This is an archive copy of wikilivres.ca as of 18 February 2017 (from the WikiTeam dump). The original site is closed.

The Canadian Forum/Trade and Industry/1920-12

Free texts and images.
Jump to navigation Jump to search

Domestic Discontent - letter The Canadian Forum/Trade and Industry
1920-12
written by G. E. Jackson
A series of articles begun in October 1920.



Trade and Industry
August 1920 Sept. 1920 Oct. 1920 Nov. 1920 Nov. 1919
Wholesale Prices1
(Michell)
274.4 254.5 242.1 233.1 257.1
Family Budget
(Labour Gazette)
$26.60 $26.38 $26.46 . . . . $22.99
Volume of Employment2
(Employment Service of Canada)
107.9 108.1 107.5 104.3 . . . .
Average Price of Twelve Canadian Securities3
(Michell)
122.9 116.6 113.3 108.4 134.5

_______

1 Base ( = 100) refers to the period 1900—1909.
2 Base ( = 100) refers to the week ending January 17th, 1920. Subsequent figures refer to the second week in each month.
3 The following common stock quotations are included: — Canadian Bank of Commerce, C.P.R., Dominion Textile, Dominion Bridge Company, Consumers' Gas, Shawinigan Light and Power, Penman's, Russell Motors, Bell Telephone, Canadian General Electric, Lake of the Woods Milling, and Canada Steamships.

November has been the most serious month for the people of Canada since the fall in prices began last June. The figures for the middle of November show a contraction in employment of more than 3% during the previous month and will probably be followed by a further contraction in December.

How widespread unemployment is at present, we do not know. We have no returns from Trade Unions later than the September figures. The percentage of organized workers unemployed in all Canada at the end of September 1920 was 3.25 — a comparatively small one. But there was serious local unemployment in certain industries and places. In British Columbia one-seventh of the organized workers in the metal trades were out of work. In Ontario almost a quarter of the organized glass bottle blowers were unemployed, and more than a quarter of organized workers in the leather trades. The returns from Quebec showed the most serious condition of all, and indicated that half the organized clothing workers of that provmce were also idle.

Uppermost in the minds of business men is the question, How long can the present situation last?

It is one which in varying degrees is constantly repeating itself. But the present fall is almost without precedent. Professor Michell estimates that in the six months between May and November, wholesale prices declined here by nearly 22%. This compares as follows with the price movement in Canada, the United Kingdom and the United States during two previous depressions. The years 1893 and 1907 have been taken as bases tor comparison.

Canada United Kingdom United States
(Dept. of Labour) (Economist) (Bradstreet's)
1893 100.0 100.0 100.0
1894 93.5 94.2 89.1
1895 92.9 91.0 85.8
1896 87.1 88.2 78.8
1907 100.0 100.0 100.0
1908 95.7 97.3 90.0
1909 96.5 98.5 95.7
1910 98.4 102.9 101.0

In no case was the initial break in wholesale prices comparable with that of 1920: but even after 1893 and 1907, recovery was slow. In the former case prices continued for four years to decline. It is clear that though there may be a temporary recovery in wholesale prices we have no warrant for supposing that a permanent recovery is at hand. Business men generally must face the prospect of an unsteady downward sag of prices for a considerable time,

Why has the decline been so rapid?

A complicating condition of to-day is inflation of the world's currency. For the true parallel to this we must go back far beyond 1893. The present state is more likely to resemble conditions in the United States after the Civil War and in the United Kingdom after Waterloo.

The Aldrich Report has measured the fluctuations after 1865, which is here taken as a base,

Wholesale Prices
United States
1865 l00.0
1866 88.1
1867 79.9
1868 74.0

During the Napoleonic Wars prices reached their maximum in 1809, and declined till 1815. The rise after 1815 closely resembles that which followed the Armistice two years ago. Reaction came and the course of prices was as follows:

Wholesale Prices
United Kingdom
(Jevons)
1818 100.0
1819 85.0
1820 78.2
1821 71.4

Only the barest hints can be gleaned from this look backwards. We may meet with better luck than our forbears under similar conditions. But only those who face facts squarely can claim to have deserved it.

G. E. Jackson