This is an archive copy of wikilivres.ca as of 18 February 2017 (from the WikiTeam dump). The original site is closed.
The Canadian Forum/Trade and Industry/1921-06
| The Canadian Forum 1921-06 written by G. E. Jackson |
| A series of articles begun in October 1920. This article began on p.284, and continued on misplaced p. 282 instead of 286. |
Owing to the possibility that there may be a printers' strike in June The Canadian Forum is compelled this month to go to press a week before the usual time. It is, therefore, impossible to bring up-to-date the table which has so far been presented every month at the head of this column. We hope that in the July number the figures for June and July may be published as usual.
In a series of economic upheavals such as have been seen in the last ten years the maintenance of the standard of living of the worker is a matter of the first importance. The labour interests have long maintained that the rise in the cost of living has outstripped the rise in wages. From their standpoint the balance can only be restored (and the standard of life of the worker be maintained), either by a rise in wages to meet the cost of living, or by a fall in the cost of living which is not accompanied by falling wages. On the other hand, the business interests maintain with equal conviction that normal conditions of industry can only be restored by cutting down production costs and that this involves an inevitable fall in wages.
Beyond question, both these claims are quite sincere. The root of the trouble lies in a divergence between the movements of wholesale and retail prices. There is no doubt that wholesale prices rose faster till June, 1920 than the retail prices of most goods required for domestic consumption. There is also no doubt that since then the fall in retail prices has been considerably less than the fall in wholesale prices. The business man naturally compares his wage bill with the prices of the things he sells, which have fallen very quickly. The worker compares his wages with the prices of the things he has to buy, which have fallen very slowly.
Ordinarily it is impossible to test either contention by reference to facts. We have not had the data which would make possible a comparison of the wages paid in Canadian industry, between one year and the next. But at the moment we are in a singularly fortunate position. The Department of Labour at Ottawa, which is indefatigable in its work of useful industrial research, has recently published a report of great value,[1] whose results can be compared directly with the Family Budget tables, published from month to month in the Labour Gazette. No trade union official, no large employer of labour, no head of a government department can afford to be without this document.
It may be useful to readers of this page if the facts are briefly summarized. The Department of Labour has studied seven classes of employees in the building trades, five in the metal trades, two in the printing trades, one in the street railways, six on the steam railways,[2] thirty-five samples of common factory labour, seventy-two samples in miscellaneous factory trades, and fifteen samples in lumbering. Expressing the wages of 1913 in each case as 100, the change from year to year is calculated both in hourly and in weekly rates. The difference between changes in hourly rates and in weekly rates is often quite considerable since the great increase which has occurred in hourly rates of wages has been accompanied almost uniformly during the last few years by a reduction in the working day. To simplify the tables published in the Labour Gazette we print here a comparison between the weekly money rates of wages paid in Canada during 1913 and 1920.
1913 1920 _____ _____ Bldg. Trades 100.0 171.9 Metal Trades 100.0 189.3 Printing Trades 100.0 181.7 Street Rlwys. 100.0 179.1 Lumbering 100.0 191.4 Common Labour in Factories 100.0 198.3 Miscellaneous Factory Trades 100.0 192.9
The average increase in weekly money rates of wages for the seven classes of labour here studied is 86.4%. Wholesale prices rose considerably more than this in the period from 1913 to 1920; but here we are concerned with the retail prices which the worker had to pay. Now it is possible that the cost of living has not changed in exactly the same degree for any two groups of workers. If one group has to spend an unduly large proportion of its wage on food, while another has to spend an unduly large proportion on rent, then a change in the retail price of foodstuffs and in rents for both of them, will not affect them in the same degree. If foodstuffs have risen faster than rentals, the former group will feel the change the more intensely and vice versa.
But while it is impossible to state for the workers of Canada as a whole that in any period the cost of living rose in a certain definite proportion, there is no reason to doubt that the figures presented from [p.282 (286)] month to month in the Labour Gazette under the heading of Family Budget represent with a good deal of precision what has been occurring. The facts from which the Family Budget is compiled are collected in sixty Canadian cities and the Budget itself probably represents fairly well the consumption of an efficiently conducted family in the higher ranks of labour.
The cost of goods in the Family Budget during 1913 was $14.02 per week. The cost of the same goods in 1920 was $25.88 per week. In other words (if the list may be trusted) the retail cost of living for a worker's family had risen by about 85% during the seven years under review. This coincides closely with the rise in wages of about 86% which we have already noticed.
One is tempted to conclude from this that the standard of life of the wage earner was well maintained during and after the war. Particularly noticeable is the increase in the wage paid to common labour in factories (98.3%), which is considerably greater than the presumed increase in the retail cost of living. It is curious that the most conspicuous rise in wages occurred in what is perhaps the least organized group of workers.
But it would be rash to conclude from these figures that the standard of life of the worker was actually so well maintained. The facts in the Family Budget relate only to foodstuffs, laundry starch, fuel, lighting and rent. In particular they do not include necessary expenditure on clothing. Now the war made demands on the clothing trades which were particularly heavy. In the period of rising prices the price of textile products rose almost half as fast again as prices in general. If the Family Budget included an allowance for expenditure on clothing, there is no doubt that the rise in the retail cost of living would have been distinctly more than 85%. Although some were earning considerable sums for overtime it is very improbable that, even before the present depression began, the workers of Canada, as a whole were as well ofif as they had been in 1913.
- G. E. Jackson.
_____
- 1. ↑ Wages and Hours of Labour in Canada 1901 to 1920. Department of Labour, Canada.
- 2. ↑ But it did not secure a weekly rate for these.