This is an archive copy of wikilivres.ca as of 18 February 2017 (from the WikiTeam dump). The original site is closed.
On the Rocks/Preface/1: Difference between revisions
imported>Wugo Created subpage |
imported>Wugo Text added |
||
| Line 7: | Line 7: | ||
|notes= | |notes= | ||
}} | }} | ||
EXTERMINATION | |||
In this play a reference is made by a Chief of Police to the | |||
political necessity for killing people: a necessity so distressing | |||
to the statesmen and so terrifying to the common citizen that | |||
nobody except myself (as far as I know) has ventured to examine it | |||
directly on its own merits, although every Government is obliged to | |||
practise it on a scale varying from the execution of a single | |||
murderer to the slaughter of millions of quite innocent persons. | |||
Whilst assenting to these proceedings, and even acclaiming and | |||
celebrating them, we dare not tell ourselves what we are doing | |||
or why we are doing it; and so we call it justice or capital | |||
punishment or our duty to king and country or any other convenient | |||
verbal whitewash for what we instinctively recoil from as from a | |||
dirty job. These childish evasions are revolting. We must strip | |||
off the whitewash and find out what is really beneath it. | |||
Extermination must be put on a scientific basis if it is ever to be | |||
carried out humanely and apologetically as well as thoroughly. | |||
KILLING AS A POLITICAL FUNCTION | |||
That killing is a necessity is beyond question by any thoughtful | |||
person. Unless rabbits and deer and rats and foxes are killed, or | |||
"kept down" as we put it, mankind must perish; and that section of | |||
mankind which lives in the country and is directly and personally | |||
engaged in the struggle with Nature for a living has no sentimental | |||
doubts that they must be killed. As to tigers and poisonous | |||
snakes, their incompatibility with human civilization is | |||
unquestioned. This does not excuse the use of cruel steel traps, | |||
agonizing poisons, or packs of hounds as methods of extermination. | |||
Killing can be cruelly or kindly done; and the deliberate choice of | |||
cruel ways, and their organization as popular pleasures, is sinful; | |||
but the sin is in the cruelty and the enjoyment of it, not in the | |||
killing. | |||
THE SACREDNESS OF HUMAN LIFE | |||
In law we draw a line between the killing of human animals and non- | |||
human ones, setting the latter apart as brutes. This was founded | |||
on a general belief that humans have immortal souls and brutes | |||
none. Nowadays more and more people are refusing to make this | |||
distinction. They may believe in The Life Everlasting and The Life | |||
to Come; but they make no distinction between Man and Brute, | |||
because some of them believe that brutes have souls, whilst | |||
others refuse to believe that the physical materializations | |||
and personifications of The Life Everlasting are themselves | |||
everlasting. In either case the mystic distinction between Man and | |||
Brute vanishes; and the murderer pleading that though a rabbit | |||
should be killed for being mischievous he himself should be spared | |||
because he has an immortal soul and a rabbit has none is as | |||
hopelessly out of date as a gentleman duellist pleading his clergy. | |||
When the necessity for killing a dangerous human being arises, as | |||
it still does daily, the only distinction we make between a man and | |||
a snared rabbit is that we very quaintly provide the man with a | |||
minister of religion to explain to him that we are not killing him | |||
at all, but only expediting his transfer to an eternity of bliss. | |||
The political necessity for killing him is precisely like that for | |||
killing the cobra or the tiger: he is so ferocious or unscrupulous | |||
that if his neighbors do not kill him he will kill or ruin his | |||
neighbors; so that there is nothing for it but to disable him once | |||
for all by making an end of him, or else waste the lives of useful | |||
and harmless people in seeing that he does no mischief, and caging | |||
him cruelly like a lion in a show. | |||
Here somebody is sure to interject that there is the alternative of | |||
teaching him better manners; but I am not here dealing with such | |||
cases: the real necessity arises only in dealing with untameable | |||
persons who are constitutionally unable to restrain their violent | |||
or acquisitive impulses, and have no compunction about sacrificing | |||
others to their own immediate convenience. To punish such persons | |||
is ridiculous: we might as reasonably punish a tile for flying off | |||
a roof in a storm and knocking a clergyman on the head. But to | |||
kill them is quite reasonable and very necessary. | |||
PRESENT EXTERMINATIONS | |||
All this so far is mere elementary criminology, already dealt with | |||
very fully by me in my Essay on Prisons, which I recommend to those | |||
readers who may feel impelled to ramble away at this point into the | |||
prosings about Deterrence beloved by our Prison commissioners and | |||
judges. It disposes of the dogma of the unconditional sacredness | |||
of human life, or any other incarnation of life; but it covers only | |||
a corner of the field opened up by modern powers of extermination. | |||
In Germany it is suggested that the Nordic race should exterminate | |||
the Latin race. As both these lingual stocks are hopelessly | |||
interbred by this time, such a sacrifice to ethnological sciolism | |||
is not practicable; but its discussion familiarizes the idea and | |||
clears the way for practicable suggestions. The extermination of | |||
whole races and classes has been not only advocated but actually | |||
attempted. The extirpation of the Jew as such figured for a few | |||
mad moments in the program of the Nazi party in Germany. The | |||
extermination of the peasant is in active progress in Russia, where | |||
the extermination of the class of ladies and gentlemen of so-called | |||
independent means has already been accomplished; and an attempt to | |||
exterminate the old Conservative professional class and the kulak | |||
or prosperous farmer class has been checked only by the discovery | |||
that they cannot as yet be done without. Outside Russia the | |||
extermination of Communists is widely advocated; and there is a | |||
movement in the British Empire and the United States for the | |||
extermination of Fascists. In India the impulse of Moslems and | |||
Hindus to exterminate one another is complicated by the impulse of | |||
the British Empire to exterminate both when they happen to be | |||
militant Nationalists. | |||
PREVIOUS ATTEMPTS MISS THE POINT | |||
The novelty and significance of these instances consists in the | |||
equal status of the parties. The extermination of what the | |||
exterminators call inferior races is as old as history. "Stone | |||
dead hath no fellow" said Cromwell when he tried to exterminate the | |||
Irish. "The only good nigger is a dead nigger" say the Americans | |||
of the Ku-Klux temperament. "Hates any man the thing he would not | |||
kill?" said Shylock naively. But we white men, as we absurdly call | |||
ourselves in spite of the testimony of our looking glasses, regard | |||
all differently colored folk as inferior species. Ladies and | |||
gentlemen class rebellious laborers with vermin. The Dominicans, | |||
the watchdogs of God, regarded the Albigenses as the enemies of | |||
God, just as Torquemada regarded the Jews as the murderers of God. | |||
All that is an old story: what we are confronted with now is a | |||
growing perception that if we desire a certain type of civilization | |||
and culture we must exterminate the sort of people who do not fit | |||
into it. There is a difference between the shooting at sight of | |||
aboriginal natives in the back blocks of Australia and the | |||
massacres of aristocrats in the terror which followed the foreign | |||
attacks on the French Revolution. The Australian gunman pots the | |||
aboriginal natives to satisfy his personal antipathy to a black man | |||
with uncut hair. But nobody in the French Republic had this | |||
feeling about Lavoisier, nor can any German Nazi have felt that way | |||
about Einstein. Yet Lavoisier was guillotined; and Einstein has | |||
had to fly for his life from Germany. It was silly to say that the | |||
Republic had no use for chemists; and no Nazi has stultified his | |||
party to the extent of saying that the new National Socialist | |||
Fascist State in Germany has no use for mathematician-physicists. | |||
The proposition is that aristocrats (Lavoisier's class) and Jews | |||
(Einstein's race) are unfit to enjoy the privilege of living in a | |||
modern society founded on definite principles of social welfare as | |||
distinguished from the old promiscuous aggregations crudely policed | |||
by chiefs who had no notion of social criticism and no time to | |||
invent it. | |||
KING CHARLES'S HEAD | |||
It was, by the way, the English Revolution which introduced the | |||
category of Malignant or Man of Blood, and killed the King as an | |||
affirmation that even kings must not survive if they are malignant. | |||
This was much more advanced than the execution in the following | |||
century of Louis XVI as an ordinary traitor, or of the Tsar in our | |||
own time to prevent his being captured by the Tchekoslovakian | |||
contingent and used as a standard to rally the royalist reaction. | |||
Charles affirmed a divine personal right to govern as against the | |||
parliament and would keep no bargain with it. Parliament denied | |||
his right, and set up against it a divine right of election winners | |||
to govern. They fought it out; and the victorious election winners | |||
exterminated the king, very logically. Finding that their | |||
authority still needed a royal disguise they drove a hard bargain | |||
for a crown with his son, and, after ejecting the next king who | |||
broke it, a still harder one with his Dutch grandson before they | |||
allowed the title of king, with nine tenths of the meaning knocked | |||
out of it, to be used as a matter of convenience again in England. | |||
Nobody had a word to say against Charles's private character. It | |||
was solely for incompatibility of politics that he was eliminated, | |||
or "liquidated" as we say now. There was a real novelty in the | |||
transaction. The Church had for centuries before compelled the | |||
secular State to liquidate heretics; and the slaughter of rebels | |||
who tried to substitute one dynasty for another, or to seize the | |||
throne for themselves, was common routine. But Charles was neither | |||
a heretic nor a rebel. He was the assertor of a divine right to | |||
govern without winning elections; and because that right could not | |||
co-exist with the supremacy of a much richer and more powerful | |||
plutocracy off went his head. | |||
Charles was only the first victim. After Culloden the defeated | |||
Highland chiefs and their clansmen were butchered like sheep on the | |||
field. Had they been merely prisoners of war, this would have been | |||
murder. But as they were also Incompatibles with British | |||
civilization, it was only liquidation. | |||
RIGHT TO EXTERMINATE CONFERRED BY PRIVATE PROPERTY | |||
Having disposed of the divine right of kings the political | |||
liquidators turned their attention slowly to its derivatory the | |||
divine right of landlords, which had gradually disguised itself as | |||
private property in land. For when a tract of land becomes the | |||
private property of an individual who has to depend on it for his | |||
subsistence, the relation between him and the inhabitants of that | |||
tract becomes an economic one; and if they become economically | |||
superfluous or wasteful, he must exterminate them. This is | |||
continually happening wherever private property in land exists. If | |||
I possess land and find it profitable to grow wheat on it, I need | |||
many agricultural laborers to enable me to do it; and I tolerate | |||
their existence accordingly. If I presently find that it is more | |||
profitable to cover my land with sheep and sell their wool, I have | |||
to tolerate the existence of the sheep; but I no longer need | |||
tolerate the existence of the laborers; so I drive them off my | |||
land, which is my legal method of extermination, retaining only a | |||
few to act as shepherds. Later on I find that it is more | |||
profitable to cover my land with wild deer, and collect money from | |||
gentlemen and ladies who enjoy shooting them. I then exterminate | |||
my shepherds and keep only a few gamekeepers. But I may do much | |||
better by letting my land to industrialists for the erection of | |||
factories. They exterminate the sheep and the deer; but they need | |||
far more men than I needed even when I grew wheat. The driven-offs | |||
crowd into the factories and multiply like rabbits; and for the | |||
moment population grows instead of diminishing. But soon machines | |||
come along and make millions of proletarians economically | |||
superfluous. The factory owner accordingly sacks them, which is | |||
his legal method of extermination. During these developments the | |||
exterminated, or, as we call them, the evicted and sacked, try to | |||
avoid starvation partly by emigration, but mostly by offering | |||
themselves for all sorts of employment as soldiers, servants, | |||
prostitutes, police officers, scavengers, and operators of the | |||
immense machinery of amusement and protection for the idle rich | |||
classes created by the private property system. By organization in | |||
trade unions, municipal and parliamentary Labor Parties, and the | |||
like, and maintaining a sort of continual civil war consisting of | |||
strikes and riots, they extort from the proprietors enough to | |||
reduce the rate of extermination (shewn by the actuarial | |||
expectation of life of the unpropertied) for periods described as | |||
progressive, until the proprietors, by engaging in suicidal wars, | |||
are forced to intensify their economies, and the rate of | |||
extermination rises again. | |||
DISGUISES UNDER WHICH PRIVATE EXTERMINATION OPERATES | |||
Note that during all this the Registrar General's returns do not | |||
give us the deaths of the exterminated as such, because the | |||
exterminated do not starve as lost travellers starve in the desert. | |||
Their starvation is more or less protracted; and when the final | |||
catastrophe arrives, it is disguised under an imposing array of | |||
doctors' names for moribundity. The victims die mostly in their | |||
first year, and subsequently at all ages short of the age at which | |||
properly nourished people die. Sometimes they are starved into | |||
attaining an age at which people with well filled pockets eat | |||
themselves to death. Either way and all ways the extermination is | |||
a real and permanent feature of private property civilization, | |||
though it is never mentioned as such, and ladies and gentlemen | |||
are carefully educated to be unconscious of its existence and | |||
to talk nonsense about its facts when they are too obvious or | |||
become too scandalous to be ignored, when they often advocate | |||
emigration or Birth Control or war as remedies. And against the | |||
facts there is a chronic humanitarian revolt expressing itself | |||
either underground or overground in revolutionary movements; | |||
making our political constitutions very unstable; and imposing | |||
an habitual disingenuousness on conservative statesmen. | |||
PRIVATE POWERS OF LIFE AND DEATH | |||
Now the central fact of all these facts is that the private | |||
proprietors have irresponsible powers of life and death in the | |||
State. Such powers may be tolerated as long as the Government is | |||
in effect a committee of private proprietors; yet if such a | |||
committee be widened into or superseded by a Government acting in | |||
the interest of the whole people, that Government will not suffer | |||
any private class to hold the lives of the citizens at its mercy | |||
and thereby become their real masters. A popular Government, | |||
before it fully grasps the situation, usually begins by attempting | |||
to redistribute property in such a manner as to make everyone a | |||
petty proprietor, as in the French Revolution. But when the | |||
impossibility of doing this (except in the special case of | |||
agricultural land) becomes apparent, and the question is probed to | |||
the bottom by unpropertied political philosophers like Proudhon and | |||
Marx, private property is sooner or later excommunicated and | |||
abolished; and what was formerly called "real property" is replaced | |||
by ordinary personal property and common property administrated by | |||
the State. | |||
All modern progressive and revolutionary movements are at bottom | |||
attacks on private property. A Chancellor of the Exchequer | |||
apologizing for an increase in the surtax, a Fascist dictator | |||
organizing a Corporate State, a Soviet Commissar ejecting a kulak | |||
and adding his acres to a collective farm, are all running the same | |||
race, though all of them except the Commissar may be extremely | |||
reluctant to win it. For in the long run the power to exterminate | |||
is too grave to be left in any hands but those of a thoroughly | |||
Communist Government responsible to the whole community. The | |||
landlord with his writ of ejectment and the employer with his sack, | |||
must finally go the way of the nobleman with his sword and his | |||
benefit of clergy, and of Hannibal Chollop with his bowie knife and | |||
pistol. | |||
Let us then assume that private property, already maimed by factory | |||
legislation, surtax, and a good deal of petty persecution in | |||
England, and in Russia tolerated only provisionally as a | |||
disgraceful necessity pending its complete extirpation, is finally | |||
discarded by civilized communities, and the duty of maintaining it | |||
at all costs replaced by the duty of giving effect to the dogma | |||
that every ablebodied and ableminded and ablesouled person has an | |||
absolute right to an equal share in the national dividend. Would | |||
the practice of extermination thereupon disappear? I suggest | |||
that, on the contrary, it might continue much more openly and | |||
intelligently and scientifically than at present, because the | |||
humanitarian revolt against it would probably become a humanitarian | |||
support of it; and there would be an end of the hypocrisy, the | |||
venal special pleading, and the concealment or ignoring of facts | |||
which are imposed on us at present because extermination for the | |||
benefit of a handful of private persons against the interests of | |||
the race is permitted and practised. The old doctrine of the | |||
sacredness of human life, which in our idiot asylums at Darenth and | |||
elsewhere still terrifies us into wasting the lives of capable | |||
people in preserving the lives of monsters, was a crude expedient | |||
for beginning civilization. At present we discard it in dealing | |||
with murderers, heretics, traitors, and (in Scotland) vitriol | |||
throwers, who can be legally killed. A runaway convict can also be | |||
summarily shot by a warder to save the trouble of pursuing and | |||
recapturing him; and although the convict is not under capital | |||
sentence and the case is therefore clearly one of wilful murder, | |||
coroners' juries persist in treating it as a harmless and necessary | |||
incident in prison routine. | |||
Unfortunately the whole question is bedevilled by our anti- | |||
Christian vice of punishment, expiation, sacrifice, and all the | |||
cognate tribal superstitions which are hammered into us in our | |||
childhood by barbarous scripturists, irascible or sadist parents, | |||
and a hideous criminal code. When the horrors of anarchy force us | |||
to set up laws that forbid us to fight and torture one another for | |||
sport, we still snatch at every excuse for declaring individuals | |||
outside the protection of law and torturing them to our hearts | |||
content. | |||
CRUELTY'S EXCUSES | |||
There have been summits of civilization at which heretics like | |||
Socrates, who was killed because he was wiser than his neighbors, | |||
have not been tortured, but ordered to kill themselves in the most | |||
painless manner known to their judges. But from that summit there | |||
was a speedy relapse into our present savagery. For Wallace, whom | |||
the Scots adored as a patriot and the English executed as a | |||
traitor, the most cruel and obscene method of killing that the | |||
human imagination could conceive at its vilest was specially | |||
invented to punish him for being a traitor (or "larn him to be a | |||
toad"); and this sentence has been passed, though not carried out, | |||
within the memory of persons now living. John of Leyden, for being | |||
a Communist, was tortured so frightfully before being hung up in a | |||
cage on the church tower to starve to death in sight of all the | |||
citizens and their little children, that the bishop who was | |||
officially obliged to witness it died of horror. Joan of Arc, for | |||
wearing men's clothes and being a Protestant and a witch, was burnt | |||
alive, after a proposal to torture her had been barely defeated. | |||
The people who saw her burnt were quite accustomed to such | |||
spectacles, and regarded them as holiday attractions. A woman's | |||
sex was made an excuse for burning her instead of more mercifully | |||
hanging her. Male criminals were broken on the wheel: that is, | |||
battered to death with iron bars, until well into the nineteenth | |||
century. This was a public spectacle; and the prolongation of the | |||
victim's suffering was so elaborately studied and arranged that | |||
Cartouche, one of the kings of scoundrelism, was bribed to betray | |||
his accomplices by the promise that he should be killed by the | |||
sixth blow of the bar. The wheel and the stake have lately gone | |||
out of use; but the Sadist mania for flogging seems ineradicable; | |||
for after a partially successful attempt to discard it in Victorian | |||
times it has revived again with redoubled ferocity: quite recently | |||
a criminal was sentenced to a flogging and ten years penal | |||
servitude; and although the victim escaped his punishment and gave | |||
a sensational advertisement to its savagery by committing suicide, | |||
nobody protested, though thirty years ago there would have been a | |||
strenuous outcry against it, raised by the old Humanitarian League, | |||
and voiced in Parliament by the Irish Nationalists. Alas! the | |||
first thing the Irish did when they at last enjoyed self-government | |||
was to get rid of these sentimental Nationalists and put flogging | |||
on their statute book in a series of Coercion Acts that would have | |||
horrified Dublin Castle. In a really civilized state flogging | |||
would cease because it would be impossible to induce any decent | |||
citizen to flog another. Among us a perfectly respectable official | |||
will do it for half a crown, and probably enjoy the job. | |||
Revision as of 18:54, 21 May 2008
| Title page | On the Rocks Preface § i written by George Bernard Shaw |
Preface § ii |
EXTERMINATION
In this play a reference is made by a Chief of Police to the
political necessity for killing people: a necessity so distressing
to the statesmen and so terrifying to the common citizen that
nobody except myself (as far as I know) has ventured to examine it
directly on its own merits, although every Government is obliged to
practise it on a scale varying from the execution of a single
murderer to the slaughter of millions of quite innocent persons.
Whilst assenting to these proceedings, and even acclaiming and
celebrating them, we dare not tell ourselves what we are doing
or why we are doing it; and so we call it justice or capital
punishment or our duty to king and country or any other convenient
verbal whitewash for what we instinctively recoil from as from a
dirty job. These childish evasions are revolting. We must strip
off the whitewash and find out what is really beneath it.
Extermination must be put on a scientific basis if it is ever to be
carried out humanely and apologetically as well as thoroughly.
KILLING AS A POLITICAL FUNCTION
That killing is a necessity is beyond question by any thoughtful
person. Unless rabbits and deer and rats and foxes are killed, or
"kept down" as we put it, mankind must perish; and that section of
mankind which lives in the country and is directly and personally
engaged in the struggle with Nature for a living has no sentimental
doubts that they must be killed. As to tigers and poisonous
snakes, their incompatibility with human civilization is
unquestioned. This does not excuse the use of cruel steel traps,
agonizing poisons, or packs of hounds as methods of extermination.
Killing can be cruelly or kindly done; and the deliberate choice of
cruel ways, and their organization as popular pleasures, is sinful;
but the sin is in the cruelty and the enjoyment of it, not in the
killing.
THE SACREDNESS OF HUMAN LIFE
In law we draw a line between the killing of human animals and non-
human ones, setting the latter apart as brutes. This was founded
on a general belief that humans have immortal souls and brutes
none. Nowadays more and more people are refusing to make this
distinction. They may believe in The Life Everlasting and The Life
to Come; but they make no distinction between Man and Brute,
because some of them believe that brutes have souls, whilst
others refuse to believe that the physical materializations
and personifications of The Life Everlasting are themselves
everlasting. In either case the mystic distinction between Man and
Brute vanishes; and the murderer pleading that though a rabbit
should be killed for being mischievous he himself should be spared
because he has an immortal soul and a rabbit has none is as
hopelessly out of date as a gentleman duellist pleading his clergy.
When the necessity for killing a dangerous human being arises, as
it still does daily, the only distinction we make between a man and
a snared rabbit is that we very quaintly provide the man with a
minister of religion to explain to him that we are not killing him
at all, but only expediting his transfer to an eternity of bliss.
The political necessity for killing him is precisely like that for killing the cobra or the tiger: he is so ferocious or unscrupulous that if his neighbors do not kill him he will kill or ruin his neighbors; so that there is nothing for it but to disable him once for all by making an end of him, or else waste the lives of useful and harmless people in seeing that he does no mischief, and caging him cruelly like a lion in a show.
Here somebody is sure to interject that there is the alternative of teaching him better manners; but I am not here dealing with such cases: the real necessity arises only in dealing with untameable persons who are constitutionally unable to restrain their violent or acquisitive impulses, and have no compunction about sacrificing others to their own immediate convenience. To punish such persons is ridiculous: we might as reasonably punish a tile for flying off a roof in a storm and knocking a clergyman on the head. But to kill them is quite reasonable and very necessary.
PRESENT EXTERMINATIONS
All this so far is mere elementary criminology, already dealt with
very fully by me in my Essay on Prisons, which I recommend to those
readers who may feel impelled to ramble away at this point into the
prosings about Deterrence beloved by our Prison commissioners and
judges. It disposes of the dogma of the unconditional sacredness
of human life, or any other incarnation of life; but it covers only
a corner of the field opened up by modern powers of extermination.
In Germany it is suggested that the Nordic race should exterminate
the Latin race. As both these lingual stocks are hopelessly
interbred by this time, such a sacrifice to ethnological sciolism
is not practicable; but its discussion familiarizes the idea and
clears the way for practicable suggestions. The extermination of
whole races and classes has been not only advocated but actually
attempted. The extirpation of the Jew as such figured for a few
mad moments in the program of the Nazi party in Germany. The
extermination of the peasant is in active progress in Russia, where
the extermination of the class of ladies and gentlemen of so-called
independent means has already been accomplished; and an attempt to
exterminate the old Conservative professional class and the kulak
or prosperous farmer class has been checked only by the discovery
that they cannot as yet be done without. Outside Russia the
extermination of Communists is widely advocated; and there is a
movement in the British Empire and the United States for the
extermination of Fascists. In India the impulse of Moslems and
Hindus to exterminate one another is complicated by the impulse of
the British Empire to exterminate both when they happen to be
militant Nationalists.
PREVIOUS ATTEMPTS MISS THE POINT
The novelty and significance of these instances consists in the
equal status of the parties. The extermination of what the
exterminators call inferior races is as old as history. "Stone
dead hath no fellow" said Cromwell when he tried to exterminate the
Irish. "The only good nigger is a dead nigger" say the Americans
of the Ku-Klux temperament. "Hates any man the thing he would not
kill?" said Shylock naively. But we white men, as we absurdly call
ourselves in spite of the testimony of our looking glasses, regard
all differently colored folk as inferior species. Ladies and
gentlemen class rebellious laborers with vermin. The Dominicans,
the watchdogs of God, regarded the Albigenses as the enemies of
God, just as Torquemada regarded the Jews as the murderers of God.
All that is an old story: what we are confronted with now is a
growing perception that if we desire a certain type of civilization
and culture we must exterminate the sort of people who do not fit
into it. There is a difference between the shooting at sight of
aboriginal natives in the back blocks of Australia and the
massacres of aristocrats in the terror which followed the foreign
attacks on the French Revolution. The Australian gunman pots the
aboriginal natives to satisfy his personal antipathy to a black man
with uncut hair. But nobody in the French Republic had this
feeling about Lavoisier, nor can any German Nazi have felt that way
about Einstein. Yet Lavoisier was guillotined; and Einstein has
had to fly for his life from Germany. It was silly to say that the
Republic had no use for chemists; and no Nazi has stultified his
party to the extent of saying that the new National Socialist
Fascist State in Germany has no use for mathematician-physicists.
The proposition is that aristocrats (Lavoisier's class) and Jews
(Einstein's race) are unfit to enjoy the privilege of living in a
modern society founded on definite principles of social welfare as
distinguished from the old promiscuous aggregations crudely policed
by chiefs who had no notion of social criticism and no time to
invent it.
KING CHARLES'S HEAD
It was, by the way, the English Revolution which introduced the
category of Malignant or Man of Blood, and killed the King as an
affirmation that even kings must not survive if they are malignant.
This was much more advanced than the execution in the following
century of Louis XVI as an ordinary traitor, or of the Tsar in our
own time to prevent his being captured by the Tchekoslovakian
contingent and used as a standard to rally the royalist reaction.
Charles affirmed a divine personal right to govern as against the
parliament and would keep no bargain with it. Parliament denied
his right, and set up against it a divine right of election winners
to govern. They fought it out; and the victorious election winners
exterminated the king, very logically. Finding that their
authority still needed a royal disguise they drove a hard bargain
for a crown with his son, and, after ejecting the next king who
broke it, a still harder one with his Dutch grandson before they
allowed the title of king, with nine tenths of the meaning knocked
out of it, to be used as a matter of convenience again in England.
Nobody had a word to say against Charles's private character. It
was solely for incompatibility of politics that he was eliminated,
or "liquidated" as we say now. There was a real novelty in the
transaction. The Church had for centuries before compelled the
secular State to liquidate heretics; and the slaughter of rebels
who tried to substitute one dynasty for another, or to seize the
throne for themselves, was common routine. But Charles was neither
a heretic nor a rebel. He was the assertor of a divine right to
govern without winning elections; and because that right could not
co-exist with the supremacy of a much richer and more powerful
plutocracy off went his head.
Charles was only the first victim. After Culloden the defeated Highland chiefs and their clansmen were butchered like sheep on the field. Had they been merely prisoners of war, this would have been murder. But as they were also Incompatibles with British civilization, it was only liquidation.
RIGHT TO EXTERMINATE CONFERRED BY PRIVATE PROPERTY
Having disposed of the divine right of kings the political
liquidators turned their attention slowly to its derivatory the
divine right of landlords, which had gradually disguised itself as
private property in land. For when a tract of land becomes the
private property of an individual who has to depend on it for his
subsistence, the relation between him and the inhabitants of that
tract becomes an economic one; and if they become economically
superfluous or wasteful, he must exterminate them. This is
continually happening wherever private property in land exists. If
I possess land and find it profitable to grow wheat on it, I need
many agricultural laborers to enable me to do it; and I tolerate
their existence accordingly. If I presently find that it is more
profitable to cover my land with sheep and sell their wool, I have
to tolerate the existence of the sheep; but I no longer need
tolerate the existence of the laborers; so I drive them off my
land, which is my legal method of extermination, retaining only a
few to act as shepherds. Later on I find that it is more
profitable to cover my land with wild deer, and collect money from
gentlemen and ladies who enjoy shooting them. I then exterminate
my shepherds and keep only a few gamekeepers. But I may do much
better by letting my land to industrialists for the erection of
factories. They exterminate the sheep and the deer; but they need
far more men than I needed even when I grew wheat. The driven-offs
crowd into the factories and multiply like rabbits; and for the
moment population grows instead of diminishing. But soon machines
come along and make millions of proletarians economically
superfluous. The factory owner accordingly sacks them, which is
his legal method of extermination. During these developments the
exterminated, or, as we call them, the evicted and sacked, try to
avoid starvation partly by emigration, but mostly by offering
themselves for all sorts of employment as soldiers, servants,
prostitutes, police officers, scavengers, and operators of the
immense machinery of amusement and protection for the idle rich
classes created by the private property system. By organization in
trade unions, municipal and parliamentary Labor Parties, and the
like, and maintaining a sort of continual civil war consisting of
strikes and riots, they extort from the proprietors enough to
reduce the rate of extermination (shewn by the actuarial
expectation of life of the unpropertied) for periods described as
progressive, until the proprietors, by engaging in suicidal wars,
are forced to intensify their economies, and the rate of
extermination rises again.
DISGUISES UNDER WHICH PRIVATE EXTERMINATION OPERATES
Note that during all this the Registrar General's returns do not
give us the deaths of the exterminated as such, because the
exterminated do not starve as lost travellers starve in the desert.
Their starvation is more or less protracted; and when the final
catastrophe arrives, it is disguised under an imposing array of
doctors' names for moribundity. The victims die mostly in their
first year, and subsequently at all ages short of the age at which
properly nourished people die. Sometimes they are starved into
attaining an age at which people with well filled pockets eat
themselves to death. Either way and all ways the extermination is
a real and permanent feature of private property civilization,
though it is never mentioned as such, and ladies and gentlemen
are carefully educated to be unconscious of its existence and
to talk nonsense about its facts when they are too obvious or
become too scandalous to be ignored, when they often advocate
emigration or Birth Control or war as remedies. And against the
facts there is a chronic humanitarian revolt expressing itself
either underground or overground in revolutionary movements;
making our political constitutions very unstable; and imposing
an habitual disingenuousness on conservative statesmen.
PRIVATE POWERS OF LIFE AND DEATH
Now the central fact of all these facts is that the private
proprietors have irresponsible powers of life and death in the
State. Such powers may be tolerated as long as the Government is
in effect a committee of private proprietors; yet if such a
committee be widened into or superseded by a Government acting in
the interest of the whole people, that Government will not suffer
any private class to hold the lives of the citizens at its mercy
and thereby become their real masters. A popular Government,
before it fully grasps the situation, usually begins by attempting
to redistribute property in such a manner as to make everyone a
petty proprietor, as in the French Revolution. But when the
impossibility of doing this (except in the special case of
agricultural land) becomes apparent, and the question is probed to
the bottom by unpropertied political philosophers like Proudhon and
Marx, private property is sooner or later excommunicated and
abolished; and what was formerly called "real property" is replaced
by ordinary personal property and common property administrated by
the State.
All modern progressive and revolutionary movements are at bottom attacks on private property. A Chancellor of the Exchequer apologizing for an increase in the surtax, a Fascist dictator organizing a Corporate State, a Soviet Commissar ejecting a kulak and adding his acres to a collective farm, are all running the same race, though all of them except the Commissar may be extremely reluctant to win it. For in the long run the power to exterminate is too grave to be left in any hands but those of a thoroughly Communist Government responsible to the whole community. The landlord with his writ of ejectment and the employer with his sack, must finally go the way of the nobleman with his sword and his benefit of clergy, and of Hannibal Chollop with his bowie knife and pistol.
Let us then assume that private property, already maimed by factory legislation, surtax, and a good deal of petty persecution in England, and in Russia tolerated only provisionally as a disgraceful necessity pending its complete extirpation, is finally discarded by civilized communities, and the duty of maintaining it at all costs replaced by the duty of giving effect to the dogma that every ablebodied and ableminded and ablesouled person has an absolute right to an equal share in the national dividend. Would the practice of extermination thereupon disappear? I suggest that, on the contrary, it might continue much more openly and intelligently and scientifically than at present, because the humanitarian revolt against it would probably become a humanitarian support of it; and there would be an end of the hypocrisy, the venal special pleading, and the concealment or ignoring of facts which are imposed on us at present because extermination for the benefit of a handful of private persons against the interests of the race is permitted and practised. The old doctrine of the sacredness of human life, which in our idiot asylums at Darenth and elsewhere still terrifies us into wasting the lives of capable people in preserving the lives of monsters, was a crude expedient for beginning civilization. At present we discard it in dealing with murderers, heretics, traitors, and (in Scotland) vitriol throwers, who can be legally killed. A runaway convict can also be summarily shot by a warder to save the trouble of pursuing and recapturing him; and although the convict is not under capital sentence and the case is therefore clearly one of wilful murder, coroners' juries persist in treating it as a harmless and necessary incident in prison routine.
Unfortunately the whole question is bedevilled by our anti- Christian vice of punishment, expiation, sacrifice, and all the cognate tribal superstitions which are hammered into us in our childhood by barbarous scripturists, irascible or sadist parents, and a hideous criminal code. When the horrors of anarchy force us to set up laws that forbid us to fight and torture one another for sport, we still snatch at every excuse for declaring individuals outside the protection of law and torturing them to our hearts content.
CRUELTY'S EXCUSES
There have been summits of civilization at which heretics like
Socrates, who was killed because he was wiser than his neighbors,
have not been tortured, but ordered to kill themselves in the most
painless manner known to their judges. But from that summit there
was a speedy relapse into our present savagery. For Wallace, whom
the Scots adored as a patriot and the English executed as a
traitor, the most cruel and obscene method of killing that the
human imagination could conceive at its vilest was specially
invented to punish him for being a traitor (or "larn him to be a
toad"); and this sentence has been passed, though not carried out,
within the memory of persons now living. John of Leyden, for being
a Communist, was tortured so frightfully before being hung up in a
cage on the church tower to starve to death in sight of all the
citizens and their little children, that the bishop who was
officially obliged to witness it died of horror. Joan of Arc, for
wearing men's clothes and being a Protestant and a witch, was burnt
alive, after a proposal to torture her had been barely defeated.
The people who saw her burnt were quite accustomed to such
spectacles, and regarded them as holiday attractions. A woman's
sex was made an excuse for burning her instead of more mercifully
hanging her. Male criminals were broken on the wheel: that is,
battered to death with iron bars, until well into the nineteenth
century. This was a public spectacle; and the prolongation of the
victim's suffering was so elaborately studied and arranged that
Cartouche, one of the kings of scoundrelism, was bribed to betray
his accomplices by the promise that he should be killed by the
sixth blow of the bar. The wheel and the stake have lately gone
out of use; but the Sadist mania for flogging seems ineradicable;
for after a partially successful attempt to discard it in Victorian
times it has revived again with redoubled ferocity: quite recently
a criminal was sentenced to a flogging and ten years penal
servitude; and although the victim escaped his punishment and gave
a sensational advertisement to its savagery by committing suicide,
nobody protested, though thirty years ago there would have been a
strenuous outcry against it, raised by the old Humanitarian League,
and voiced in Parliament by the Irish Nationalists. Alas! the
first thing the Irish did when they at last enjoyed self-government
was to get rid of these sentimental Nationalists and put flogging
on their statute book in a series of Coercion Acts that would have
horrified Dublin Castle. In a really civilized state flogging
would cease because it would be impossible to induce any decent
citizen to flog another. Among us a perfectly respectable official
will do it for half a crown, and probably enjoy the job.