory with wings. For that there must be a
| |
| final choice, for a man cannot make statues without rejecting stone. And there
| |
| really is this ultimate unmorality behind the metaphysics of Asia. And the
| |
| reason is that there has been nothing through all those unthinkable ages to
| |
| bring the human mind sharply to the point; to tell it that the time has come to
| |
| choose. The mind has lived too much in eternity. The soul has been too
| |
| immortal, in the special sense that it ignores the idea of mortal sin. It has had
| |
| too much of eternity, in the sense that it has not had enough of the hour of
| |
| death and the day of judgement. It is not crucial enough; in the literal sense
| |
| that it has not had enough of the cross. That is what we mean when we say that
| |
| Asia is very old. But strictly speaking Europe is quite as old as Asia; indeed in
| |
| a sense any place is as old as any other place. What we mean is that Europe
| |
| has not merely gone on growing older. It has been born again.
| |
|
| |
| Asia is all humanity; as it has worked out its human doom. Asia, in its vast
| |
| territory, in its varied populations, in its heights of past achievement and its
| |
| depths of dark speculation, is itself a world; and represents something of what
| |
| we mean when we speak of the world. It is a cosmos rather than a continent. It
| |
| is the world as man has made it; and contains many of the most wonderful
| |
| things that man has made. Therefore Asia stands as the one representative of
| |
| paganism and the one rival to Christendom. But everywhere else where we get
| |
| glimpses of that mortal destiny, they suggest stages in the same story. Where
| |
| Asia trails away into the southern archipelagoes of the savages, or where a
| |
| darkness full of nameless shapes dwells in the heart of Africa, or where the
| |
| last survivors of lost races linger in the cold volcano of prehistoric America, it
| |
| is all the same story; sometimes perhaps later chapters of the same story. It is
| |
| men entangled in the forest of their own mythology; it is men drowned in the
| |
| sea of their own metaphysics. Polytheists have grown weary of the wildest of
| |
| fictions. Monotheists have grown weary of the most wonderful of truths.
| |
| Diabolists here and there have such a hatred of heaven and earth that they have
| |
| tried to take refuge in hell. It is the Fall of Man; and it is exactly that fall that
| |
| was being felt by our own fathers at the first moment of the Roman decline.
| |
| We also were going down that side road; down that easy slope; following the
| |
| magnificent procession of the high civilisations of the world.
| |
|
| |
| If the Church had not entered the world then, it seems probable that Europe
| |
| would be now very much what Asia is now. Something may be allowed for a
| |
| real difference of race and environment, visible in the ancient as in the modern
| |
| world. But after all we talk about the changeless East very largely because it
| |
| has not suffered the great change. Paganism in its last phase showed
| |
| considerable signs of becoming equally changeless. This would not mean that
| |
| new schools or sects of philosophy would not arise; as new schools did arise in
| |
| Antiquity and do arise in Asia. It does not mean that there would be no real
| |
| mystics or visionaries; as there were mystics in Antiquity and are mystics in
| |
| Asia. It does not mean that there would be no social codes, as there were codes
| |
| in Antiquity and are codes in Asia. It does not mean that there could not be
| |
| good men or happy lives, for God has given all men a conscience and
| |
| conscience can give all men a kind of peace. But it does mean that the tone
| |
| and proportion of all these things, and especially the proportion of good and
| |
| evil things, would be in the unchanged West what they are in the changeless
| |
| East. And nobody who looks at that changeless East honestly, and with a real
| |
| sympathy, can believe that there is anything there remotely resembling the
| |
| challenge and revolution of the Faith.
| |
|
| |
| In short, if classic paganism had lingered until now, a number of things might
| |
| well have lingered with it; and they would look very like what we call the
| |
| religions of the East. There would still be Pythagoreans teaching reincarnation,
| |
| as there are still Hindus teaching reincarnation. There would still be Stoics
| |
| making a religion out of reason and virtue, as there are still Confucians making
| |
| a religion out of reason and virtue. There would still be Neo-Platonists
| |
| studying transcendental truths, the meaning of which was mysterious to other
| |
| people and disputed even amongst themselves; as the Buddhists still study a
| |
| transcendentalism mysterious to others and disputed among themselves. There
| |
| would still be intelligent Apollonians apparently worshipping the sun-god but
| |
| explaining that they were worshipping the divine principle; just as there are
| |
| still intelligent Parsees apparently worshipping the sun but explaining that they
| |
| are worshipping the deity. There would still be wild Dionysians dancing on the
| |
| mountain as there are still wild Dervishes dancing in the desert. There would
| |
| still be crowds of people attending the popular feasts of the gods, in pagan
| |
| Europe as in pagan Asia. There would still be crowds of gods, local and other,
| |
| for them to worship. And there would still be a great many more people who
| |
| worshipped them than people who believed in them. Finally there would still
| |
| be a very large number of people who did worship gods and did believe in
| |
| gods; and who believed in gods and worshipped gods simply because they
| |
| were demons. There would still be Levantines secretly sacrificing to Moloch
| |
| as there are still Thugs secretly sacrificing to Kalee. There would still be a
| |
| great deal of magic; and a great deal of it would be black magic. There would
| |
| still be a considerable admiration of Seneca and a considerable imitation of
| |
| Nero; just as the exalted epigrams of Confucius could coexist with the tortures
| |
| of China. And over all that tangled forest of traditions growing wild or
| |
| withering would brood the broad silence of a singular and even nameless
| |
| mood; but the nearest name of it is nothing. All these things, good and bad,
| |
| would have an indescribable air of being too old to die.
| |
|
| |
| None of these things occupying Europe in the absence of Christendom would
| |
| bear the least likeness to Christendom. Since the Pythagorean Metempsychosis
| |
| would still be there, we might call it the Pythagorean religion as we talk about
| |
| the Buddhist religion. As the noble maxims of Socrates would still be there,
| |
| we might call it the Socratic religion as we talk about the Confucian religion.
| |
| As the popular holiday was still marked by a mythological hymn to Adonis,
| |
| we might call it the religion of Adonis as we talk about the religion of
| |
| Juggernaut. As literature would still be based on the Greek mythology, we
| |
| might call that mythology a religion, as we call the Hindu mythology a
| |
| religion. We might say that there were so many thousands or millions of
| |
| people belonging to that religion, in the sense of frequenting such temples or
| |
| merely living in a land full of such temples. But if we called the last tradition
| |
| of Pythagoras or the lingering legend of Adonis by the name of a religion, then
| |
| we must find some other name for the Church of Christ.
| |
|
| |
| If anybody says that philosophic maxims presented through many ages, or
| |
| mythological temples frequented by many people, are things of the same class
| |
| and category as the Church, it is enough to answer quite simply that they are
| |
| not. Nobody thinks they are the same when he sees them in the old civilisation
| |
| of Greece and Rome; nobody would think they were the same if that
| |
| civilisation had lasted two thousand years longer and existed at the present
| |
| day; nobody can in reason think they are the same in the parallel pagan
| |
| civilisation in the East, as it is at the present day. None of these philosophies
| |
| or mythologies are anything like a Church; certainly nothing like a Church
| |
| Militant. And, as I have shown elsewhere, even if this rule were not already
| |
| proved, the exception would prove the rule. The rule is that pre-Christian or
| |
| pagan history does not produce a Church Militant; and the exception, or what
| |
| some would call the exception, is that Islam is at least militant if it is not
| |
| Church. And that is precisely because Islam is the one religious rival that is
| |
| not pre-Christian and therefore not in that sense pagan. Islam was a product of
| |
| Christianity; even if it was a by-product; even if it was a bad product. It was a
| |
| heresy or parody emulating and therefore imitating the Church. It is no more
| |
| surprising that Mahomedanism had something of her fighting spirit than that
| |
| Quakerism had something of her peaceful spirit. After Christianity there are
| |
| any number of such emulations or extensions. Before it there are none.
| |
|
| |
| The Church Militant is thus unique because it is an army marching to effect a
| |
| universal deliverance. The bondage from which the world is thus to be
| |
| delivered is something that is very well symbolised by the state of Asia as by
| |
| the state of pagan Europe. I do not mean merely their moral or immoral state.
| |
| The missionary, as a matter of fact, has much more to say for himself than the
| |
| enlightened imagine even when he says that the heathen are idolatrous and
| |
| immoral. A touch or two of realistic experience about Eastern religion, even
| |
| about Moslem religion, will reveal some startling insensibilities in ethics; such
| |
| as the practical indifference to the line between passion and perversion. It is
| |
| not prejudice but practical experience which says that Asia is full of demons as
| |
| well as gods. But the evil I mean is in the mind. And it is in the mind wherever
| |
| the mind has worked for a long time alone. It is what happens when all
| |
| dreaming and thinking have come to an end in an emptiness that is at once
| |
| negation and necessity. It sounds like an anarchy, but it is also a slavery. It is
| |
| what has been called already the wheel of Asia; all those recurrent arguments
| |
| about cause and effect or things beginning and ending in the mind, which
| |
| make it impossible for the soul really to strike out and go anywhere or do
| |
| anything. And the point is that it is not necessarily peculiar to Asiatics; it
| |
| would have been true in the end of Europeans--if something had not happened.
| |
| If the Church Militant had not been a thing marching, all men would have
| |
| been marking time. If the Church Militant had not endured a discipline, all
| |
| men would have endured a slavery.
| |
|
| |
| What that universal yet fighting faith brought into the world was hope.
| |
| Perhaps the one thing common to mythology and philosophy was that both
| |
| were really sad; in the sense that they had not this hope even if they had
| |
| touches of faith or charity. We may call Buddhism a faith; though to us it
| |
| seems more like a doubt. We may call the Lord of Compassion a Lord of
| |
| Charity, though it seems to us a very pessimist sort of pity. But those who
| |
| insist most on the antiquity and size of such cults must agree that in all their
| |
| ages they have not covered all their areas with that sort of practical and
| |
| pugnacious hope. In Christendom hope has never been absent; rather it has
| |
| been errant, extravagant, excessively fixed upon fugitive chances. Its perpetual
| |
| revolution and reconstruction has at least been an evidence of people being in
| |
| better spirits. Europe did very truly renew its youth like the eagles; just as the
| |
| eagles of Rome rose again over the legions of Napoleon, or we have seen
| |
| soaring but yesterday the silver eagle of Poland. But in the Polish case ever
| |
| revolution always went with religion. Napoleon himself sought a
| |
| reconciliation with religion. Religion could never be finally separated even
| |
| from the most hostile of the hopes; simply because it was the very source of
| |
| the hopefulness. And the cause of this is to be found simply in the religion
| |
| itself. Those who quarrel about it seldom even consider it in itself. There is
| |
| neither space nor place for such a full consideration here; but a word may be
| |
| said to explain a reconciliation that always recurs and still seems to require
| |
| explanation.
| |
|
| |
| There will be no end to the weary debates about liberalising theology, until
| |
| people face the fact that the only liberal part of it is really the dogmatic part. If
| |
| dogma is incredible, it is because it is incredibly liberal. If it is irrational, it can
| |
| only be in giving us more assurance of freedom than is justified by reason. The
| |
| obvious example is that essential form of freedom which we call free-will. It is
| |
| absurd to say that a man shows his liberality in denying his liberty. But it is
| |
| tenable that he has to affirm a transcendental doctrine in order to affirm his
| |
| liberty. There is a sense in which we might reasonably say that if man has a
| |
| primary power of choice, he has in that fact a super-natural power of creation,
| |
| as if he could raise the dead or give birth to the unbegotten. Possibly in that
| |
| case a man must be a miracle; and certainly in that case he must be a miracle
| |
| in order to be a man; and most certainly in order to be a free man. But it is
| |
| absurd to forbid him to be a free man and do it in the name of a more free
| |
| religion.
| |
|
| |
| But it is true in twenty other matters. Anybody who believes at all in God must
| |
| believe in the absolute supremacy of God. But in so far as that supremacy does
| |
| allow of any degrees that can be called liberal or illiberal, it is self-evident that
| |
| the illiberal power is the deity of the rationalists and the liberal power is the
| |
| deity of the dogmatists. Exactly in proportion as you turn monotheism into
| |
| monism you turn it into despotism. It is precisely the unknown God of the
| |
| scientist, with his impenetrable purpose and his inevitable and unalterable law,
| |
| that reminds us of a Prussian autocrat making rigid plans in a remote tent and
| |
| moving mankind like machinery. It is precisely the God of miracles and of
| |
| answered prayers who reminds us of a liberal and popular prince, receiving
| |
| petitions, listening to parliaments and considering the cases of a whole people.
| |
| I am not now arguing the rationality of this conception in other respects; as a
| |
| matter of fact it is not, as some suppose, irrational; for there is nothing
| |
| irrational in the wisest and most well-informed king acting differently
| |
| according to the action of those he wishes to save. But I am here only noting
| |
| the general nature of liberality, or of free or enlarged atmosphere of action.
| |
| And in this respect it is certain that the king can only be what we call
| |
| magnanimous if he is what some call capricious. It is the Catholic, who has the
| |
| feeling that his prayers do make a difference, when offered for the living and
| |
| the dead, who also has the feeling of living like a free citizen in something
| |
| almost like a constitutional commonwealth. It is the monist who lives under a
| |
| single iron law who must have the feeling of living like a slave under a sultan.
| |
| Indeed I believe that the original use of the word suffragium, which we now
| |
| use in politics for a vote, was that employed in theology about a prayer. The
| |
| dead in Purgatory were said to have the suffrages of the living. And in this
| |
| sense, of a sort of right of petition to the supreme ruler, we may truly say that
| |
| the whole of the Communion of Saints, as well as the whole of the Church
| |
| Militant, is founded on universal suffrage.
| |
|
| |
| But above all, it is true of the most tremendous issue; of that tragedy which has
| |
| created the divine comedy of our creed. Nothing short of the extreme and
| |
| strong and startling doctrine of the divinity of Christ will give that particular
| |
| effect that can truly stir the popular sense like a trumpet; the idea of the king
| |
| himself serving in the ranks like a common soldier. By making that figure
| |
| merely human we make that story much less human. We take away the point
| |
| of the story which actually pierces humanity; the point of the story which was
| |
| quite literally the point of a spear. It does not especially humanise the universe
| |
| to say that good and wise men can die for their opinions; any more than it
| |
| would be any sort of uproariously popular news in an army that good soldiers
| |
| may easily get killed. It is no news that King Leonidas is dead any more than
| |
| that Queen Anne is dead; and men did not wait for Christianity to be men, in
| |
| the full sense of being heroes. But if we are describing, for the moment, the
| |
| atmosphere of what is generous and popular and even picturesque, any
| |
| knowledge of human nature will tell us that no sufferings of the sons of men,
| |
| or even of the servants of God, strike the same note as the notion of the master
| |
| suffering instead of his servants. And this is given by the theological and
| |
| emphatically not by the scientific deity. No mysterious monarch, hidden in his
| |
| starry pavilion at the base of the cosmic campaign, is in the least like that
| |
| celestial chivalry of the Captain who carries his five wounds in the front of
| |
| battle.
| |
|
| |
| What the denouncer of dogma really means is not that dogma is bad; but rather
| |
| that dogma is too good to be true. That is, he means that dogma is too liberal
| |
| to be likely. Dogma gives man too much freedom when it permits him to fall.
| |
| Dogma gives even God too much freedom when it permits him to die. That is
| |
| what the intelligent sceptics ought to say; and it is not in the least my intention
| |
| to deny that there is something to be said for it. They mean that the universe is
| |
| itself a universal prison; that existence itself is a limitation and a control; and it
| |
| is not for nothing that they call causation a chain. In a word, they mean quite
| |
| simply that they cannot believe these things; not in the least that they are
| |
| unworthy of belief. We say not lightly but very literally, that the truth has
| |
| made us free. They say that it makes us so free that it cannot be the truth. To
| |
| them it is like believing in fairyland to believe in such freedom as we enjoy. It
| |
| is like believing in men with wings to entertain the fancy of men with wills. It
| |
| is like accepting a fable about a squirrel in conversation with a mountain to
| |
| believe in a man who is free to ask or a God who is free to answer. This is a
| |
| manly and a rational negation for which I for one shall always show respect.
| |
| But I decline to show any respect for those who first of all clip the wings and
| |
| cage the squirrel, rivet the chains and refuse the freedom, close all the doors of
| |
| the cosmic prison on us with a clang of eternal iron, tell us that our
| |
| emancipation is a dream and our dungeon a necessity; and then calmly turn
| |
| round and tell us they have a freer thought and a more liberal theology.
| |
| The moral of all this is an old one; that religion is revelation. In other words it
| |
| is a vision, and a vision received by faith; but it is a vision of reality. The faith
| |
| consists in a conviction of its reality. That, for example, is the difference
| |
| between a vision and a day-dream. And that is the difference between religion
| |
| and mythology. That is the difference between faith and all that fancy-work,
| |
| quite human and more or less healthy, which we considered under the head of
| |
| mythology. There is something in the reasonable use of the very word vision
| |
| that implies two things about it; first that it comes very rarely, possibly that it
| |
| comes only once; and secondly that it probably comes once and for all. A daydream
| |
| may come every day. A day-dream may be different every day. It is
| |
| something more than the difference between telling ghost-stories and meeting
| |
| a ghost.
| |
|
| |
| But if it is not a mythology neither is it a philosophy. It is not a philosophy
| |
| because, being a vision, it is not a pattern but a picture. It is not one of those
| |
| simplifications which resolve everything into an abstract explanation; as that
| |
| everything is recurrent; or everything is relative; or everything is inevitable; or
| |
| everything is illusive. It is not a process but a story. It has proportions, of the
| |
| sort seen in a picture or a story; it has not the regular repetitions of a pattern or
| |
| a process; but it replaces them by being convincing as a picture or a story is
| |
| convincing. In other words, it is exactly, as the phrase goes, like life. For
| |
| indeed it is life. An example of what is meant here might well be found in the
| |
| treatment of the problem of evil. It is easy enough to make a plan of life of
| |
| which the background is black, as the pessimists do; and then admit a speck or
| |
| two of star-dust more or less accidental, or at least in the literal sense
| |
| insignificant. And it is easy enough to make another plan on white paper, as
| |
| the Christian Scientists do, and explain or explain away somehow such dots or
| |
| smudges as may be difficult to deny. Lastly it is easiest of all perhaps, to say
| |
| as the dualists do, that life is like a chess-board in which the two are equal, and
| |
| can as truly be said to consist of white squares on a black board or of black
| |
| squares on a white board. But every man feels in his heart that none of these
| |
| three paper plans is like life; that none of these worlds is one in which he can
| |
| live. Something tells him that the ultimate idea of a world is not bad or even
| |
| neutral; staring at the sky or the grass or the truths of mathematics or even a
| |
| new-laid egg, he has a vague feeling like the shadow of that saying of the great
| |
| Christian philosopher, St. Thomas Aquinas, 'Every existence, as such, is good.'
| |
| On the other hand, something else tells him that it is unmanly and debased and
| |
| even diseased to minimise evil to a dot or even a blot. He realises that
| |
| optimism is morbid. It is if possible even more morbid than pessimism. These
| |
| vague but healthy feelings, if he followed them out, would result in the idea
| |
| that evil is in some way an exception but an enormous exception; and
| |
| ultimately that evil is an invasion or yet more truly a rebellion. He does not
| |
| think that everything is right or that every thing is wrong, or that everything is
| |
| equally right and wrong. But he does think that right has a right to be right and
| |
| therefore a right to be there, and wrong has no right to be wrong and therefore
| |
| no right to be there. It is the prince of the world; but it is also a usurper. So he
| |
| will apprehend vaguely what the vision will give to him vividly; no less than
| |
| all that strange story of treason in heaven and the great desertion by which evil
| |
| damaged and tried to destroy a cosmos that it could not create. It is a very
| |
| strange story and its proportions and its lines and colours are as arbitrary and
| |
| absolute as the artistic composition of a picture. It is a vision which we do in
| |
| fact symbolise in pictures by titanic limbs and passionate tints of plumage; all
| |
| that abysmal vision of falling stars and the peacock panoplies of the night. But
| |
| that strange story has one small advantage over the diagrams. It is like life.
| |
|
| |
| Another example might be found, not in the problem of evil, but in what is
| |
| called the problem of progress. One of the ablest agnostics of the age once
| |
| asked me whether I thought mankind grew better or grew worse or remained
| |
| the same. He was confident that the alternative covered all possibilities. He did
| |
| not see that it only covered patterns and not pictures; processes and not stories.
| |
| I asked him whether he thought that Mr. Smith of Golder's Green got better or
| |
| worse or remained exactly the same between the age of thirty and forty. It then
| |
| seemed to dawn on him that it would rather depend on Mr. Smith; and how he
| |
| chose to go on. It had never occurred to him that it might depend on how
| |
| mankind chose to go on; and that its course was not a straight line or an
| |
| upward or downward curve, but a track like that of a man across a valley,
| |
| going where he liked and stopping where he chose, going into a church or
| |
| falling down in a ditch. The life of man is a story; an adventure story; and in
| |
| our vision the same is true even of the story of God.
| |
|
| |
| The Catholic faith is the reconciliation because it is the realisation both of
| |
| mythology and philosophy. It is a story and in that sense one of a hundred
| |
| stories; only it is a true story. It is a philosophy and in that sense one of a
| |
| hundred philosophies; only it is a philosophy that is like life. But above all, it
| |
| is a reconciliation because it is something that can only be called the
| |
| philosophy of stories. That normal narrative instinct which produced all the
| |
| fairy tales is something that is neglected by all the philosophies--except one.
| |
| The Faith is the justification of that popular instinct; the finding of a
| |
| philosophy for it or the analysis of the philosophy in it. Exactly as a man in an
| |
| adventure story has to pass various tests to save his life, so the man in this
| |
| philosophy has to pass several tests and save his soul. In both there is an idea
| |
| of free will operating under conditions of design; in other words, there is an
| |
| aim and it is the business of a man to aim at it; we therefore watch to see
| |
| whether he will hit it. Now this deep and democratic and dramatic instinct is
| |
| derided and dismissed in all the other philosophies. For all the other
| |
| philosophies avowedly end where they begin; and it is the definition of a story
| |
| that it ends differently; that it begins in one place and ends in another. From
| |
| Buddha and his wheel to Akhen Aten and his disc, from Pythagoras with his
| |
| abstraction of number to Confucius with his religion of routine, there is not
| |
| one of them that does not in some way sin against the soul of a story. There is
| |
| none of them that really grasps this human notion of the tale, the test, the
| |
| adventure; the ordeal of the free man. Each of them starves the story-telling
| |
| instinct, so to speak, and does something to spoil human life considered as a
| |
| romance; either by fatalism (pessimist or optimist) and that destiny that is the
| |
| death of adventure; or by indifference and that detachment that is the death of
| |
| drama; or by a fundamental scepticism that dissolves the actors into atoms; or
| |
| by a materialistic limitation blocking the vista of moral consequences; or a
| |
| mechanical recurrence making even moral tests monotonous; or a bottomless
| |
| relativity making even practical tests insecure. There is such a thing as a
| |
| human story; and there is such a thing as the divine story which is also a
| |
| human story; but there is no such thing as a Hegelian story or a Monist story or
| |
| a relativist story or a determinist story; for every story, yes, even a penny
| |
| dreadful or a cheap novelette, has something in it that belongs to our universe
| |
| and not theirs. Every short story does truly begin with creation and end with a
| |
| last judgement.
| |
|
| |
| And that is the reason why the myths and the philosophers were at war until
| |
| Christ came. That is why the Athenian democracy killed Socrates out of
| |
| respect for the gods; and why every strolling sophist gave himself the airs of a
| |
| Socrates whenever he could talk in a superior fashion of the gods; and why the
| |
| heretic Pharaoh wrecked his huge idols and temples for an abstraction and why
| |
| the priests could return in triumph and trample his dynasty under foot; and
| |
| why Buddhism had to divide itself from Brahminism, and why in every age
| |
| and country outside Christendom there has been a feud for ever between the
| |
| philosopher and the priest. It is easy enough to say that the philosopher is
| |
| generally the more rational; it is easier still to forget that the priest is always
| |
| the more popular. For the priest told the people stories; and the philosopher did
| |
| not understand the philosophy of stories. It came into the world with the story
| |
| of Christ.
| |
|
| |
| And this is why it had to be a revelation or vision given from above. Any one
| |
| who will think of the theory of stories or pictures will easily see the point. The
| |
| true story of the world must be told by somebody to somebody else. By the
| |
| very nature of a story it cannot be left to occur to anybody. A story has
| |
| proportions, variations, surprises, particular dispositions, which cannot be
| |
| worked out by rule in the abstract, like a sum. We could not deduce whether or
| |
| no Achilles would give back the body of Hector from a Pythagorean theory of
| |
| number or recurrence; and we could not infer for ourselves in what way the
| |
| world would get back the body of Christ, merely from being told that all things
| |
| go round and round upon the wheel of Buddha. A man might perhaps work out
| |
| a proposition of Euclid without having heard of Euclid; but he would not work
| |
| out the precise legend of Eurydice without having heard of Eurydice. At any
| |
| rate he would not be certain how the story would end and whether Orpheus
| |
| was ultimately defeated. Still less could he guess the end of our story; or the
| |
| legend of our Orpheus rising, not defeated from, the dead.
| |
|
| |
| To sum up; the sanity of the world was restored and the soul of man offered
| |
| salvation by something which did indeed satisfy the two warring tendencies of
| |
| the past; which had never been satisfied in full and most certainly never
| |
| satisfied together. It met the mythological search for romance by being a story
| |
| and the philosophical search for truth by being a true story. That is why the
| |
| ideal figure had to be a historical character, as nobody had ever felt Adonis or
| |
| Pan to be a historical character. But that is also why the historical character
| |
| had to be the ideal figure; and even fulfil many of the functions given to these
| |
| other ideal figures; why he was at once the sacrifice and the feast, why he
| |
| could be shown under the emblems of the growing vine or the rising sun. The
| |
| more deeply we think of the matter the more we shall conclude that, if there be
| |
| indeed a God, his creation could hardly have reached any other culmination
| |
| than this granting of a real romance to the world. Otherwise the two sides of
| |
| the human mind could never have touched at all; and the brain of man would
| |
| have remained cloven and double; one lobe of it dreaming impossible dreams
| |
| and the other repeating invariable calculations. The picture-makers would have
| |
| remained forever painting the portrait of nobody. The sages would have
| |
| remained for ever adding up numerals that came to nothing. It was that abyss
| |
| that nothing but an incarnation could cover; a divine embodiment of our
| |
| dreams; and he stands above that chasm whose name is more than priest and
| |
| older even than Christendom; Pontifex Maximus, the mightiest maker of a
| |
| bridge.
| |
|
| |
| But even with that we return to the more specially Christian symbol in the
| |
| same tradition; the perfect pattern of the keys. This is a historical and not a
| |
| theological outline, and it is not my duty here to defend in detail that theology,
| |
| but merely to point out that it could not even be justified in design without
| |
| being justified in detail--like a key. Beyond the broad suggestion of this
| |
| chapter I attempt no apologetic about why the creed should be accepted. But in
| |
| answer to the historical query of why it was accepted and is accepted, I answer
| |
| for millions of others in my reply; because it fits the lock, because it is like
| |
| life. It is one among many stories; only it happens to be a true story. It is one
| |
| among many philosophies; only it happens to be the truth. We accept it; and
| |
| the ground is solid under our feet and the road is open before us. It does not
| |
| imprison us in a dream of destiny or a consciousness of the universal delusion.
| |
| It opens to us not only incredible heavens but what seems to some an equally
| |
| incredible earth, and makes it credible. This is the sort of truth that is hard to
| |
| explain because it is a fact; but it is a fact to which we can call witnesses. We
| |
| are Christians and Catholics not because we worship a key, but because we
| |
| have passed a door; and felt the wind that is the trumpet of liberty blow over
| |
| the land of the living.
| |
|
| |
| ===VI. The Five Deaths of the Faith===
| |
| It is not the purpose of this book to trace the subsequent history of
| |
| Christianity, especially the later history of Christianity; which involves
| |
| controversies of which I hope to write more fully elsewhere. It is devoted only
| |
| to the suggestion that Christianity, appearing amid heathen humanity, had all
| |
| the character of a unique thing and even of a supernatural thing. It was not like
| |
| any of the other things; and the more we study it the less it looks like any of
| |
| them. But there is a certain rather peculiar character which marked it
| |
| henceforward even down to the present moment, with a note on which this
| |
| book may well conclude.
| |
|
| |
| I have said that Asia and the ancient world had an air of being too old to die.
| |
| Christendom has had the very opposite fate. Christendom has had a series of
| |
| revolutions and in each one of them Christianity has died. Christianity has died
| |
| many times and risen again; for it had a God who knew the way out of the
| |
| grave. But the first extraordinary fact which marks this history is this: that
| |
| Europe has been turned upside down over and over again; and that at the end
| |
| of each of these revolutions the same religion has again been found on top.
| |
| The Faith is always converting the age, not as an old religion but as a new
| |
| religion. This truth is hidden from many by a convention that is too little
| |
| noticed. Curiously enough, it is a convention of the sort which those who
| |
| ignore it claim especially to detect and denounce. They are always telling us
| |
| that priests and ceremonies are not religion and that religious organisation can
| |
| be a hollow sham, but they hardly realise how true it is. It is so true that three
| |
| or four times at least in the history of Christendom the whole soul seemed to
| |
| have gone out of Christianity; and almost every man in his heart expected its
| |
| end. This fact is only masked in medieval and other times by that very official
| |
| religion which such critics pride themselves on seeing through. Christianity
| |
| remained the official religion of a Renaissance prince or the official religion of
| |
| an eighteenth-century bishop, just as an ancient mythology remained the
| |
| official religion of Julius Caesar or the Arian creed long remained the official
| |
| religion of Julian the Apostate. But there was a difference between the cases of
| |
| Julius and of Julian; because the Church had begun its strange career. There
| |
| was no reason why men like Julius should not worship gods like Jupiter for
| |
| ever in public and laugh at them for ever in private. But when Julian treated
| |
| Christianity as dead, he found it had come to life again. He also found,
| |
| incidentally, that there was not the faintest sign of Jupiter ever coming to life
| |
| again. This case of Julian and the episode of Arianism is but the first of a
| |
| series of examples that can only be roughly indicated here. Arianism, as has
| |
| been said, had every human appearance of being the natural way in which that
| |
| particular superstition of Constantine might be expected to peter out. All the
| |
| ordinary stages had been passed through; the creed had become a respectable
| |
| thing, had become a ritual thing, had then been modified into a rational thing;
| |
| and the rationalists were ready to dissipate the last remains of it, just as they do
| |
| to-day. When Christianity rose again suddenly and threw them, it was almost
| |
| as unexpected as Christ rising from the dead. But there are many other
| |
| examples of the same thing, even about the same time. The rush of
| |
| missionaries from Ireland, for instance, has all the air of an unexpected
| |
| onslaught of young men on an old world, and even on a Church that showed
| |
| signs of growing old. Some of them were martyred on the coast of Cornwall;
| |
| and the chief authority on Cornish antiquities told me that he did not believe
| |
| for a moment that they were martyred by heathens but (as he expressed it with
| |
| some humour) 'by rather slack Christians.'
| |
|
| |
| Now if we were to dip below the surface of history, as it is not in the scope of
| |
| this argument to do, I suspect that we should find several occasions when
| |
| Christendom was thus to all appearance hollowed out from within by doubt
| |
| and indifference, so that only the old Christian shell stood as the pagan shell
| |
| had stood so long. But the difference is that in every such case, the sons were
| |
| fanatical for the faith where the fathers had been slack about it. This is obvious
| |
| in the case of the transition from the Renaissance to the Counter-Reformation.
| |
| It is obvious in the case of a transition from the eighteenth century to the many
| |
| Catholic revivals of our own time. But I suspect many other examples which
| |
| would be worthy of separate studies.
| |
|
| |
| The Faith is not a survival. It is not as if the Druids had managed somehow to
| |
| survive somewhere for two thousand years. That is what might have happened
| |
| in Asia or ancient Europe, in that indifference or tolerance in which
| |
| mythologies and philosophies could live for ever side by side. It has not
| |
| survived; it has returned again and again in this Western world of rapid change
| |
| and institutions perpetually perishing. Europe, in the tradition of Rome, was
| |
| always trying revolution and reconstruction; rebuilding a universal republic.
| |
| And it always began by rejecting this old stone and ended by making it the
| |
| head of the corner; by bringing it back from the rubbish-heap to make it the
| |
| crown of the capitol. Some stones of Stonehenge are standing and some are
| |
| fallen; and as the stone falleth so shall it lie. There has not been a Druidic
| |
| renaissance every century or two, with the young Druids crowned with fresh
| |
| mistletoe, dancing in the sun on Salisbury Plain. Stonehenge has not been
| |
| rebuilt in every style of architecture from the rude round Norman to the last
| |
| rococo of the Baroque. The sacred place of the Druids is safe from the
| |
| vandalism of restoration.
| |
|
| |
| But the Church in the West was not in a world where things were too old to
| |
| die; but in one in which they were always young enough to get killed. The
| |
| consequence was that superficially and externally it often did get killed; nay, it
| |
| sometimes wore out even without getting killed. And there follows a fact I find
| |
| it somewhat difficult to describe, yet which I believe to be very real and rather
| |
| important. As a ghost is the shadow of a man, and in that sense the shadow of
| |
| life, so at intervals there passed across this endless life a sort of shadow of
| |
| death. It came at the moment when it would have perished had it been
| |
| perishable. It withered away everything that was perishable. If such animal
| |
| parallels were worthy of the occasion we might say that the snake shuddered
| |
| and shed a skin and went on, or even that the cat went into convulsions as it
| |
| lost only one of its nine-hundred-and-ninety-nine lives. It is truer to say, in a
| |
| more dignified image, that a clock struck and nothing happened; or that a bell
| |
| tolled for an execution that was everlastingly postponed.
| |
|
| |
| What was the meaning of all that dim but vast unrest of the twelfth century;
| |
| when, as it has been so finely said, Julian stirred in his sleep? Why did there
| |
| appear so strangely early, in the twilight of dawn after the Dark Ages, so deep
| |
| a scepticism as that involved in urging nominalism against realism? For
| |
| realism against nominalism was really realism against rationalism, or
| |
| something more destructive than what we call rationalism. The answer is that
| |
| just as some might have thought the Church simply a part of the Roman
| |
| Empire, so others later might have thought the Church only a part of the Dark
| |
| Ages. The Dark Ages ended as the Empire had ended, and the Church should
| |
| have departed with them, if she had been also one of the shades of night. It
| |
| was another of those spectral deaths or simulations of death. I mean that if
| |
| nominalism had succeeded, it would have been as if Arianism had succeeded,
| |
| it would have been the beginning of a confession that Christianity had failed.
| |
| For nominalism is a far more fundamental scepticism than mere atheism. Such
| |
| was the question that was openly asked as the Dark Ages broadened into that
| |
| daylight that we call the modern world. But what was the answer? The answer
| |
| was Aquinas in the chair of Aristotle, taking all knowledge for his province;
| |
| and tens of thousands of lads down to the lowest ranks of peasant and serf,
| |
| living in rags and on crusts about the great colleges, to listen to the scholastic
| |
| philosophy.
| |
|
| |
| What was the meaning of all that whisper of fear that ran round the west under
| |
| the shadow of Islam, and fills every old romance with incongruous images of
| |
| Saracen knights swaggering in Norway or the Hebrides? Why were men in the
| |
| extreme west, such as King John if I remember rightly, accused of being
| |
| secretly Moslems, as men are accused of being secretly atheists? Why was
| |
| there that fierce alarm among some of the authorities about the rationalistic
| |
| Arab version of Aristotle? Authorities are seldom alarmed like that except
| |
| when it is too late. The answer is that hundreds of people probably believed in
| |
| their hearts that Islam would conquer Christendom; that Averroes was more
| |
| rational than Anselm; that the Saracen Culture was really, as it was
| |
| superficially, a superior culture. Here again we should probably find a whole
| |
| generation, the older generation, serve doubtful and depressed and weary. The
| |
| coming of Islam would only have been the coming of Unitarianism a thousand
| |
| years before its time. To many it may have seemed quite reasonable and quite
| |
| probable and quite likely to happen. If so, they would have been surprised at
| |
| what did happen. What did happen was a roar like thunder from thousands and
| |
| thousands of young men, throwing all their youth into one exultant countercharge,
| |
| the Crusades. It was the sons of St. Francis, the Jugglers of God,
| |
| wandering singing over all the roads of the world; it was the Gothic going up
| |
| like a flight of arrows; it was the waking of the world. In considering the war
| |
| of the Albigensians, we come to the breach in the heart of Europe and the
| |
| landslide of a new philosophy that nearly ended Christendom for ever. In that
| |
| case the new philosophy was also a very new philosophy; it was pessimism. It
| |
| was none the less like modern ideas because it was as old as Asia; most
| |
| modern ideas are. It was the Gnostics returning; but why did the Gnostics
| |
| return? Because it was the end of an epoch, like the end of the Empire; and
| |
| should have been the end of the Church. It was Schopenhauer hovering over
| |
| the future; but it was also Manichaeus rising from the dead; that men might
| |
| have death and that they might have it more abundantly.
| |
|
| |
| It is rather more obvious in the case of the Renaissance, simply because the
| |
| period is so much nearer to us and people know so much more about it. But
| |
| there is more even in that example than most people know. Apart from the
| |
| particular controversies which I wish to reserve for a separate study, the period
| |
| was far more chaotic that those controversies commonly imply. When
| |
| Protestants call Latimer a martyr to Protestantism, and Catholics reply that
| |
| Campion was a martyr to Catholicism, it is often forgotten that many who
| |
| perished in such persecutions could only be described as martyrs to atheism or
| |
| anarchism or even diabolism. That world was almost as wild as our own; the
| |
| men wandering about in it included the sort of man who says there is no God,
| |
| the sort of man who says he is himself God, the sort of man who says
| |
| something that nobody can make head or tail of. If we could have the
| |
| conversation of the age following the Renaissance, we should probably be
| |
| shocked by its shameless negations. The remarks attributed to Marlowe are
| |
| probably pretty typical of the talk in many intellectual taverns. The transition
| |
| from Pre-Reformation to Post-Reformation Europe was through a void of very
| |
| yawning questions; yet again in the long run the answer was the same. It was
| |
| one of those moments when, as Christ walked on the water, so was
| |
| Christianity walking in the air.
| |
|
| |
| But all these cases are remote in date and could only be proved in detail. We
| |
| can see the fact much more clearly in the case when the paganism of the
| |
| Renaissance ended Christianity and Christianity unaccountably began all over
| |
| again. But we can see it most clearly of all in the case which is close to us and
| |
| full of manifest and minute evidence; the case of the great decline of religion
| |
| that began about the time of Voltaire. For indeed it is our own case, and we
| |
| ourselves have seen the decline of that decline. The two hundred years since
| |
| Voltaire do not flash past us at a glance like the fourth and fifth centuries or
| |
| the twelfth and thirteenth centuries. In our own case we can see this oftrepeated
| |
| process close at hand; we know how completely a society can lose its
| |
| fundamental religion without abolishing its official religion; we know how
| |
| men can all become agnostics long before they abolish bishops. And we know
| |
| that also in this last ending, which really did look to us like the final ending,
| |
| the incredible thing has happened again; the Faith has a better following
| |
| among the young men than among the old. When Ibsen spoke of the new
| |
| generation knocking at the door, he certainly never expected that it would be
| |
| the church-door.
| |
|
| |
| At least five times, therefore, with the Arian and the Albigensian, with the
| |
| Humanist sceptic, after Voltaire and after Darwin, the Faith has to all
| |
| appearance gone to the dogs. In each of these five cases it was the dog that
| |
| died. How complete was the collapse and how strange the reversal we can only
| |
| see in detail in the case nearest to our own time.
| |
|
| |
| A thousand things have been said about the Oxford Movement and the parallel
| |
| French Catholic revival; but few have made us feel the simplest fact about it;
| |
| that it was a surprise. It was a puzzle as well as a surprise; because it seemed
| |
| to most people like a river turning backwards from the sea and trying to climb
| |
| back into the mountains. To have read the literature of the eighteenth and
| |
| nineteenth centuries is to know that nearly everybody had come to take it for
| |
| granted that religion was a thing that would continually broaden like a river,
| |
| till it reached an infinite sea. Some of them expected it to go down in a
| |
| cataract of catastrophe, most of them expected it to widen into an estuary of
| |
| equality and moderation; but all of them thought its returning on itself a
| |
| prodigy as incredible as witchcraft. In other words, most moderate people
| |
| thought that faith like freedom would be slowly broadened down, and some
| |
| advanced people thought that it would be very rapidly broadened down, not to
| |
| say flattened out. All that world of Guizot and Macaulay and the commercial
| |
| and scientific liberality was perhaps more certain than any men before or since
| |
| about the direction in which the world is going. People were so certain about
| |
| the direction that they only differed about the pace. Many anticipated with
| |
| alarm, and a few with sympathy, a Jacobin revolt that should guillotine the
| |
| Archbishop of Canterbury or a Chartist riot that should hang the parsons on
| |
| the lampposts. But it seemed like a convulsion in nature that the Archbishop
| |
| instead of losing his head should be looking for his mitre; and that instead of
| |
| diminishing the respect due to parsons we should strengthen it to the respect
| |
| due to priests. It revolutionised their very vision of revolution; and turned their
| |
| very topsyturveydom topsyturvey.
| |
|
| |
| In short, the whole world being divided about whether the stream was going
| |
| slower or faster, became conscious of something vague but vast that was going
| |
| against the stream. Both in fact and figure there is something deeply disturbing
| |
| about this, and that for an essential reason. A dead thing can go with the
| |
| stream, but only a living thing can go against it. A dead dog can be lifted on
| |
| the leaping water with all the swiftness of a leaping hound; but only a live dog
| |
| can swim backwards. A paper boat can ride the rising deluge with all the airy
| |
| arrogance of a fairy ship, but if the fairy ship sails up stream it is really rowed
| |
| by the fairies. And among the things that merely went with the tide of apparent
| |
| progress and enlargement there was many a demagogue or sophist whose wild
| |
| gestures were in truth as lifeless as the movement of a dead dog's limbs
| |
| wavering in the eddying water; and many a philosophy uncommonly like a
| |
| paper boat, of the sort that it is not difficult to knock into a cocked hat. But
| |
| even the truly living and even life-giving things that went with that stream did
| |
| not thereby prove that they were living or life-giving. It was this other force
| |
| that was unquestionably and unaccountably alive; the mysterious and
| |
| unmeasured energy that was thrusting back the river. That was felt to be like
| |
| the movement of some great monster; and it was none the less clearly a living
| |
| monster because most people thought it a prehistoric monster. It was none the
| |
| less an unnatural, an incongruous, and to some a comic upheaval; as if the
| |
| Great Sea Serpent had suddenly risen out of the Round Pond--unless we
| |
| consider the Sea Serpent as more likely to live in the Serpentine. This flippant
| |
| element in the fantasy must not be missed, for it was one of the clearest
| |
| testimonies to the unexpected nature of the reversal. That age did really feel
| |
| that a preposterous quality in prehistoric animals belonged also to historic
| |
| rituals; that mitres and tiaras were like the horns or crests of antediluvian
| |
| creatures; and that appealing to a Primitive Church was like dressing up as a
| |
| Primitive Man.
| |
|
| |
| The world is still puzzled by that movement; but most of all because it still
| |
| moves. I have said something elsewhere of the rather random sort of
| |
| reproaches that are still directed against it and its much greater consequences;
| |
| it is enough to say here that the more such critics reproach it the less they
| |
| explain it. In a sense it is my concern here, if not to explain it, at least to
| |
| suggest the direction of the explanation; but above all, it is my concern to
| |
| point out one particular thing about it. And that is that it had all happened
| |
| before; and even many times before.
| |
|
| |
| To sum up, in so far as it is true that recent centuries have seen an attenuation
| |
| of Christian doctrine, recent centuries have only seen what the most remote
| |
| centuries have seen. And even the modern example has only ended as the
| |
| medieval and pre-medieval examples ended. It is already clear, and grows
| |
| clearer every day, that it is not going to end in the disappearance of the
| |
| diminished creed; but rather in the return of those parts of it that had really
| |
| disappeared. It is going to end as the Arian compromise ended, as the attempts
| |
| at a compromise with Nominalism and even with Albigensianism ended. But
| |
| the point to seize in the modern case, as in all the other cases is that what
| |
| returns is not in that sense a simplified theology; not according to that view a
| |
| purified theology; it is simply theology. It is that enthusiasm for theological
| |
| studies that marked the most doctrinal ages; it is the divine science. An old
| |
| Don with D. D. after his name may have become the typical figure of a bore;
| |
| but that was because he was himself bored with his theology, not because he
| |
| was excited about it. It was precisely because he was admittedly more
| |
| interested in the Latin of Plautus than in the Latin of Augustine, in the Greek
| |
| of Xenophon than in the Greek of Chrysostom. It was precisely because he
| |
| was more interested in a dead tradition than in a decidedly living tradition. In
| |
| short, it was precisely because he was himself a type of the time in which
| |
| Christian faith was weak. It was not because men would not hail, if they could,
| |
| the wonderful and almost wild vision of a Doctor of Divinity.
| |
|
| |
| There are people who say they wish Christianity to remain as a spirit. They
| |
| mean, very literally, that they wish it to remain as a ghost. But it is not going
| |
| to remain as a ghost. What follows this process of apparent death is not the
| |
| lingerings of the shade; it is the resurrection of the body. These people are
| |
| quite prepared to shed pious and reverential tears over the Sepulchre of the
| |
| Son of Man; what they are not prepared for is the Son of God walking once
| |
| more upon the hills of morning. These people, and indeed most people, were
| |
| indeed by this time quite accustomed to the idea that the old Christian candlelight
| |
| would fade into the light of common day. To many of them it did quite
| |
| honestly appear like that pale yellow flame of a candle when it is left burning
| |
| in daylight. It was all the more unexpected, and therefore all the more
| |
| unmistakable, that the seven branched candle-stick suddenly towered to
| |
| heaven like a miraculous tree and flamed until the sun turned pale. But other
| |
| ages have seen the day conquer the candle-light and then the candle-light
| |
| conquer the day. Again and again, before our time, men have grown content
| |
| with a diluted doctrine. And again and again there has followed on that
| |
| dilution, coming as out of the darkness in a crimson cataract, the strength of
| |
| the red original wine. And we only say once more to-day as has been said
| |
| many times by our fathers: `Long years and centuries ago our fathers or the
| |
| founders of our people drank, as they dreamed, of the blood of God. Long
| |
| years and centuries have passed since the strength of that giant vintage has
| |
| been anything but a legend of the age of giants. Centuries ago already is the
| |
| dark time of the second fermentation, when the wine of Catholicism turned
| |
| into the vinegar of Calvinism. Long since that bitter drink has been itself
| |
| diluted; rinsed out and washed away by the waters of oblivion and the wave of
| |
| the world. Never did we think to taste again even that bitter tang of sincerity
| |
| and the spirit, still less the richer and the sweeter strength of the purple
| |
| vineyards in our dreams of the age of gold. Day by day and year by year we
| |
| have lowered our hopes and lessened our convictions; we have grown more
| |
| and more used to seeing those vats and vineyards overwhelmed in the waterfloods
| |
| and the last savour and suggestion of that special element fading like a
| |
| stain of purple upon a sea of grey. We have grown used to dilution, to
| |
| dissolution, to a watering down that went on for ever. But 'Thou hast kept the
| |
| good wine until now.'
| |
|
| |
| This is the final fact, and it is the most extraordinary of all. The faith has not
| |
| only often died but it has often died of old age. It has not only been often
| |
| killed but it has often died a natural death; in the sense of coming to a natural
| |
| and necessary end. It is obvious that it has survived the most savage and the
| |
| most universal persecutions from the shock of the Diocletian fury to the shock
| |
| of the French Revolution. But it has a more strange and even a more weird
| |
| tenacity; it has survived not only war but peace. It has not only died often but
| |
| degenerated often and decayed often; it has survived its own weakness and
| |
| even its own surrender. We need not repeat what is so obvious about the
| |
| beauty of the end of Christ in its wedding of youth and death. But this is
| |
| almost as if Christ had lived to the last possible span, had been a white-haired
| |
| sage of a hundred and died of natural decay, and then had risen again
| |
| rejuvenated, with trumpets and the rending of the sky. It was said truly enough
| |
| that human Christianity in its recurrent weakness was sometimes too much
| |
| wedded to the powers of the world; but if it was wedded it has very often been
| |
| widowed. It is a strangely immortal sort of widow. An enemy may have said at
| |
| one moment that it was but an aspect of the power of the Caesars; and it
| |
| sounds as strange to-day as to call it an aspect of the Pharaohs. An enemy
| |
| might say that it was the official faith of feudalism; and it sounds as
| |
| convincing now as to say that it was bound to perish with the ancient Roman
| |
| villa. All these things did indeed run their course to its normal end; and there
| |
| seemed no course for the religion but to end with them. It ended and it began
| |
| again.
| |
|
| |
| 'Heaven and earth shall pass away, but my words shall not pass away.' The
| |
| civilisation of antiquity was the whole world: and men no more dreamed of its
| |
| ending than of the ending of daylight. They could not imagine another order
| |
| unless it were in another world. The civilisation of the world has passed away
| |
| and those words have not passed away. In the long night of the Dark Ages
| |
| feudalism was so familiar a thing that no man could imagine himself without a
| |
| lord: and religion was so woven into that network that no man would have
| |
| believed they could be torn asunder. Feudalism itself was torn to rags and
| |
| rotted away in the popular life of the true Middle Ages; and the first and
| |
| freshest power in that new freedom was the old religion. Feudalism had passed
| |
| away, and the words did not pass away. The whole medieval order, in many
| |
| ways so complete and almost cosmic a home for man, wore out gradually in its
| |
| turn and here at least it was thought that the words would die. They went forth
| |
| across the radiant abyss of the Renaissance and in fifty years were using all its
| |
| light and learning for new religious foundations, new apologetics, new saints.
| |
| It was supposed to have been withered up at last in the dry light of the Age of
| |
| Reason; it was supposed to have disappeared ultimately in the earthquake of
| |
| the Age of Revolution. Science explained it away; and it was still there.
| |
| History disinterred it in the past; and it appeared suddenly in the future. Today
| |
| it stands once more in our path; and even as we watch it, it grows.
| |
| If our social relations and records retain their continuity, if men really learn to
| |
| apply reason to the accumulating facts of so crushing a story, it would seem
| |
| that sooner or later even its enemies will learn from their incessant and
| |
| interminable disappointments not to look for anything so simple as its death.
| |
| They may continue to war with it, but it will be as they war with nature; as
| |
| they war with the landscape, as they war with the skies. 'Heaven and earth
| |
| shall pass away, but my words shall not pass away.' They will watch for it to
| |
| stumble; they will watch for it to err; they will no longer watch for it to end.
| |
| Insensibly, even unconsciously, they will in their own silent anticipations fulfil
| |
| the relative terms of that astounding prophecy; they will forget to watch for the
| |
| mere extinction of what has so often been vainly extinguished; and will learn
| |
| instinctively to look first for the coming of the comet or the freezing of the
| |
| star.
| |
|
| |
| ==Conclusion: The Summary Of This Book==
| |
| I have taken the liberty once or twice of borrowing the excellent phrase about | | I have taken the liberty once or twice of borrowing the excellent phrase about |
| an Outline of History; though this study of a special truth and a special error | | an Outline of History; though this study of a special truth and a special error |