This is an archive copy of wikilivres.ca as of 18 February 2017 (from the WikiTeam dump). The original site is closed.
On the Rocks/Preface/2
| Preface § i | On the Rocks Preface § ii written by George Bernard Shaw |
Preface § iii |
LEADING CASE OF JESUS CHRIST
I dislike cruelty, even cruelty to other people, and should
therefore like to see all cruel people exterminated. But I should
recoil with horror from a proposal to punish them. Let me
illustrate my attitude by a very famous, indeed far too famous,
example of the popular conception of criminal law as a means of
delivering up victims to the normal popular lust for cruelty which
has been mortified by the restraint imposed on it by civilization.
Take the case of the extermination of Jesus Christ. No doubt there
was a strong case for it. Jesus was from the point of view of the
High Priest a heretic and an impostor. From the point of view of
the merchants he was a rioter and a Communist. From the Roman
Imperialist point of view he was a traitor. From the commonsense
point of view he was a dangerous madman. From the snobbish point
of view, always a very influential one, he was a penniless
vagrant. From the police point of view he was an obstructor of
thoroughfares, a beggar, an associate of prostitutes, an apologist
of sinners, and a disparager of judges; and his daily companions
were tramps whom he had seduced into vagabondage from their regular
trades. From the point of view of the pious he was a Sabbath
breaker, a denier of the efficacy of circumcision and the advocate
of a strange rite of baptism, a gluttonous man and a winebibber.
He was abhorrent to the medical profession as an unqualified
practitioner who healed people by quackery and charged nothing for
the treatment. He was not anti-Christ: nobody had heard of such a
power of darkness then; but he was startlingly anti-Moses. He was
against the priests, against the judiciary, against the military,
against the city (he declared that it was impossible for a rich man
to enter the kingdom of heaven), against all the interests,
classes, principalities and powers, inviting everybody to abandon
all these and follow him. By every argument, legal, political,
religious, customary, and polite, he was the most complete enemy of
the society of his time ever brought to the bar. He was guilty on
every count of the indictment, and on many more that his accusers
had not the wit to frame. If he was innocent then the whole world
was guilty. To acquit him was to throw over civilization and all
its institutions. History has borne out the case against him; for
no State has ever constituted itself on his principles or made it
possible to live according to his commandments: those States who
have taken his name have taken it as an alias to enable them to
persecute his followers more plausibly.
It is not surprising that under these circumstances, and in the absence of any defence, the Jerusalem community and the Roman government decided to exterminate Jesus. They had just as much right to do so as to exterminate the two thieves who perished with him. But there was neither right nor reason in torturing him. He was entitled to the painless death of Socrates. We may charitably suppose that if the death could have been arranged privately between Pilate and Caiaphas Jesus would have been dispatched as quickly and suddenly as John the Baptist. But the mob wanted the horrible fun of seeing somebody crucified: an abominably cruel method of execution. Pilate only made matters worse by trying to appease them by having Jesus flogged. The soldiers, too, had to have their bit of sport, to crown him with thorns and, when they buffeted him, challenge him ironically to guess which of them had struck the blow.
"CROSSTIANITY"
All this was cruelty for its own sake, for the pleasure of it. And
the fun did not stop there. Such was and is the attraction of
these atrocities that the spectacle of them has been reproduced in
pictures and waxworks and exhibited in churches ever since as an
aid to piety. The chief instrument of torture is the subject of a
special Adoration. Little models of it in gold and ivory are worn
as personal ornaments; and big reproductions in wood and marble are
set up in sacred places and on graves. Contrasting the case with
that of Socrates, one is forced to the conclusion that if Jesus had
been humanely exterminated his memory would have lost ninetynine
per cent of its attraction for posterity. Those who were specially
susceptible to his morbid attraction were not satisfied with
symbolic crosses which hurt nobody. They soon got busy with "acts
of faith" which consisted of great public shows at which Jews and
Protestants or Catholics, and anyone else who could be caught out
on a point of doctrine, were burnt alive. Cruelty is so infectious
that the very compassion it rouses is infuriated to take revenge by
still viler cruelties.
The tragedy of this—or, if you will, the comedy—is that it was his clearness of vision on this very point that set Jesus so high above his persecutors. He taught that two blacks do not make a white; that evil should not be countered by worse evil but by good; that revenge and punishment only duplicate wrong; that we should conceive God, not as an irascible and vindictive tyrant but as an affectionate father. No doubt many private amiabilities have been inspired by this teaching; but politically it has received no more quarter than Pilate gave it. To all Governments it has remained paradoxical and impracticable. A typical acknowledgement of it was the hanging of a crucifix above the seat of the judge who was sentencing evildoers to be broken on the wheel.
CHRISTIANITY AND THE SIXTH COMMANDMENT
Now it is not enough to satirize this. We must examine why it
occurred. It is not enough to protest that evildoers must not be
paid in their own coin by treating them as cruelly as they have
treated others. We still have to stop the mischief they do. What
is to be done with them? It is easy to suggest that they should be
reformed by gentleness and shamed by non-resistance. By all means,
if they respond to that treatment. But if gentleness fails to
reform them and non-resistance encourages them to further
aggression, what then? A month spent in a Tolstoyan community will
convince anybody of the soundness of the nearest police inspector's
belief that every normal human group contains not only a percentage
of saints but also a percentage of irreclaimable scoundrels and
good-for-noughts who will wreck any community unless they are
expensively restrained or cheaply exterminated. Our Mosaic system
of vindictive punishment, politely called "retributory" by Prison
Commissioners, disposes of them temporarily; but it wastes the
lives of honest citizens in guarding them; sets a horrible example
of cruelty and malicious injury; costs a good deal of money that
might be better spent; and, after all, sooner or later lets the
scoundrel loose again to recommence his depredations. It would be
much more sensible and less cruel to treat him as we treat mad dogs
or adders, without malice or cruelty, and without reference to
catalogues of particular crimes. The notion that persons should be
safe from extermination as long as they do not commit wilful
murder, or levy war against the Crown, or kidnap, or throw vitriol,
is not only to limit social responsibility unnecessarily, and to
privilege the large range of intolerable misconduct that lies
outside them, but to divert attention from the essential
justification for extermination, which is always incorrigible
social incompatibility and nothing else.
THE RUSSIAN EXPERIMENT
The only country which has yet awakened to this extension of social
responsibility is Russia. When the Soviet Government undertook to
change over from Capitalism to Communism it found itself without
any instruments for the maintenance of order except a list of
crimes and punishments administered through a ritual of criminal
law. And in the list of crimes the very worst offences against
Communist society had no place: on the contrary they were highly
honored and rewarded. As our English doggerel runs, the courts
could punish a man for stealing the goose from off the common, but
not the man who stole the common from the goose. The idler, that
common enemy of mankind who robs everybody all the time, though he
is so carefully protected from having his own pocket picked,
incurred no penalty, and had actually passed the most severe laws
against any interference with his idling. It was the business of
the Soviet to make all business public business and all persons
public servants; but the view of the ordinary Russian citizen was
that a post in a public service was an exceptional stroke of good
luck for the holder because it was a sinecure carrying with it the
privilege of treating the public insolently and extorting bribes
from it. For example, when the Russian railways were communized,
some of the local stationmasters interpreted the change as meaning
that they might now be as lazy and careless as they pleased,
whereas in fact it was of life-or-death importance that they should
redouble their activity and strain every nerve to make the service
efficient. The unfortunate Commissar who was Minister of Transport
found himself obliged to put a pistol in his pocket and with his
own hand shoot stationmasters who had thrown his telegrams into the
dustbin instead of attending to them, so that he might the more
impressively ask the rest of the staff whether they yet grasped the
fact that orders are meant to be executed.
INADEQUACY OF PENAL CODES
Now being Minister of Transport, or Minister of any other public
service, is a whole time job: it cannot be permanently combined
with that of amateur executioner, carrying with it the reputation
in all the capitalist papers of the west of being a ferocious and
coldblooded murderer. And no conceivable extension of the criminal
code nor of the service disciplines, with their lists of specific
offences and specific penalties, could have provided for instant
exemplary exterminations of this kind, any more than for the
growing urgency of how to dispose of people who would not or could
not fit themselves into the new order of things by conforming to
its new morality. It would have been easy to specify certain
offences and certain penalties in the old fashion: as, for
instance, if you hoard money you will be shot; if you speculate in
the difference in purchasing power of the rouble in Moscow and
Berlin you will be shot; if you buy at the Co-operative to sell at
the private trader's shop you will be shot; if you take bribes you
will be shot; if you falsify farm or factory balance sheets you
will be shot; if you exploit labor you will be shot; and it will be
useless to plead that you have been brought up to regard these as
normal business activities, and that the whole of respectable
society outside Russia agrees with you. But the most elaborate
code of this sort would still have left unspecified a hundred ways
in which wreckers of Communism could have sidetracked it without
ever having to face the essential questions: are you pulling your
weight in the social boat? are you giving more trouble than you are
worth? have you earned the privilege of living in a civilized
community? That is why the Russians were forced to set up an
Inquisition or Star Chamber, called at first the Cheka and now the
Gay Pay Oo (Ogpu), to go into these questions and "liquidate"
persons who could not answer them satisfactorily. The security
against the abuse of this power of life and death was that the
Cheka had no interest in liquidating anybody who could be made
publicly useful, all its interests being in the opposite direction.
LIMITED LIABILITY IN MORALS
Such a novelty is extremely terrifying to us, who are still working
on a system of limited liability in morals. Our "free" British
citizens can ascertain exactly what they may do and what they may
not do if they are to keep out of the hands of the police. Our
financiers know that they must not forge share certificates nor
overstate their assets in the balance sheets they send to their
shareholders. But provided they observe a few conditions of this
kind they are free to enter upon a series of quite legitimate but
not the less nefarious operations. For example, making a corner in
wheat or copper or any other cornerable commodity and forcing up
prices so as to make enormous private fortunes for themselves, or
making mischief between nations through the Press to stimulate the
private trade in armaments. Such limited liability no longer
exists in Russia, and is not likely to exist in the future in any
highly civilized state. It may be quite impossible to convict a
forestaller or regrator under a criminal code of having taken a
single illegal step, but quite easy to convince any reasonable body
of judges that he is what the people call "a wrong one." In Russia
such a conviction would lead to his disappearance and the receipt
by his family of a letter to say that they need not wait up for
him, as he would not return home any more.* In our country he
would enjoy his gains in high honor and personal security, and
thank his stars that he lived in a free country and not in
Communist Russia.
- Note, however, that a sentence of extermination should never be
so certain as to make it worth the delinquent's while to avoid arrest by murdering his or her pursuers.
But as the new tribunal has been forced on Russia by pressure of
circumstances and not planned and thought out at leisure, the two
institutions, the Ogpu and the ordinary police administering the
criminal code, work side by side, with the odd result that the
surest way to escape the Ogpu is to commit an ordinary crime and
take refuge in the arms of the police and the magistrate, who
cannot exterminate you because capital punishment has been
abolished in Russia (liquidation by the Ogpu is not punishment: it
is only "weeding the garden"); and the sentence of imprisonment,
though it may seem severe to us in view of the cruelty of our
treatment of criminals, will be carried out with comparative
leniency, and probably, if the culprit behaves well be remitted
after a while. As four years imprisonment is considered enough for
any reasonable sort of murder, a cornerer who finds himself in
imminent danger of detection and liquidation by the Ogpu would be
well advised to lose his temper and murder his mother-in-law,
thereby securing a lease of life for at least four years.
Sooner or later this situation will have to be thoroughly studied and thought out to its logical conclusion in all civilized countries. The lists of crimes and penalties will obsolesce like the doctors' lists of diseases and medicines; and it will become possible to be a judge without ceasing to be a Christian. And extermination, my present subject, will become a humane science instead of the miserable mixture of piracy, cruelty, vengeance, race conceit, and superstition it now is.
NATURAL LIMIT TO EXTERMINATION
Fortunately the more frankly and realistically it is faced the more
it detaches itself from the associations with crude slaughter which
now make it terrible. When Charlemagne founded the Holy Roman
Empire (as far as anyone can be said to have founded it) he
postulated that all its subjects must be Catholic Christians, and
made an amateurish attempt to secure this condition of social
stability by killing everyone who fell into his power and refused
to be baptized. But he cannot ever have got very far with it,
because there is one sort of bird you must not kill on any pretext
whatever: namely, the goose that lays the golden eggs. In Russia
the Soviet Government began by a Charlemagnesque attempt to
exterminate the bourgeoisie by classing them as intelligentsia,
restricting their rations, and putting their children at the foot
of the overcrowded educational list. They also proscribed the
kulak, the able, hardheaded, hardfisted farmer who was richer than
his neighbors and liked to see them poorer than himself. Him they
rudely took by the shoulders and threw destitute into the lane.
There were plausible reasons for this beginning of selection in
population; for the moral outlook of the bourgeoisie and the kulaks
was dangerously antisocial. But the results were disastrous. The
bourgeoisie contained the professional class and the organizing
business class. Without professional men and business organizers
nothing could be done in the industries; and the hope that picked
members of the proletariat could take up professional and
organizing work on the strength of their native talent in
sufficient numbers was crushingly disappointed. When the kulak was
thrown out of his farm, and his farming ability paralyzed, food ran
short. Very soon the kulak had to be thrown back into his farm and
told to carry on until his hour had come; and a pleasant convention
was established whereby all educated persons, however obviously
ladies or gentlemen, who were willing to assure the authorities
that their fathers had "worked on the land with their hands" were
accepted as genuine proletarians, and transferred from the infamous
category of intelligentsia to the honourable one of "the
intellectual proletariat." Even Lenin and his colleagues, all
ultra-bourgeois (otherwise they would never have so absurdly
overestimated the intellectual resources of the proletariat and
been so contemptuous of the pretension of their own class to be
indispensable), allowed their parents to be described as
hornyhanded cultivators of the soil. The pretence has now become a
standing joke; but you will still come up against it if you accuse
any Russian of being a lady or gentleman.
INCOMPATIBILITY OF PEASANTRY WITH MODERN CIVILIZATION
These, however, are merely expedients of transition. The Russian
proletariat is now growing its own professional and organizing
class; and the ex-bourgeois is dying out, after seeing his children
receive a sound Communist education and being lectured by them on
his oldfashioned prejudices. And the planners of the Soviet State
have no time to bother about moribund questions; for they
are confronted with the new and overwhelming necessity for
exterminating the peasants, who still exist in formidable numbers.
The notion that a civilized State can be made out of any sort of
human material is one of our old Radical delusions. As to building
Communism with such trash as the Capitalist system produces it is
out of the question. For a Communist Utopia we need a population
of Utopians; and Utopians do not grow wild on the bushes nor are
they to be picked up in the slums: they have to be cultivated very
carefully and expensively. Peasants will not do; yet without the
peasants the Communists could never have captured the Russian
Revolution. Nominally it was the Soviets of peasants and soldiers
who backed Lenin and saved Communism when all Western Europe set on
him like a pack of hounds on a fox. But as all the soldiers were
peasants, and all the peasants hungry for property, the military
element only added to the peasants' cry of Give us land, the
soldiers' cry of Give us peace. Lenin said, in effect, Take the
land; and if feudally minded persons obstruct you, exterminate
them; but do not burn their houses, as you will need them to live
in. And it was the resultant legions of petty landed proprietors
that made Lenin's position impregnable, and provided Trotsky
and Stalin with the Red soldiers who defeated the counter-
revolutionists of 1918. For the counter-revolution, in which we,
to our eternal shame, took part (England sets the example of
revolution and then attacks all other countries which presume to
follow it), meant bringing the old landlords back; and the peasant
fought against that as the mercenaries and conscripts of the
Capitalist armies would not fight in favour of it.
A PEASANT VICTORY IS A VICTORY FOR PRIVATE PROPERTY
So far so good for Lenin; but the war against the counter-
revolutionists, when it ended in victory for the peasant
proprietor, was really a victory for private property, and was
therefore succeeded by a fiercer struggle between the fanatically
Communist Government and the fiercely individualist peasant
proprietor, who wanted the produce of his plot for himself, and
had no notion of pooling it with anybody, least of all with the
urban proletarians who seemed like another species to him. Left
to themselves the moujiks would have reproduced Capitalist
civilization at its American worst in ten years. Thus the most
urgent task before the victorious Communist Government was the
extermination of the moujik; and yet the moujik, being still the
goose that laid the golden eggs, could not be exterminated
summarily without incidentally exterminating the whole Russian
nation.
The way out of this deadlock was obvious enough, though very expensive and tedious. You can exterminate any human class not only by summary violence but by bringing up its children to be different. In the case of the Russian peasantry the father lives in a lousy kennel, at no man's call but his own, and extracts a subsistence by primitive methods from a strip of land on which a tractor could hardly turn even if he could afford such a luxury, but which is his very own. His book is a book of Nature, from which all wisdom can be gathered by those who have been taught to read it by due practice on printed books; but he has not been so practised, and for cultural purposes has to be classed as ignorant, though he knows things that university professors do not know. He is brutalized by excessive muscular labor; he is dirty; his freedom from civilized control leaves him so unprotected from the tyranny of Nature that it becomes evident to his children that the highly regulated people in the nearest collectivist farm, where thousands of acres are cultivated by dozens of tractors, and nobody can put his foot on one of the acres or his hand on one of the tractors and say "This is my own to do what I like with," are better fed and housed, nicer, and much more leisured, and consequently free, than he ever is.