This is an archive copy of wikilivres.ca as of 18 February 2017 (from the WikiTeam dump). The original site is closed.

The Canadian Forum/Trade and Industry/1921-01

Free texts and images.
Jump to navigation Jump to search
Review:Walpole:The Captives (S.H.H.) The Canadian Forum/Trade and Industry
1921-01
written by G. E. Jackson
A series of articles begun in October 1920.




Trade and Industry
September 1920 Oct. 1920 Nov. 1920 Dec. 1920 Dec. 1919
Wholesale Prices1
(Michell)
254.5 242.1 233.1 221.6 259.2
Family Budget
(Labour Gazette)
$26.38 $26.46 $26.13 . . . . $23.49
Volume of Employment2
(Employment Service of Canada)
108.1 107.5 104.3 99.0 . . . .
Average Price of Twelve Canadian Securities3
(Michell)
116.6 113.3 108.4 106.7 132.0

_______

1 Base ( = 100) refers to the period 1900—1909.
2 Base ( = 100) refers to the week ending January 17th, 1920. Subsequent figures refer to the second week in each month.
3 The following common stock quotations are included: — Canadian Bank of Commerce, C.P.R., Dominion Textile, Dominion Bridge Company, Consumers' Gas, Shawinigan Light and Power, Penman's, Russell Motors, Bell Telephone, Canadian General Electric, Lake of the Woods Milling, and Canada Steamships.


'The fall in wholesale prices is at last being faintly reflected in retail fluctuations. The Family Budget published in December by the Labour Gazette shows a decline of about 3% in retail food prices. This is offset in part by a further rise in rent and fuel. Retail prices inevitably lag behind wholesale prices in a situation like the present. They rose more slowly than wholesale prices in the war; we need not be surprised if they fall more slowly for some time to come.

The Index of Employment, however, moves very rapidly. Trade Unions with a membership of 215,000 report that at the end of October 6% of their members were out of work. Since then, the contraction of employment, as shown by returns made to the Department of Labour by 5,000 Canadian firms, has exceeded 8%. We cannot, of course, add these two figures together, and say positively that 14% of the wage earners of Canada were out of work in the fortnight before Christmas. But at a conservative estimate, considerably more than 10% were then unemployed; and with the close of the Christmas season, the proportion is likely to increase.

Speaking to an American audience in the last week of the Old Year, the Canadian Minister of Labour was as cheerful as the circumstances permitted. He went so far as to say that the present depression has not up to now been more severe than that of 1913-14. The statement is worth investigation.

In 1913-14 there were no trustworthy records of employment in Canada. Such records as we have of that period were collected in 1915 by the Ontario Commission on Unemployment. Its terms of reference related only to Ontario; but for that Province it gathered data from more than 1,600 employers which, while not exactly comparable with the present information of the Federal Department of Labour (since the records of the Commission related only to manufacturing industries), are more nearly comparable than any other independent records.

April, 1913, was the month in which employment reached its peak. The peak in 1920 was reached in the month of July. We are thus able to compare the contraction in employment in the five months following April, 1913, with that which occurred in the last five months of last year.

In the first period, the decline was a little less than 5%. In the last five months of last year, the decline was almost exactly 10%. It appears at first sight, therefore, that despite the Senator's assurance to the contrary the present depression has affected the volume of employment about twice as severely as its predecessor.

On the other hand, a comparison of the same period in each year reveals a different result. In 1913, the volume of employment did not seriously begin to decline, until two months after the peak was reached and passed. Between July 1913 and December of that year, the decline in employment was equal to 9½% of all manufacturing operatives covered by the returns. Thus there is no marked difference between our experience in the last depression, and unemployment at the present time. Indeed if we had reason to believe that manufacturing was at present less affected than our other industrial activities, we might be tempted to think that the present is the more hopeful situation. Unfortunately, there is no good reason for any such opinion. Even at the end of October, when only 6% of all organized workers in Canada were out of employment, the percentage of organized manufacturing operatives who were out of work, as shown by the returns made to Senator Robertson's Department by 384 Trade Unions, was nearly 12%. On the evidence it appears that, if anything, conditions are rather worse to-day than they were at this time seven years ago. But the difference, if it exists, cannot be very important.

It is interesting to note the fluctuations that followed in 1914. After a rally during February, March and April, employment declined in May to a new low level. At this time, the number of workers employed in manufactures in Ontario was 13% below the high level of the preceding May. The decline was accelerated by the outbreak of war in August; and only with the demand for munitions in 1915 did revival begin.

G. E. Jackson