This is an archive copy of wikilivres.ca as of 18 February 2017 (from the WikiTeam dump). The original site is closed.

The Canadian Forum/Trade and Industry/1921-04

Free texts and images.
Jump to navigation Jump to search

Review:Train:As It Was In The Beginning The Canadian Forum/Trade and Industry
1921-04
written by G. E. Jackson
A series of articles begun in October 1920.



Trade and Industry
_______
Dec. 1920 Jan. 1921 Feb. 1921 Mar. 1921 Mar. 1920
Wholesale Prices1
(Michell)
221.6 212.6 198.7 190.0 287.6
Family Budget
(Labour Gazette)
$25.67 $25.30 $24.85 . . . . $25.01
Volume of Employment2
(Employment Service of Canada)
99.0 90.5 89.0 87.2 101.2
Average Price of Twelve Canadian Securities3
(Michell)
106.7 109.9 110.3 109.0 124.4

_______

1 Base ( = 100) refers to the period 1900—1909.
2 Base ( = 100) refers to the week ending January 17th, 1920. Subsequent figures refer to the second week in each month.
3 The following common stock quotations are included: — Canadian Bank of Commerce, C.P.R., Dominion Textile, Dominion Bridge Company, Consumers' Gas, Shawinigan Light and Power, Penman's, Russell Motors, Bell Telephone, Canadian General Electric, Lake of the Woods Milling, and Canada Steamships.


THE financial pages of the daily papers are now beginning to reflect the opinion voiced in these columns a month ago, that deflation has proceeded more rapidly in some other countries than in Canada. We recorded in our March issue the fact that in the last ten months prices have fallen considerably faster in the United States than in our own markets.

This is simply another way of saying that the purchasing power of the American dollar has been rising considerably faster than the purchasing power of the Canadian dollar. For a fall in the prices of goods (measured in money) is exactly the same as a rise in the purchasing power of money.

Now so long as the purchasing power of the American dollar is higher than that of the Canadian dollar, certain reactions will follow which we cannot ignore.

It is doubtful whether these reactions are everywhere understood. For instance the Minister of Finance has recently been advising the women of Canada to buy their goods at home. He has been criticized for seeming to suggest that our exchange difficulties are partly due to the preference of Canadian women for goods of American make.

Whether he really believes this or not, only Sir Henry Drayton knows. But it is important to us all, men as well as women, that he should not believe it. For the expression of such a belief will do more than ruffle the feelings of feminine voters.

If he believes this he will naturally look for an improvement in American exchange as a result of [p.222] arbitrary interference with the balance of trade. And it is probable that the roots of the problem go much deeper than this.

Let us for a moment imagine our exchange difficulty with the United States at an end. In other words, that instead of having (as at present) to pay about $1.13 in our own money for an American dollar we could change our currency at par.

Under these circumstances, since the purchasing power of the American dollar is higher than that of the Canadian, it would be greatly to the interest of the ordinary Canadian to make his purchases as far as possible with American dollars in the American market. In other words, the balance of trade would inevitably be in favour of the United States, and American exchange would inevitably turn once more against us.

It is difficult to see how the old par of exchange can permanently be restored, except by restoring the domestic purchasing power of the Canadian dollar to the same level as the domestic purchasing power of the American. And this can only occur in one of two ways: either through a considerable rise in the level of American commodity prices, or through a considerable further fall in prices here.

The former of these alternatives is obviously beyond our control; the latter may be subject to control. And this, not by the arbitrary decree of a price-fixing court like the Board of Commerce, but by a frank recognition that the value of the dollar, like that of everything it pays for, depends on demand and supply.

The paper dollars that we handle were, until the war, "equivalent to gold." That is to say, any one could exchange gold against dollars; and dollars against gold. The banks were directed by law daily to redeem their own notes with Dominion notes as they came in for payment. The amount of the bank note issue was in any case limited by law; and in order to get more Dominion notes it was necessary to deposit an equivalent amount of gold with the Dominion Government.

In other words, the quantity of gold available set limits on the volume of our paper money. The supply of dollar bills was regulated automatically.

With the beginning of the war emergency provisions were inevitable. In face of a possible panic an elastic currency had to be provided. Supplies of gold were limited, and might prove quite inadequate. On August 10th, 1914, the redemption in gold of Dominion notes was suspended. On August 22nd the Finance Act of 1914 was passed. Issues of Dominion notes to the Banks were authorized, to bear interest at not less than 5%, against deposits of approved securities.

Automatic regulation of the currency thus ceased. Dominion notes were fruitful and multiplied exceedingly. The average monthly circulation in 1913 was $117,000,000. In 1920 it was more than $300,000,000. And as the supply of paper dollars increased, their value, that is, their purchasing power, naturally fell.

Herein lies the root of our exchange problem. Restore the purchasing power at home of the Canadian dollar and the balance of trade will right itself. Neglect to do so and nothing will permanently right it.

Not by removing the mote from the eye of the Canadian housewife will Sir Henry Drayton save the State. His task is fundamentally: How to reduce the volume of our paper currency? It is one which he cannot possibly evade. But it involves other issues so serious and wide, that any man might hesitate before it. He will not find it easy.

G. E. Jackson.